Deprecate this Custom Integration when push access is implemented for sensors and remotes in HA Core #22
Comments
|
Can I ask how you can see if this is indeed working? I was using the fasthue hack / workaround set at 1s and my switches were very responsive. Now since upgrading and removing the fasthue component it is several times slower response when pressing buttons on the HUE taps and remotes. I am running core-2021.7.1 |
|
Hi @s3frank, You are totally right! it isn't working, apparently 🤨 I could swear that, when I tried it with the dev branch of HA Core (> 1 month ago), when listening to I'm not sure if this integration could work as it is after 2021.6 (there were reported errors about it in #23 (comment)), so I don't think a reinstall would work :( |
|
Does it need a particular firmware version on the hue bridges?
I update mine automatically which so far seems weekly for the past few
years without issues.
…On Fri, Jul 9, 2021 at 3:03 PM Eugenio Panadero ***@***.***> wrote:
Hi @s3frank <https://github.com/s3frank>,
You are totally right! it isn't working, apparently 🤨
I could swear that, when I tried it with the dev branch of HA Core (> 1
month ago), when *listening to hue_event in dev-tools->events*, they were
coming instantly (= pushed from bridge), but now I'm checking it from my
*production* HA (with 2021.6 yet), and it looks like it's using the old
polling each 5s 😢 ... I'll try to investigate a bit more and dive in the
code to see what is happening. Maybe the push access is not enabled for
sensors/remotes in the release version yet 🤷
I'm not sure if this integration could work as it is after 2021.6 (there
were reported errors about it in #23 (comment)
<#23 (comment)>), so I
don't think a reinstall would work :(
—
You are receiving this because you were mentioned.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#22 (comment)>, or
unsubscribe
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAQW7CWUVUOYJHPSRPY2GLTTW2NLVANCNFSM445VFCXA>
.
--
Best regards,
-FF
|
|
It seems to me the custom integration works better than what's in HA ATM. Would be nice to have some sort of settings option in the Hue integration to see the status of the polling/push messages. |
|
@azogue were you able to figure out what is wrong? I have been upgrading to the point release hoping to see it get fixed but so far still seems to be slow at like multiple seconds and it's causing me issues at times. My wife and kids pressing a 2nd time before the first event is triggered, that type of thing. |
I'm on holidays, so not much time in front of the computer these days 😝
I just tried it again using the If you want to try it yourself, and are in a hurry, I think the beta channel should work. |
|
okidoki, I will wait for the next release and see, thanks for getting back
to me while on holiday.
enjoy your time away and stay safe!
…On Fri, Jul 30, 2021 at 5:55 PM Eugenio Panadero ***@***.***> wrote:
@s3frank <https://github.com/s3frank>,
were you able to figure out what is wrong?
I'm on holidays, so not much time in front of the computer these days 😝
You are totally right! it isn't working, apparently 🤨
I could swear that, when I tried it with the dev branch of HA Core (> 1
month ago), when listening to hue_event in dev-tools->events, they were
coming instantly (= pushed from bridge), but now I'm checking it from my
production HA (with 2021.6 yet), and it looks like it's using the old
polling each 5s
I just tried it again using the upstream/rc branch of HA Core, and
apparently *it is included there*, so I suppose it will be included in
2021.8.0 (which will be released next wednesday, I think). Good things take
time 😊
If you want to try it yourself, and are in a hurry, I think the *beta
channel* should work.
In my simple test, I used the dev-tools->Event listener, listening to
hue_event, in both machines: *production* with 2021.7.3, and the dev
machine running rc branch. In 2021.8.0b4 the push access is clearly
enabled, as events from a Hue remote come instantly ⚡️
—
You are receiving this because you were mentioned.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#22 (comment)>, or
unsubscribe
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAQW7CS7I3DXPAFG3GX7TXDT2JZKHANCNFSM445VFCXA>
.
--
Best regards,
-FF
|
|
Looks like it is working, thx
On Fri, 30 Jul 2021 at 18:43, Frank Feldmann ***@***.***>
wrote:
okidoki, I will wait for the next release and see, thanks for getting back
to me while on holiday.
enjoy your time away and stay safe!
On Fri, Jul 30, 2021 at 5:55 PM Eugenio Panadero ***@***.***>
wrote:
> @s3frank <https://github.com/s3frank>,
>
> were you able to figure out what is wrong?
>
> I'm on holidays, so not much time in front of the computer these days 😝
>
> You are totally right! it isn't working, apparently 🤨
>
> I could swear that, when I tried it with the dev branch of HA Core (> 1
> month ago), when listening to hue_event in dev-tools->events, they were
> coming instantly (= pushed from bridge), but now I'm checking it from my
> production HA (with 2021.6 yet), and it looks like it's using the old
> polling each 5s
>
> I just tried it again using the upstream/rc branch of HA Core, and
> apparently *it is included there*, so I suppose it will be included in
> 2021.8.0 (which will be released next wednesday, I think). Good things take
> time 😊
>
> If you want to try it yourself, and are in a hurry, I think the *beta
> channel* should work.
> In my simple test, I used the dev-tools->Event listener, listening to
> hue_event, in both machines: *production* with 2021.7.3, and the dev
> machine running rc branch. In 2021.8.0b4 the push access is clearly
> enabled, as events from a Hue remote come instantly ⚡️
>
> —
> You are receiving this because you were mentioned.
> Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
> <#22 (comment)>, or
> unsubscribe
> <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAQW7CS7I3DXPAFG3GX7TXDT2JZKHANCNFSM445VFCXA>
> .
>
--
Best regards,
-FF
--
Best regards,
…-FF
|
|
On home assistant 2021.8.4. Response time seems slowish for my hue Motion sensors. How can I test? Wave my hands and check event listener? I don't have any buttons just the motion sensors. |
Hi @dasb00ter, quickest way is to use a cheap Hue dimmer switch, as you control the trigger with your finger 🤣, but if you only have motion sensors, I suppose the hand-waving is the only way 😅 |
Very interesting changes have been made recently in relation to how to talk to the Hue Bridge, so it seems that we will soon have ⚡️local push access⚡️ to the bridge, and therefore no more polling.
In that scenario, this integration/dirty-hack loses all its meaning, fortunately, so it will not be necessary anymore.
When the HA Core version with these changes is released, and verified, this repository will be archived and removed from HACS
🎉 Many thanks to everyone involved in these changes, especially the fantastic team at HA / NabuCasa 👏👏
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: