feat(serializer): add ApiProperty::uriTemplate option #5675

GregoireHebert · 2023-07-17T22:51:27Z

Q	A
Branch?	main
Tickets	n/a
License	MIT
Doc PR	api-platform/docs#1782

This feature gives control over the operation used for *toOne and
*toMany relations IRI generation.

When defined, API Platform will use the operation declared on the related
resource that matches the uriTemplate string.

In addition, this will override the value returned to be the IRI string
only, not an object in JSONLD formats. For HAL and JSON:API format, the
IRI will be used in links properties, and in the objects embedded or in
relationship properties.

learn more with this guide : https://github.com/GregoireHebert/core/blob/iri-only-collection-property/docs/guides/return-the-iri-of-your-resources-relations.php

Need more tests

usu · 2023-07-18T20:29:04Z

Hi @GregoireHebert. This is an interesting PR. We've developed a similar feature for our application & as a matter of fact, we were also thinking about proposing a PR to api-platform on this. Trying to chime in on this PR & dissect where our solutions differs from yours. Maybe we can build the best out of both solutions 😃

Our current solution is built with a custom Normalizer which decorates the built-in Hal\ItemNormalizer (we're currently only using HAL, but the concept is most probably also usable for other formats). In this Normalizer we automatically replace all array of links with a single IRI (similar as your proposal).

Functionally, this method works great for us. However, we ran into an issue with sub-optimal performance: Due to the fact, that our Normalizer decorates the built-in one, too many entities are loaded from DB and normalized (basically a waste of resources, because all these data is loaded & normalized, event if they are only discarded later-on by our custom Normalizer). This is the reason why we were interested into building this into api platform natively.

Some questions & points where our solutions differ:

Our solution replaces all IRIs application-wide without the need of specifying iriOnly for each ApiProperty. Did you think about using a global flag, which then could be overriden on property level?
Our solution checks for a Search Filter on the target resource and only replaces the Array of IRIs with a single IRI, if such a search filter exists. To utilise the same example you used in your doc PR, this would result in the following response (in case Car resource implements a brands search filter):
```
{
  "@context": "/contexts/Brand",
  "@id": "/brands/1",
  "@type": "Brand",
  "cars": "/cars?brand=/brands/1"
}
```
The property name iriOnly could be misleading in my opinion. Especially in HAL format, the current/original response is also IRI's only (array of IRIs), if the data is not embedded. So the property name could mislead that it is about embedding data (=today's property readableLink). What about collectionLink as a proposal? Basically, we replace a collection of entities with a single collection link, hence the name.
As you specified, a current limitation is, that multiple GetCollection operations are not supported (same is true for our current implementation). Having iriOnly as a boolean property makes it difficult to later expand it further to support multiple operations. What about using a separate attribute, which could later be expanded, e.g.:
```
#[ApiProperty(link: new CollectionLink())] // does the same as iriOnly: true
```
This could later be extended without BC to allow for specific operations or also for route parameters:
```
#[ApiProperty(link: new CollectionLink(
    relatedEntity: Cars::class,
    parameters: [
        'brand' => 'getBrand',
        'yearOfConstruction' => 'getYear',
    ],
    operationName: 'nested_subresource_get_collection'
))]
```
Latter example could then generate the following response:
```
{
  "@context": "/contexts/Brand",
  "@id": "/brands/1",
  "@type": "Brand",
  "cars": "/brands/1/cars?year=2021"
}
```
In our current solution, we use a similar attribute to generate manual links, in cases where we cannot derive target entity and search filter from the context automatically.
For performance reasons, it would be beneficial, if generation of the collection IRI happens before loading the collection data from DB (basically before [propertyAccessor->getValue()](https://github.com/api-platform/core/pull/5675/files#diff-d87efa25fbf52904daa06047002652f08645e3ad4a7f4985ffeec5a7c8e39c4fR604) is called). This should be possible, because $attributeValue is not needed for IRI generation.

Apologies for throwing all these points into your PR. Kind of want to avoid, we come up with a conflicting/non-compatible PR from our side. Happy to support on implementation of the points above, if they seem sensible to you.

Also looping in @carlobeltrame, who was the initial developer of our applications' solution.

mrossard · 2023-07-19T11:38:38Z

May I be silly for a minute?

