Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Arturia Minifuse 2 (and probably any other using SplitPCM macro) - lost sample rate range on each in/out (and forced to 48000) #333

Closed
kmarty opened this issue Jun 29, 2023 · 3 comments
Closed

Arturia Minifuse 2 (and probably any other using SplitPCM macro) - lost sample rate range on each in/out (and forced to 48000) #333

kmarty opened this issue Jun 29, 2023 · 3 comments

Comments

@kmarty
Copy link

kmarty commented Jun 29, 2023 •
edited

Hi,
I have Arturia MiniFuse 2 card allowing playback/capture sample rate in range 44100 - 192000. But using channel name (e.g. Mic/Line/Inst 1 (L), Main Output L/R) created by UCM, it offers 48000 only (and in case of playback, it offers S15_LE only).

Looks like something is lost when SplitPCM macro is used or so (I have absolutely no idea what's going on here).

Is there any possibility to make it work as it should?

=================================
/proc/asound/card4/stream0 output:

ARTURIA MiniFuse 2 at usb-0000:16:00.0-6.2, high speed : USB Audio

Playback:
  Status: Stop
  Interface 1
    Altset 1
    Format: S32_LE
    Channels: 4
    Endpoint: 0x01 (1 OUT) (ASYNC)
    Rates: 44100, 48000, 88200, 96000, 176400, 192000
    Data packet interval: 125 us
    Bits: 24
    Channel map: FL FR FC LFE
    Sync Endpoint: 0x81 (1 IN)
    Sync EP Interface: 1
    Sync EP Altset: 1
    Implicit Feedback Mode: No
  Interface 1
    Altset 2
    Format: S16_LE
    Channels: 4
    Endpoint: 0x01 (1 OUT) (ASYNC)
    Rates: 44100, 48000, 88200, 96000, 176400, 192000
    Data packet interval: 125 us
    Bits: 16
    Channel map: FL FR FC LFE
    Sync Endpoint: 0x81 (1 IN)
    Sync EP Interface: 1
    Sync EP Altset: 2
    Implicit Feedback Mode: No

Capture:
  Status: Stop
  Interface 2
    Altset 1
    Format: S32_LE
    Channels: 4
    Endpoint: 0x82 (2 IN) (ASYNC)
    Rates: 44100, 48000, 88200, 96000, 176400, 192000
    Data packet interval: 125 us
    Bits: 24
    Channel map: FL FR FC LFE

alsaucm -c hw:4 dump text output:

Verb.HiFi {
	Comment "Default Alsa Profile"
	Device.Line1 {
		Comment "Main Output L/R"
		Values {
			CaptureCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
			PlaybackCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
			PlaybackChannels 2
			PlaybackPCM "_ucm0001.minifuse12_stereo_out:M2,0,0,1"
			PlaybackPriority 300
		}
	}
	Device.Line2 {
		Comment "Loopback L/R"
		Values {
			CaptureCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
			CaptureChannels 2
			CapturePCM "_ucm0001.minifuse12_stereo_in:M2,0,2,3"
			CapturePriority 200
			PlaybackCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
			PlaybackChannels 2
			PlaybackPCM "_ucm0001.minifuse12_stereo_out:M2,0,2,3"
			PlaybackPriority 200
		}
	}
	Device.Line3 {
		Comment "Stereo Input 1+2 L/R"
		ConflictingDevices [
			Mic2,
			Mic1
		]
		Values {
			CaptureCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
			CaptureChannels 2
			CapturePCM "_ucm0001.minifuse12_stereo_in:M2,0,0,1"
			CapturePriority 100
			PlaybackCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
		}
	}
	Device.Mic1 {
		Comment "Mic/Line/Inst 1 (L)"
		ConflictingDevices [
			Line3
		]
		Values {
			CaptureCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
			CaptureChannels 1
			CapturePCM "_ucm0001.minifuse12_mono_in:M2,0,0"
			CapturePriority 400
			PlaybackCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
		}
	}
	Device.Mic2 {
		Comment "Mic/Line/Inst 2 (R)"
		ConflictingDevices [
			Line3
		]
		Values {
			CaptureCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
			CaptureChannels 1
			CapturePCM "_ucm0001.minifuse12_mono_in:M2,0,1"
			CapturePriority 300
			PlaybackCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
		}
	}
}
Verb.Direct {
	Comment "Direct MiniFuse 2"
	Device.Direct {
		Comment "Direct MiniFuse 2"
		Values {
			CaptureCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
			CaptureChannels 4
			CapturePCM "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
			CapturePriority 1000
			PlaybackCTL "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
			PlaybackChannels 4
			PlaybackPCM "_ucm0001.hw:M2"
			PlaybackPriority 1000
		}
	}
}

