Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

New / Updated Weather Icons #541

Closed
SaltySeaDog opened this issue Jul 27, 2015 · 22 comments
Closed

New / Updated Weather Icons #541

SaltySeaDog opened this issue Jul 27, 2015 · 22 comments
Assignees
Labels
Icon Request Request for a specific icon.

Comments

@SaltySeaDog
Copy link

Hello,

I updated some of your weather icons to match the latest google spec. In particular in regards to rounded ends. I also added some new ones as well.

https://www.dropbox.com/sh/zzephzko5ibxahh/AACyE145kvU3qQhan90R1GGPa?dl=0

weather_icons2

@CoDEmanX
Copy link

You need to use the share feature to generate a proper Dropbox link, the one you posted will only work for you.

@SaltySeaDog
Copy link
Author

Added 3 new icons: tornado, blustery (the old windy with some flattening) and cold, which can also be used for #500

@Templarian
Copy link
Owner

I'll get these imported this weekend.

Yea, making the weather ones I knew the rounded terminals were bad idea but felt they looked odd. Guess it's best to just follow the guidelines rather than detouring for a few specific icons.

@Templarian
Copy link
Owner

@SaltySeaDog The contributor system is currently down as it is being updated, but if you email ([redacted] I can forward you the contributor getting started steps.

@Templarian Templarian added Contribution Icon request has a contribution from either the team or someone else. Bug A bug in an icon glyph or a first-party library. labels Jul 28, 2015
@CoDEmanX
Copy link

It looks a little weird indeed, especially haze... A rough look and feel.

I like the idea of tornado, but it's hardly recognizable at larger sizes. Maybe some of the lines could be connected by curves, similar to the curves seen in blustery? (U-turn)
//edit: doesn't really work: tornado

The raindrops might be more legible at small sizes if the upper point was moved further up. It's hard to distinguish from hail otherwise.

@SaltySeaDog
Copy link
Author

(Ooops really sorry, hit totally the wrong button).

Haze is the one I'm least proud off but its difficult to find any adjustments that really work. Its similar to the foggy one, in that its hard to convey a haze in a monochrome.

For the rain, I found that it I was fine with the light rain but really struggled to distinguish easily when it was the heavy rain icon. I was thinking maybe something like this:
rain-alt

@Templarian
Copy link
Owner

The haze one is nice, can't think of another way it would be represented. Filling in the cloud doesn't fit well with the others, so I think the way it is now is best.

@CoDEmanX
Copy link

Original haze + 2 variants (sun beams moved slightly up to improve separation of sun and haze, wider haze in the last):

weather-haze5 weather-haze weather-haze2

Original rain + variant with exaggerated rain drops:
weather-rain weather-rain2

@Templarian
Copy link
Owner

The 3rd haze one is a subtle, but nice change. Can you link the SVG for that one.

i think the current rain icon is fine.

@CoDEmanX
Copy link

weather-haze-2 A) 3rd from above
weather-haze-7 B) with sun beam strokes in original position (margin only ~1.5px between beams and haze)
weather-haze-6 C) just to see how it would look with Templarian's beams

A) https://www.dropbox.com/s/h0g9sgckh81xnst/weather-haze-2.svg?dl=0
B) https://www.dropbox.com/s/1zuegz8p7l4qgn5/weather-haze-7.svg?dl=0

We shouldn't forget about the sunset icons by the way!
weather-sunset 1px border margin
https://www.dropbox.com/s/s62q7pub6ce769p/weather-sunset.svg?dl=0
weather-sunset2 Closer beams (2px border margin)
https://www.dropbox.com/s/zh4c50knbvbyw10/weather-sunset2.svg?dl=0
weather-sunset3 better distinction of beams and water reflections, but inconsistent with below up/down icons https://www.dropbox.com/s/3nn3itorasmmbu8/weather-sunset3.svg?dl=0

weather-sunset-up https://www.dropbox.com/s/lxr3xy2qknx2fuy/weather-sunset-up.svg?dl=0
weather-sunset-down https://www.dropbox.com/s/ysm1jskyf0tdmiv/weather-sunset-down.svg?dl=0
The chevrons seem a bit blurry, maybe there's a better way to do them (i.e. less on pixel). The beams could be moved outwards, like in 1st weather-sunset icon above...

@CoDEmanX CoDEmanX mentioned this issue Aug 5, 2015
@SaltySeaDog
Copy link
Author

The first haze is definitely better.