To me this looks a lot like you sometimes have very big collections and want to lighten the output...which actually just seems like a custom ApiResource to me. Building IRIs for your collections in the provider and exposing them with the field name used in the entity shouldn't be a complicated task.

I feel like I'm missing something or severely underestimating the amount of work required in your project(s) to do it "manually" that way...is that it?

usu · 2023-07-19T13:21:00Z

To me this looks a lot like you sometimes have very big collections and want to lighten the output...which actually just seems like a custom ApiResource to me.

Speaking for our use-case, it's mostly about reducing the number of network requests necessary to load a tree of related data.

The following response needs 3+1 network requests to load the car and all its repairs. It's an N+1 problem, so the number of requests scale linearly with the number of repairs (very bad for performance and for frontend UX).
(Wrote the example in HAL format, as I'm more familiar with it)

{
    "_links": {
        "self": {
            "href": "/cars/1"
        },
        "repairs": [
            {
                "href": "/repairs/1"
            },
            {
                "href": "/repairs/2"
            },
            {
                "href": "/repairs/3"
            }
        ]
    },
    "id": "1"
}

The following response always needs exactly 2 network requests, independent of the number of repairs:

{
    "_links": {
        "self": {
            "href": "/cars/1"
        },
        "repairs": {
            "href": "/repairs?car=/cars/1"
        }
    },
    "id": "1"
}

Building IRIs for your collections in the provider and exposing them with the field name used in the entity shouldn't be a complicated task.

I guess the overriding the fields in the provider would work for the top-level item. However, this could get complicated very fast for embedded resources. For example when the brand resource embeds its cars:

{
    "_links": {
        "self": {
            "href": "/brands/1"
        },
        "cars": {
            "href": "/cars?brand=/brands/1"
        }
    },
    "_embedded": {
        "cars": [
            {
                "_links": {
                    "self": {
                        "href": "/cars/1"
                    },
                    "repairs": {
                        "href": "/repairs?car=/cars/1"
                    }
                },
                "id": "1"
            }
        ]
    },
    "id": "1"
}

The beauty of hooking into the Normalizer is that it generates consistent results, independent of whether a resource is top-level resource or a deeply nested embedded resource.

mrossard · 2023-07-19T14:27:11Z

Ok, so with embedded resources you'd have to have everything as separate ApiResources different from your entities.

That's actually the way i work with APIP right now, but i understand how that could become a problem / a huge amount of work if it's not the case for you!

GregoireHebert · 2023-07-19T15:37:41Z

@usu

Did you think about using a global flag, which then could be overriden on property level?

I did, but for this PR, I introduced it in the ApiProperty level only.
We can add the global option later on :)

Filtering the collection on the current resource
It is definitly something I want to add with the two possible solutions:
"cars": "/cars?brand={BRAND-IRI}" and "cars": "/brands/{brandId}/cars"

collectionLink proposal
Why not.

link: new CollectionLink()
We talked about something similar with @vincentchalamon, but the exact structure isn't clear in my head yet.

Definitely some things to consider.
Thanks a lot for your feedback !

Right off the bat, I am tempted to consider the CollectionLink. I'll give it a thought :)

dunglas · 2023-07-20T12:36:19Z

I love the idea. This approach has many benefits:

Performance/ecodesign: this prevents generating and serializing huge, non-paginated collections
Architecture: this is an incentive for creating an atomic, ESI-like API
Security: this mitigates some DoS attacks

In my opinion, we should allow enabling this option globally, and turn this feature on by default in API Platform 4 (to do so without introducing a breaking change, we can deprecate not setting explicitly the config flag in v3, and set its default value to true in v4).

Instead of relying on the search filter, this feature should be tightly coupled to "subresources".
It should be used only if a corresponding subresource exists, or, better, create automatically the corresponding subresource:

Before:

{
    "@id": "/brands/1",
    "cars": [
        {"@id": "/cars/a", ...},
        {"@id": "/cars/b", ...}
     ]
}

After:

{
    "@id": "/brands/1",
    "cars": "/brands/1/cars"
}

The property name iriOnly could be misleading in my opinion.

I don't like it either, but we already have a similar option named like that. What about uriTemplate: bool|uri-template-id? This is consistent with the name prop of #[ApiResource], as a good DX, and allows selecting a specific route if several are defined for the same resource. We should maybe also allow mapping the current prop with the corresponding URI variable on the other side.