Pipewire debug log "spa.alsa:D" excerpts (I have no idea how to get this elsewhere, but it matches to offered reality):

[I][12125.973616] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  618 spa_alsa_open()] 0x562ee6e95448: ALSA device open '_ucm0001.minifuse12_mono_in:M2,0,0' capture
[I][12125.993003] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  568 probe_pitch_ctl()] minifuse12_mono_in:M2,0,0 could not find ctl device: No such file or directory
[D][12125.993047] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1048 debug_hw_params()] enum_pcm_formats:
[D][12125.993065] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] ACCESS:  MMAP_INTERLEAVED MMAP_NONINTERLEAVED RW_INTERLEAVED RW_NONINTERLEAVED
[D][12125.993075] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] FORMAT:  S32_LE
[D][12125.993082] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] SUBFORMAT:  STD
[D][12125.993089] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] SAMPLE_BITS: 32
[D][12125.993095] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] FRAME_BITS: 32
[D][12125.993101] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] CHANNELS: 1
[D][12125.993107] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] RATE: 48000
[D][12125.993113] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_TIME: 10000
[D][12125.993119] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_SIZE: 480
[D][12125.993124] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_BYTES: 1920
[D][12125.993130] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIODS: [2 50]
[D][12125.993136] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_TIME: [20000 500000]
[D][12125.993142] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_SIZE: [960 24000]
[D][12125.993148] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_BYTES: [3840 96000]
[D][12125.993153] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] TICK_TIME: ALL
[D][12125.993165] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  885 add_rate()] min:48000 max:48000 min-allowed:0 scale:1 interleave:1 all:0
[D][12125.993172] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  909 add_rate()] rate:48000 multi:1 card:0 def:0
[D][12125.993180] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  963 add_channels()] channels (1 1) default:1 all:0
[D][12125.993187] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1036 add_channels()] 0x562ee6e95448: position 0 2

[I][12125.637937] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  618 spa_alsa_open()] 0x562ee6e24218: ALSA device open '_ucm0001.minifuse12_stereo_out:M2,0,0,1' playback
[I][12125.657353] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  568 probe_pitch_ctl()] minifuse12_stereo_out:M2,0,0,1 could not find ctl device: No such file or directory
[D][12125.657379] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1048 debug_hw_params()] enum_pcm_formats:
[D][12125.657398] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] ACCESS:  MMAP_INTERLEAVED MMAP_NONINTERLEAVED RW_INTERLEAVED RW_NONINTERLEAVED
[D][12125.657407] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] FORMAT:  S16_LE
[D][12125.657414] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] SUBFORMAT:  STD
[D][12125.657420] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] SAMPLE_BITS: 16
[D][12125.657427] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] FRAME_BITS: 32
[D][12125.657433] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] CHANNELS: 2
[D][12125.657439] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] RATE: 48000
[D][12125.657445] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_TIME: 10000
[D][12125.657452] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_SIZE: 480
[D][12125.657458] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_BYTES: 1920
[D][12125.657463] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIODS: [2 50]
[D][12125.657468] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_TIME: [20000 500000]
[D][12125.657474] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_SIZE: [960 24000]
[D][12125.657481] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_BYTES: [3840 96000]
[D][12125.657488] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] TICK_TIME: ALL
[D][12125.657499] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  885 add_rate()] min:48000 max:48000 min-allowed:0 scale:1 interleave:1 all:0
[D][12125.657507] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  909 add_rate()] rate:48000 multi:1 card:0 def:0
[D][12125.657514] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  963 add_channels()] channels (2 2) default:2 all:0
[D][12125.657521] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1036 add_channels()] 0x562ee6e24218: position 0 3
[D][12125.657528] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1036 add_channels()] 0x562ee6e24218: position 1 4

