Release Candidate Comments (Reviews Declined)

[klumb]

This issue was created to collect comments about the upcoming metrics release.

This thread is for comments about Reviews Declined

GitHub location: https://github.com/chaoss/wg-evolution/blob/master/metrics/Reviews_Declined.md

See all release candidates of metrics are at:
https://chaoss.community/metrics-202001/

[germonprez]

"Resources" should be "References"

[germonprez]

Un-bold "Question"

[ccarterlandis]

@germonprez fixed by #304

[foundjem]

I have a concern about this metric. For example, (i) reviews that authors themselves abandon; this will not also be merged in the codebase, similarly, (ii) declined can also mean that the author(s) did not satisfy the reviewers' requirements before they could accept and merge the patch, etc.

Signed-off-by: Armstrong Foundjem foundjem@ieee.org

[klumb]

Is this metric ready for release?

@foundjem do you have specific edits in mind?

[ccarterlandis]

Barring any specific edits @foundjem may have in mind, I would say it's ready!

[klumb]

I am marking this for release. If we need to address unresolved comments, we can do so in the next release.