Regarding possible filters, documenting them is already supported by Hydra, so I don't think we have more to do, at least for JSON-LD. Unlike Hydra, I don't think that HAL has support for URI templates.

usu · 2023-07-22T15:36:20Z

Thanks @dunglas for your perspective on this and for the general support of the concept.

I don't like it either, but we already have a similar option named like that. What about uriTemplate: bool|uri-template-id? This is consistent with the name prop of #[ApiResource], as a good DX, and allows selecting a specific route if several are defined for the same resource. We should maybe also allow mapping the current prop with the corresponding URI variable on the other side.

For simple use cases, a boolean flag or a string identifying the route might be sufficient (e.g. simple properties linking to other resources).

For more complex use cases (e.g. manual getters) this is not sufficient, and more information is needed (target resource + route + URI/query parameters). Latter could also be a separate feature, which basically allows overriding links with an arbitrary route. I just though there's a case to combine the 2 use-cases, as they share some similarities.

Providing an example:

#[ApiResource]
class Brand {
    #[ApiProperty(link: new CollectionLink(
        relatedEntity: Repair::class,
        parameters: [
            'finished' => false,
        ],
        callbackParameters: [
            'brand' => 'getBrand',
        ],
    ))]
    public function getUnfinishedRepairs(): array {
        $repairs = array_map(function (Car $car) {
            return array_filter(
                $car->repairs->getValues(),
                function (Repair $repair) { return !$repair->finished; }
            );
        }, $this->cars->getValues());

        return array_merge(...$repairs);
    }

    public function getBrand() {
        return $this;
    }
}

Which then would result in the following response:

{
    "@id": "/brands/1",
    "cars": "/brands/1/cars",
    "unfinishedRepairs": "/repairs?brand=/brands/1&finished=false",
}

Regarding possible filters, documenting them is already supported by Hydra, so I don't think we have more to do, at least for JSON-LD. Unlike Hydra, I don't think that HAL has support for URI templates.

HAL actually has support for URI templates (following RFC6570).
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-kelly-json-hal#section-5.1:

Its value is either a URI [RFC3986] or a URI Template [RFC6570].

We have some code on our side to create RFC6570 templates for an ApiResource.

GregoireHebert · 2023-07-25T12:14:26Z

I did a few changes from my initial proposal.

using a string to define an uriTemplate in the same fashion as the itemUriTemplate of an operation.
I need to add a test to check a behaviour fixed by @vincentchalamon in the following PR: #5663

It will use a GetCollection Operation IRI matching the template, but this Operation has to be defined through the related Resource class.
I am not in favour of defining this much data from the main resource. The property is not a resource nor a resource representation and should not be the source of truth regarding the Uri generation. In a DX sense, that one one the reasons the SubResource annotation was such a mayhem in 2.*.

Then for the global/true/false value possibility, I think it's a bad idea in the same way as the previous comment, the current ressource should not be the source of truth for the related resource class. It guesses too much, and can allow to select matching operation that are not the desired ones. Plus it will be easier to maintain since it uses the same mechanism than the operations, will use correctly the uriVariable already declared.

Now my current proposal doesn't cover one of your need that is passing default filters values during the IRI generation.
This is not possible at all at the moment. I understand your use case, but It deserves a separate PR/Proposal.

GregoireHebert · 2023-07-26T13:42:44Z

note: last failing tests should be green when 3.1 is merged into main.

soyuka · 2023-08-01T12:22:20Z

src/Doctrine/Orm/Extension/EagerLoadingExtension.php

@@ -155,8 +155,9 @@ private function joinRelations(QueryBuilder $queryBuilder, QueryNameGeneratorInt
            }

            $fetchEager = $propertyMetadata->getFetchEager();
+            $uriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->geturiTemplate();


Suggested change

$uriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->geturiTemplate();

$uriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->getUriTemplate();

soyuka · 2023-08-01T12:22:40Z

composer.json

@@ -75,6 +75,7 @@
        "symfony/maker-bundle": "^1.24",
        "symfony/mercure-bundle": "*",
        "symfony/messenger": "^6.1",
+        "symfony/monolog-bundle": "^3.8",