Without matching UCM profile the in/outs offers the full range (but everything is mapped as "surround" 4-channel):

[D][13133.383190] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1346 spa_alsa_enum_format()] opened:0 format:0 started:0
[I][13133.383199] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  618 spa_alsa_open()] 0x5629c57893f8: ALSA device open 'surround40:4' capture
[I][13133.384911] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  568 probe_pitch_ctl()] surround40:4 could not find ctl device: No such file or directory
[D][13133.384928] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1048 debug_hw_params()] enum_pcm_formats:
[D][13133.384941] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] ACCESS:  MMAP_INTERLEAVED RW_INTERLEAVED
[D][13133.384947] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] FORMAT:  S32_LE
[D][13133.384951] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] SUBFORMAT:  STD
[D][13133.384955] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] SAMPLE_BITS: 32
[D][13133.384959] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] FRAME_BITS: 128
[D][13133.384963] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] CHANNELS: 4
[D][13133.384967] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] RATE: [44100 192000]
[D][13133.384970] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_TIME: [125 1000000]
[D][13133.384974] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_SIZE: [6 192000]
[D][13133.384978] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_BYTES: [96 3072000]
[D][13133.384982] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIODS: [2 1024]
[D][13133.384986] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_TIME: (62 2000000]
[D][13133.384990] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_SIZE: [12 384000]
[D][13133.384993] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_BYTES: [192 6144000]
[D][13133.384997] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] TICK_TIME: ALL
[D][13133.385004] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  885 add_rate()] min:44100 max:192000 min-allowed:0 scale:1 interleave:1 all:0
[D][13133.385009] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  909 add_rate()] rate:48000 multi:1 card:0 def:0
[D][13133.385014] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  963 add_channels()] channels (4 4) default:4 all:0
[D][13133.385018] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1036 add_channels()] 0x5629c57893f8: position 0 3
[D][13133.385022] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1036 add_channels()] 0x5629c57893f8: position 1 4
[D][13133.385026] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1036 add_channels()] 0x5629c57893f8: position 2 12
[D][13133.385030] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1036 add_channels()] 0x5629c57893f8: position 3 13

[D][13133.381023] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1346 spa_alsa_enum_format()] opened:0 format:0 started:0
[I][13133.381032] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  618 spa_alsa_open()] 0x5629c57650b8: ALSA device open 'surround40:4' playback
[I][13133.382756] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  568 probe_pitch_ctl()] surround40:4 could not find ctl device: No such file or directory
[D][13133.382772] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1048 debug_hw_params()] enum_pcm_formats:
[D][13133.382786] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] ACCESS:  MMAP_INTERLEAVED RW_INTERLEAVED
[D][13133.382792] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] FORMAT:  S16_LE S32_LE
[D][13133.382796] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] SUBFORMAT:  STD
[D][13133.382800] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] SAMPLE_BITS: [16 32]
[D][13133.382804] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] FRAME_BITS: [64 128]
[D][13133.382808] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] CHANNELS: 4
[D][13133.382812] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] RATE: [44100 192000]
[D][13133.382816] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_TIME: [125 1000000]
[D][13133.382820] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_SIZE: [6 192000]
[D][13133.382824] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIOD_BYTES: [64 3072000]
[D][13133.382827] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] PERIODS: [2 1024]
[D][13133.382831] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_TIME: (62 2000000]
[D][13133.382835] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_SIZE: [12 384000]
[D][13133.382839] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] BUFFER_BYTES: [96 6144000]
[D][13133.382843] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  469 log_write()] TICK_TIME: ALL
[D][13133.382850] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  885 add_rate()] min:44100 max:192000 min-allowed:0 scale:1 interleave:1 all:0
[D][13133.382855] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  909 add_rate()] rate:48000 multi:1 card:0 def:0
[D][13133.382859] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c:  963 add_channels()] channels (4 4) default:4 all:0
[D][13133.382864] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1036 add_channels()] 0x5629c57650b8: position 0 3
[D][13133.382868] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1036 add_channels()] 0x5629c57650b8: position 1 4
[D][13133.382872] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1036 add_channels()] 0x5629c57650b8: position 2 12
[D][13133.382876] spa.alsa     | [      alsa-pcm.c: 1036 add_channels()] 0x5629c57650b8: position 3 13
@perexg
Copy link
Member

