why not from PIL import Image

[crcrpar]

I wonder why not from PIL import Image in https://github.com/bethgelab/foolbox/blob/master/foolbox/utils.py#L76-L78

In major open sources, they use from PIL import Image such as pillow official documents and pytorch/torchvision.
In addition to this, I encountered an error when using foolbox.utils.imagenet_example caused by PIL.Image.open.

[jonasrauber]

Can you clarify what you mean. Whether I do import PIL and then use PIL.Image or instead from PIL import Image and then use Image shouldn't make a difference?!

[crcrpar]

In my environment, PIL.Image raised AttributeError: module 'PIL' has no attribute 'Image'.
This error is solved by using from PIL import Image instead.

my environment:

• python 3.5.3
• Pillow 5.0.0

[jonasrauber]

Interesting. Thanks for reporting this. If you want you can make a pull-request, otherwise I will fix it in a few days.

[jonasrauber]

fixed in the recently released version 0.12.4

[crcrpar]

Thank you.