Suggested change

"symfony/monolog-bundle": "^3.8",

Use LoggerInterface from PSR

src/Metadata/ApiProperty.php

soyuka · 2023-08-01T12:25:20Z

src/Serializer/AbstractItemNormalizer.php

@@ -638,6 +639,13 @@ protected function getAttributeValue(object $object, string $attribute, string $
                $childContext = $this->createChildContext($context, $attribute, $format);
                unset($childContext['iri'], $childContext['uri_variables'], $childContext['resource_class'], $childContext['operation']);

+                if (null !== $itemUriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->getUriTemplate()) {


Suggested change

if (null !== $itemUriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->getUriTemplate()) {

if ($itemUriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->getUriTemplate()) {

soyuka · 2023-08-01T12:25:54Z

src/Serializer/AbstractItemNormalizer.php

@@ -638,6 +639,13 @@ protected function getAttributeValue(object $object, string $attribute, string $
                $childContext = $this->createChildContext($context, $attribute, $format);
                unset($childContext['iri'], $childContext['uri_variables'], $childContext['resource_class'], $childContext['operation']);

+                if (null !== $itemUriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->getUriTemplate()) {
+                    $operation = $this->resourceMetadataCollectionFactory->create($resourceClass)->getOperation($itemUriTemplate, true, true);


Suggested change

$operation = $this->resourceMetadataCollectionFactory->create($resourceClass)->getOperation($itemUriTemplate, true, true);

$operation = $this->resourceMetadataCollectionFactory->create($resourceClass)->getOperation($itemUriTemplate, true, true);

you can use named arguments for clarity on these booleans?

usu · 2023-08-14T20:57:02Z

Thanks for progressing on this. I tried to test with our application, but noticed this doesn't work with HAL format.

The code fails on Hal/Serializer/ItemNormalizer.php#L230 with a "Warning: foreach() argument must be of type array|object, string given". Basically this code expects an array (because $relation['cardinality'] is not 'one') but instead gets the URI as a string value. This could be catched earlier in the same function, however, the issue is that I might want to embed the relation as well. So getAttributeValue would need to return the URI when $type==="link", but return the actual array of objects for $type==="embedded".

Might be an issue for other formats as well. I don't know JsonAPI enough, but the code in JsonApi/Serializer/ItemNormalizer looks very similar.

usu · 2023-08-15T06:58:21Z

src/Serializer/AbstractItemNormalizer.php

@@ -638,6 +639,17 @@ protected function getAttributeValue(object $object, string $attribute, string $
                $childContext = $this->createChildContext($context, $attribute, $format);
                unset($childContext['iri'], $childContext['uri_variables'], $childContext['resource_class'], $childContext['operation']);

+                if ($itemUriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->getUriTemplate()) {


Would actually be cool if we can avoid populating $attributeValue before checking for uriTemplate. This can save quite some DB requests, as the actual data is not needed to generate the uri.

I made a proposal here: GregoireHebert#1

This also includes enabling uriTemplate for non-collections. While we both have mainly collections in mind as the main purpose of this feature, I think there's no harm to also allow overriding the uriTemplate for *:1 relations.

I am trying to take this into account, and it gives me insomnia and headaches...
I will eventually get there, please bear with me :D

🤣 got it. Let me know if I can be of any help?

I am getting somewhere... I think.
If you could check on your project that I dont break anything 😬
I had to change the HAL json schema that didn't allowed having object embedded (only array of objects)
But I wasn't 100% sure it was alright according to the specification.

If it is ok, I'll write/update the documentation guide

GregoireHebert · 2023-08-16T07:52:17Z

@usu thanks for the feedbacks, I'll try to have a look and fix the other formats during this week or the next.

usu

Checked on my project in HAL format and everything works as intended 🚀

Thanks a lot!

usu · 2023-08-27T08:55:10Z

src/Doctrine/Orm/Extension/EagerLoadingExtension.php


-            if (false === $fetchEager) {
+            if (false === $fetchEager || null !== $uriTemplate) {


When items are embedded, they should still be fetched.

Should we change as following?

if (false === $fetchEager || (null !== $uriTemplate && !$propertyMetadata->isReadableLink() )) {

I'll try this

usu · 2023-08-27T09:08:51Z

src/Hal/Serializer/ItemNormalizer.php

+                continue;
+            }
+
+            $childContext = $this->createChildContext($context, $relationName, $format);


What exactly is the purpose of this and the next few lines? $relation['operation'] is only populated when $relation['iri'] is populated as well, in which case the for-loop has already continued/returned above.