perexg commented Jun 29, 2023 •
edited

The dshare/dsnoop alsa-lib plugins are used when the UCM client code does not support the splitting itself (and pipewire does not have this code as far as I know).

The split is using exclusive resource (hardware PCM stream) and create more separated PCM streams on top. This means if any of this stream is opened, it "fixes" the parameters to the first opened splitted PCM stream. So if client needs to change the rate / format parameters, all related streams must be closed.

So, it's design issue and pipewire does not behave good in this case. You may highlight this problem to pipewire developers.

The format may be set to fixed value in the UCM file - just add Format S32_LE to the Device blocks. Something like:

diff --git a/ucm2/USB-Audio/Arturia/Minifuse-12-HiFi.conf b/ucm2/USB-Audio/Arturia/Minifuse-12-HiFi.conf
index 644a0bb..3e57c59 100644
--- a/ucm2/USB-Audio/Arturia/Minifuse-12-HiFi.conf
+++ b/ucm2/USB-Audio/Arturia/Minifuse-12-HiFi.conf
@@ -23,6 +23,7 @@ Macro [
                SplitPCM {
                        Name "minifuse12_stereo_out"
                        Direction Playback
+                       Format S32_LE
                        Channels 2
                        HWChannels 4
                        HWChannelPos0 FL
@@ -35,6 +36,7 @@ Macro [
                SplitPCM {
                        Name "minifuse12_stereo_in"
                        Direction Capture
+                       Format S32_LE
                        Channels 2
                        HWChannels 4
                        HWChannelPos0 FL
@@ -47,6 +49,7 @@ Macro [
                SplitPCM {
                        Name "minifuse12_mono_in"
                        Direction Capture
+                       Format S32_LE
                        Channels 1
                        HWChannels 4
                        HWChannelPos0 MONO

If you test this, I can apply this change to the UCM repo.

EDIT: For rate, ask pipewire developers how the 48000Hz problem can be resolved. UCM does not limit the rate range (for the first opened PCM stream).

@kmarty
Copy link
Author

kmarty commented Jun 29, 2023

Format has very similar problem. Once you set it, the other option is no longer available.
Anyway, the Format forced to the "S32_LE" works.

perexg added a commit that referenced this issue Jun 29, 2023
@perexg
USB-Audio: Arturia: set S32_LE format for SplitPCM
dc561ab 
Improve quality with forcing the S32_LE format. Apparently,
current pipewire does not handle correctly the conflicting
PCM streams - not all splitted streams are closed before
rate / format change.

Link: #333
Signed-off-by: Jaroslav Kysela <perex@perex.cz>
sarnold pushed a commit to VCTLabs/alsa-ucm-conf that referenced this issue Nov 30, 2023
@perexg @sarnold
USB-Audio: Arturia: set S32_LE format for SplitPCM
0b714ec 
Improve quality with forcing the S32_LE format. Apparently,
current pipewire does not handle correctly the conflicting
PCM streams - not all splitted streams are closed before
rate / format change.

Link: alsa-project#333
Signed-off-by: Jaroslav Kysela <perex@perex.cz>
@perexg
Copy link
Member

perexg commented Jan 9, 2024

No further work for UCM for this case.

@perexg perexg closed this as completed Jan 9, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
2 participants
@perexg @kmarty