How does that sunset look with filled in sun by the way?

@CoDEmanX
Copy link

CoDEmanX commented Aug 5, 2015

Good point:

weather-sunset-filled
weather-sunset2-filled
weather-sunset-down-filled
weather-sunset-up-filled

@SaltySeaDog
Copy link
Author

I don't know about you but the alignment rays seem a little odd to me. the horizontal rays seem to not in the middle.

@CoDEmanX
Copy link

CoDEmanX commented Aug 5, 2015

Yeah I had to move them and tried to keep them on a virtual circle line, but it may look unbalanced after all. Do you want to fine tune them?

@SaltySeaDog
Copy link
Author

weather-sunrise
weather-sunset
weather-sunset-alt

It was a lot harder to do that than I expected

@CoDEmanX
Copy link

Looks good to me! 3 beams are plenty enough.

I tried to do a snow flake btw: #500 (comment)

The exclamation mark is optional, I couldn't make it work at 20x20px though.

@CoDEmanX
Copy link

Oh, and maybe you could try 3 beams on the haze icon too? Or at least check if the 5 strokes are well-aligned, because I moved them.

@CoDEmanX
Copy link

@SaltySeaDog Do you happen to have the source files still around and can share them?

@PeterShaggyNoble PeterShaggyNoble added the Icon Request Request for a specific icon. label Apr 24, 2018
@PeterShaggyNoble PeterShaggyNoble added this to the Version 2.4.xx milestone Apr 24, 2018
@Templarian Templarian modified the milestones: Version 2.4.xx, Backlog Apr 29, 2018
@mririgoyen
Copy link
Sponsor Collaborator

@SaltySeaDog We cannot add these without the source SVGs. Can you please provide them?

@mririgoyen mririgoyen removed Contribution Icon request has a contribution from either the team or someone else. High Priority Issue is a high priority. Bug A bug in an icon glyph or a first-party library. labels Nov 25, 2018
@mririgoyen
Copy link
Sponsor Collaborator

Removing the Contribution label since the original source files were not provided for us to include.

@mririgoyen mririgoyen self-assigned this Nov 25, 2018
@mririgoyen
Copy link
Sponsor Collaborator

After an internal discussion, we've decided we're happy with the current style of the weather icons. That being said, any new additions from your list of contributions should aim to follow the style (for example, the sun rays).

Out of the original posting, the following icons were provided:

  • weather-blustery - Already included as weather-windy
  • weather-cloudy - Already included as weather-cloudy
  • weather-cold - Already included as snowflake, but could be a snowflake variation
  • weather-fog - Already included as weather-fog
  • weather-hail - Already included as weather-hail
  • weather-haze
  • weather-hot
  • weather-night - Already included as weather-night
  • weather-overcast - Is a filled version of weather-cloudy
  • weather-partial-night
  • weather-partial - Already included as weather-partlycloudy
  • weather-rain-light - Already included as weather-rainy
  • weather-rain - Already included as weather-pouring
  • weather-severe-storm
  • weather-showers - Already included as weather-pouring
  • weather-snow - Already included as weather-snowy
  • weather-storm - Already included as weather-lightning
  • weather-sunny - Already included as weather-sunny
  • weather-sunrise - Already included as weather-sunset-up
  • weather-sunset-alt - Already included as weather-sunset-down
  • weather-sunset - Already included as weather-sunset
  • weather-tornado
  • weather-windy - Already included as weather-windy

That leaves this issue wanting to add the following icons to the library:

  • snowflake-variation
  • weather-haze
  • weather-hot
  • weather-cloudy
    • Rename the current weather-cloudy to weather-cloudy-outline
  • weather-cloudy-alert
  • weather-night-partlycloudy
  • weather-tornado

This was referenced Nov 26, 2018
@mririgoyen
Copy link
Sponsor Collaborator

mririgoyen commented Nov 26, 2018

Now that we've inventoried this issue, we've created and combined it with another master weather-related issue since there were two very large issues regarding weather icons. We'll track the work of the addition of the additional 6 icons from this issue there. Please follow issue #3736 to keep up-to-date with the progress. Thank you for your contribution.

@PeterShaggyNoble PeterShaggyNoble removed this from the Backlog milestone Jan 29, 2019
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Icon Request Request for a specific icon.
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

5 participants