I'll double check that, I may have been carried away x)

I think for HAL and JSON:API formats, the behaviour is fine.

But for the JSONLD format, I feel that we should not use the uriTemplate acting as an IriOnly option, when there is one that exist for NormalizationContext. Would it make more sense that, unless we use a second ApiProperty::IriOnly option, it only resolves the IRI with uriTemplate within the object(s) themselves ? And if the ApiProperty::IriOnly option is true, then return the IRI string instead of an object? But then what about the IriOnly option on Normalization Context?

ping @vincentchalamon @dunglas

As discussed on video call with Vincent and Soyuka, the behaviour is different, but doesn't interfere that much. It is acceptable.

This feature gives control over the operation used for *toOne and *toMany relations IRI generation. When defined, API Platform will use the operation declared on the related resource that matches the uriTemplate string. In addition, this will override the value returned to be the IRI string only, not an object in JSONLD formats. For HAL and JSON:API format, the IRI will be used in links properties, and in the objects embedded or in relationship properties.

soyuka · 2023-09-11T13:09:10Z

Merging this as experimental, future updates can be provided as bug fix on 3.2 (currently main). Thanks @usu @GregoireHebert !

BacLuc · 2023-10-10T15:18:45Z

Thank you very much @GregoireHebert and @usu.
I tested the feature and i could reduce unnecessary db queries by quite a bit:
BacLuc/ecamp3@fe00aa1#diff-e8620ddac3c501cd95265fa71310036a686d6a1376608ed804d001937c88149c
If i expand this to all problematic relations this will have a big impact.

It even documents the property as an iri-reference string instead of an array of iri-reference strings, very cool.
BacLuc/ecamp3@fe00aa1#diff-ad6583babfa03aae1d6fc116bafe6e03eacd4fa1642f875be723a11e58bae455

BacLuc/ecamp3#208

NikoGrano · 2023-10-14T16:29:07Z

src/Doctrine/Orm/Extension/EagerLoadingExtension.php

@@ -155,8 +155,9 @@ private function joinRelations(QueryBuilder $queryBuilder, QueryNameGeneratorInt
            }

            $fetchEager = $propertyMetadata->getFetchEager();
+            $uriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->getUriTemplate();


@GregoireHebert This causes an issue here.

Error: Typed property ApiPlatform\Metadata\ApiProperty::$uriTemplate must not be accessed before initialization #32 /vendor/api-platform/core/src/Metadata/ApiProperty.php(477): ApiPlatform\Metadata\ApiProperty::getUriTemplate #31 /vendor/api-platform/core/src/Doctrine/Orm/Extension/EagerLoadingExtension.php(158): ApiPlatform\Doctrine\Orm\Extension\EagerLoadingExtension::joinRelations #30 /vendor/api-platform/core/src/Doctrine/Orm/Extension/EagerLoadingExtension.php(98): ApiPlatform\Doctrine\Orm\Extension\EagerLoadingExtension::apply #29 /vendor/api-platform/core/src/Doctrine/Orm/Extension/EagerLoadingExtension.php(61): ApiPlatform\Doctrine\Orm\Extension\EagerLoadingExtension::applyToItem

weird, it's initialized to null inside the constructor. Can you provide a reproducer an open a new issue please?

GregoireHebert force-pushed the iri-only-collection-property branch from 0a4f1b4 to 6c56f0d Compare July 17, 2023 23:10

GregoireHebert marked this pull request as ready for review July 18, 2023 08:16

GregoireHebert mentioned this pull request Jul 18, 2023

feat(serialisation): return collection property as IRI api-platform/docs#1782

Closed

GregoireHebert force-pushed the iri-only-collection-property branch from a8c6e3f to fbebb25 Compare July 31, 2023 14:14

soyuka reviewed Aug 1, 2023

View reviewed changes

GregoireHebert force-pushed the iri-only-collection-property branch from ffb7c8f to 847ee8b Compare August 3, 2023 12:51

usu reviewed Aug 15, 2023

View reviewed changes

usu mentioned this pull request Aug 15, 2023

POC: improve normalizer performance (related collection links) ecamp/ecamp3#3559

Closed

GregoireHebert force-pushed the iri-only-collection-property branch from 5c90aae to e3bf432 Compare August 21, 2023 08:57

usu approved these changes Aug 27, 2023

View reviewed changes

GregoireHebert force-pushed the iri-only-collection-property branch from 0fdb3be to d7eac24 Compare August 28, 2023 07:30

GregoireHebert marked this pull request as draft August 28, 2023 07:32

GregoireHebert changed the title ~~feat: Add IriOnly Option on Collection properties~~ feat(serializer): add ApiProperty::uriTemplate option Aug 28, 2023

GregoireHebert force-pushed the iri-only-collection-property branch from d7eac24 to da6df8b Compare August 28, 2023 17:41

vincentchalamon mentioned this pull request Sep 11, 2023

Update Demo api-platform/demo#327

Merged

18 tasks

soyuka force-pushed the iri-only-collection-property branch 2 times, most recently from 76c6942 to 8550276 Compare September 11, 2023 12:28

soyuka marked this pull request as ready for review September 11, 2023 12:31

fix: update for guide

2aa93a8

soyuka force-pushed the iri-only-collection-property branch from 8550276 to 2aa93a8 Compare September 11, 2023 12:32

soyuka merged commit e65d2c3 into api-platform:main Sep 11, 2023
41 of 43 checks passed

BacLuc mentioned this pull request Oct 8, 2023

Api Platform upgrade to 3.2 ecamp/ecamp3#3933

Closed

NikoGrano reviewed Oct 14, 2023

View reviewed changes

usu mentioned this pull request Apr 14, 2024

fix(serializer): uriTemplate wrong cache usage in hal format #6313

Merged

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

feat(serializer): add ApiProperty::uriTemplate option #5675

feat(serializer): add ApiProperty::uriTemplate option #5675

GregoireHebert commented Jul 17, 2023 •

edited

Loading

usu commented Jul 18, 2023

mrossard commented Jul 19, 2023

usu commented Jul 19, 2023

mrossard commented Jul 19, 2023

GregoireHebert commented Jul 19, 2023

dunglas commented Jul 20, 2023 •

edited

Loading

usu commented Jul 22, 2023

GregoireHebert commented Jul 25, 2023

GregoireHebert commented Jul 26, 2023

soyuka Aug 1, 2023

soyuka Aug 1, 2023

soyuka Aug 1, 2023

soyuka Aug 1, 2023

usu commented Aug 14, 2023

usu Aug 15, 2023

GregoireHebert Aug 24, 2023

usu Aug 24, 2023

GregoireHebert Aug 24, 2023

GregoireHebert Aug 24, 2023

GregoireHebert commented Aug 16, 2023

usu left a comment

usu Aug 27, 2023

GregoireHebert Aug 28, 2023

usu Aug 27, 2023

GregoireHebert Aug 28, 2023

GregoireHebert Aug 28, 2023

GregoireHebert Aug 28, 2023

soyuka commented Sep 11, 2023

BacLuc commented Oct 10, 2023

NikoGrano Oct 14, 2023

soyuka Oct 15, 2023

	$uriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->geturiTemplate();
	$uriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->getUriTemplate();

	if (null !== $itemUriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->getUriTemplate()) {
	if ($itemUriTemplate = $propertyMetadata->getUriTemplate()) {

	$operation = $this->resourceMetadataCollectionFactory->create($resourceClass)->getOperation($itemUriTemplate, true, true);
	$operation = $this->resourceMetadataCollectionFactory->create($resourceClass)->getOperation($itemUriTemplate, true, true);


		if (false === $fetchEager) {
		if (false === $fetchEager \|\| null !== $uriTemplate) {

feat(serializer): add ApiProperty::uriTemplate option #5675

feat(serializer): add ApiProperty::uriTemplate option #5675

Conversation

GregoireHebert commented Jul 17, 2023 • edited Loading

usu commented Jul 18, 2023

mrossard commented Jul 19, 2023

usu commented Jul 19, 2023

mrossard commented Jul 19, 2023

GregoireHebert commented Jul 19, 2023

dunglas commented Jul 20, 2023 • edited Loading

usu commented Jul 22, 2023

GregoireHebert commented Jul 25, 2023

GregoireHebert commented Jul 26, 2023

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

usu commented Aug 14, 2023

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

GregoireHebert commented Aug 16, 2023

usu left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

soyuka commented Sep 11, 2023

BacLuc commented Oct 10, 2023

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

GregoireHebert commented Jul 17, 2023 •

edited

Loading

dunglas commented Jul 20, 2023 •

edited

Loading