New icu_* crate releases break (unlocked) main build and latest crates release

[mattsse]

Describe the bug
0.17.0 on crates is currently broken due to new icu releases (icu_provider 0.13.0) which bumped zerovec through tinystr bump

To Reproduce
cargo new repro

add deps:

[dependencies]
boa_engine = "0.17"

cargo c

This is also an issue on main after removing lock file which then picks up new icu_* crates rm Cargo.lock && cargo c

[jedel1043]

Can you check if the build is now fixed? I think this broke because ICU4X published its crates by parts, instead of all at once.

[mattsse]

for new crates via boa_engine = "0.17.0" this is still the case because it pulls in all icu_ 1.3.0 crates

on main as well after rm Cargo.lock

[mattsse]

I guess #3306 addresses this?

[jedel1043]

I guess #3306 addresses this?

No, that's for the next version of Boa. We'll have to backport a fix and yank 0.17.

[jedel1043]

The problem is that we're pinning zerovec to "0.9.4" on boa_icu_provider without pinning the rest of the libraries to 1.2.0. I'll see if we can fix this on boa_icu_provider only. Otherwise, we can yank both boa_engine@0.17 and boa_icu_provider@0.17, and push new versions for both.

[Borber]

I still can't seem to find a solution. Is there any solution that can be solved now?

[jedel1043]

I still can't seem to find a solution. Is there any solution that can be solved now?

We're preparing a new release that should publish at most tomorrow :)

[sffc]

tl;dr, icu 1.2 needs zerovec 0.9 and icu 1.3 needs zerovec 0.10, and mixing versions will cause errors.

[sffc]

Worth noting that icu 1.3 supports a range dependency such that it can work with zerovec 0.9.

[sffc]

Can you check if the build is now fixed? I think this broke because ICU4X published its crates by parts, instead of all at once.

We hit a crates.io rate limit when publishing crates. We have asked for a rate limit increase so that next time we can shorten the amount of time it takes to ship a release on crates.io

[jedel1043]

Worth noting that icu 1.3 supports a range dependency such that it can work with zerovec 0.9.

Like using a range version in Cargo.toml ("icu_plurals = ">=1.2.0, <1.3")? Or what do you mean?

[jedel1043]

Ah, I see. ICU4X's repo pins zerovec to ">0.9.4, <0.11.0"
https://github.com/unicode-org/icu4x/blob/63a0b286b88d4e721530177316a5d8b518183c99/Cargo.toml#L217

[jedel1043]

Boa@0.17.1 is up! https://crates.io/crates/boa_engine/0.17.1