get_members() isn't returning emails for all users, despite showing up in the GIthub UI

[brendan-snyk]

Hello,
I'm going a full organization get_members() and it's returning all the users. The problem is, i'm trying to tie the 'login' (their github username) over to email, specifically their corporate email address. However, most of our members are returning an empty email field. Despite showing in the GIthub Web UI.

Any ideas here?

[brendan-snyk]

My code is as simple as:

from github import Github
access_token = <redacted>

# Initialize GitHub
g = Github(access_token)

# Name of the organization
org_name = 'test'

# Get the organization
org = g.get_organization(org_name)

# List all teams in the organization
members = org.get_members()
for member in members:
        print(f"- {member.login}")
        print(f"- {member.email}")

[gjabouley-invn]

Hello

in order to get the mail from API, user needs to configure its email address as public.

in https://github.com/settings/profile

Needs to select in the drop down list the corporate email address, then hit save button

then you can access email using API

[brendan-snyk]

I understand what you are saying there, however, if we do this:

url = "https://api.github.com/graphql"
h = {"Authorization": "bearer " + token}
    ext = 'externalIdentities(first:1, userName: "' + email + '") {'
    q1 = """
    query{
    organization(login: "snyk") {
     samlIdentityProvider {
"""
    q2 = """
         edges {
           node {
             user {
               login
             }
           }
         }
       }
     }
   }

 }
"""
    final = q1 + ext + q2
    r = requests.post(url, json={"query": final}, headers=h).json()
    edges = safeget(
        r, "data", "organization", "samlIdentityProvider", "externalIdentities", "edges"
    )

It indeed works. Can the non-GraphQL endpoint match the data returned by GraphQL endpoint?

[gjabouley-invn]

i'm not GraphQL fluent, but it looks like you are reading data from the samlIdentityProvider endpoint.
It might be different from the public email address API data accessed when calling member.email

[Arlington1985]

I am running the following code snippet, it doesn't get me any member

from github import Github
import os

github = Github(
    base_url="https://GITHUB_ENDPOINT/api/v3",
    login_or_token=os.environ["GITHUB_TOKEN"],
)

organization=github.get_organization("MYORG")

members=[]
# List all teams in the organization
members = organization.get_members()
for member in members:
        print(f"- {member.login}")
        print(f"- {member.email}")

But running with GH CLI returns

gh api \                            
  -H "Accept: application/vnd.github+json" \
  -H "X-GitHub-Api-Version: 2022-11-28" \
  /orgs/MYORG/members

[gjabouley-invn]

Your snippet works fine, using an access token with following permission: admin:org, repo, user, workflow
I just removed the base_url="https://GITHUB_ENDPOINT/api/v3", line