This fork violates the LPPL license

[FrankMittelbach]

Hi Bastien,

the package as it is placed on CTAN (or here on github) is a very problematical fork as it doesn't tell anywhere what is changed (or why). Instead it is a 1-2-1 copy of the original with just footmisc replaced by footmisx (which is good but makes it of course very hard to see what you have done to the code written by Robin).

LPPL requires for derived works (ie forks):

 Every component of the Derived Work contains prominent notices
 detailing the nature of the changes to that component, or a
 prominent reference to another file that is distributed as part
 of the Derived Work and that contains a complete and accurate log
 of the changes.

and while "complete and accurate" may be a matter of opinion but nothing here comes even close to it.

Looks like that by the end of the day all your changes come down to a few lines

footmisx-real-changes.txt

and even that could be further reduced.

Given that you make minimal real changes, it would be much better to simply load footmisc (passing the options on) and then have a few lines containing your changes (plus some documentation why and how). And along the way an example that tells a user why he or she should use your code over the well-established footmisc would also help.

So please update your package or withdraw it from here and CTAN.

[bastien-roucaries]

Le mar. 28 août 2018 à 11:53, Frank Mittelbach <notifications@github.com> a écrit :

Hi Bastien, the package as it is placed on CTAN (or here on github) is a very problematical fork as it doesn't tell anywhere what is changed (or why). Instead it is a 1-2-1 copy of the original with just footmisc replaced by footmisx (which is good but makes it of course very hard to see what you have done to the code written by Robin). LPPL requires for derived works (ie forks): Every component of the Derived Work contains prominent notices detailing the nature of the changes to that component, or a prominent reference to another file that is distributed as part of the Derived Work and that contains a complete and accurate log of the changes. and while "complete and accurate" may be a matter of opinion but nothing here comes even close to it. Looks like that by the end of the day all your changes come down to a few lines footmisx-real-changes.txt <https://github.com/bastien-roucaries/footmisx/files/2327494/footmisx-real-changes.txt> and even that could be further reduced. Given that you make minimal real changes, it would be much better to simply load footmisc (passing the options on) and then have a few lines containing your changes (plus some documentation why and how). And along the way an example that tells a user why he or she should use your code over the well-established footmisc would also help. So please update your package or withdraw it from here and CTAN.

Will add a changelog... And document changes

…

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#2>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AEnaHOcw8kKCkvJ_jntHounyCFvq_QDSks5uVRMPgaJpZM4WPR64> .