tcpprep -x option issue

[fklassen]

As reported in tcpreplay-users@lists.sourceforge.net mail list:

tcpreplay version: 4.1.0 (build git:v4.1.0)

This is from the tcpprep man page

-x string, --include=string
Include only packets matching rule. This option may appear up to 1 times. This option must not appear in combination with any of the following options: exclude.
Override default of processing all packets stored in the capture file and only send/edit packets which match the provided rule. Rules can be one of:
S:<CIDR1>,... - Source IP must match specified IPv4/v6 CIDR(s)
D:<CIDR1>,... - Destination IP must match specified IPv4/v6 CIDR(s)
B:<CIDR1>,... - Both source and destination IP must match specified IPv4/v6 CIDR(s)
E:<CIDR1>,... - Either IP must match specified IPv4/v6 CIDR(s)
P:<LIST> - Must be one of the listed packets where the list corresponds to the packet number in the capture file.
-x P:1-5,9,15,72-
would process packets 1 thru 5, the 9th and 15th packet, and packets 72 until the end of the file

Emphasis mine.

After doing all this, to the attached capture:

tcprewrite --enet-vlan=del --pnat=10.48.144.240/32:1.0.1.5/32,10.48.144.248/32:1.0.1.6/32,172.21.61.25/32:4.0.1.12/32 -b --infile='tmp/LINK.pcap' --outfile='tmp/IP.pcap'
tcprewrite --dlt=enet --enet-vlan=del --enet-dmac=02:00:00:bb:bb:00,02:00:00:cc:cc:00 --enet-smac=02:00:00:aa:aa:00,02:00:00:dd:dd:00 --cachefile=tmp/INPUT.cache --infile='tmp/IP.pcap' --outfile='tmp/REPLAY.pcap'
tcpprep --cidr=1.0.0.0/8 --include=P:4-16,21-33 --cachefile='tmp/INPUT.cache' --pcap='tmp/IP.pcap'

I would expect only packets 4-16,21-33 to be modified and/or given a direction in the cache. But they all have and there is nothing indicating that it will not replay everything.
And, indeed, the entire capture is replayed. This makes no difference: --include='P:4-16,21-33' vs --include=P:4-16,21-33

This also does not stop anything:
tcpprep --cidr=1.0.0.0/8 --include=E:1.0.0.0/8 --cachefile='tmp/INPUT.cache' --pcap='tmp/IP.pcap'

This does:
tcpprep --cidr=1.0.0.0/8 --include=S:1.0.0.0/8 --cachefile='tmp/INPUT.cache' --pcap='tmp/IP.pcap'

I cannot find where this was recently discussed or fixed in the archives. Seems like a bug.

-Mike
two-gets.pcap.txt

[fklassen]

fixed in PR #453