pointInPolygon not supported MultiPolygon #9403
Comments
|
ClickHouse doesn't support MultiPolygon's. But we support polygons with holes. |
|
I have new issue when used below polygon and some locations (see attached) and got wrong result. Does CH not support like this polygon as well?
|
qoega
added
feature
and removed
bug
|
Yes, ClickHouse supports these types of polygons (polygon with multiple holes). |
|
Thanks for your reply. |
|
@vicchen7 I'm trying to figure out why the result is not correct. |
|
I found this fiddle: But if I didn't missed something, it looks like that the polygon has multiple self-intersections. |
|
No, it is the issue in this JavaScript. |
alexey-milovidov
added
the
bug
I used below URL to draw and I separate all polygons to draw one by one but not found self-intersections. |
|
Yes, I have also validated this polygon and added a test. |
|
Fixed in master. |
Does pointInPolygon support MultiPolygon?
I tested this function and it seems not fully support.
Below is the test script.
SELECT pointInPolygon((97.66905, 16.5026053), [(97.66905, 16.5026053), (97.667878, 16.4979175), (97.661433, 16.4917645), (97.656745, 16.4859047), (97.656745, 16.4818029), (97.658796, 16.4785801), (97.665535, 16.4753572), (97.670808, 16.4730135), (97.676082, 16.4697907), (97.680477, 16.4677398), (97.68575, 16.4686189), (97.689559, 16.4727207), (97.69454, 16.4744788), (97.698055, 16.4747718), (97.702157, 16.4724279), (97.703036, 16.4683261), (97.703036, 16.4633453), (97.702451, 16.4594354), (97.699533, 16.4539205), (97.699106, 16.4521467), (97.699896, 16.4500714), (97.701852, 16.4474887), (97.701272, 16.4460233), (97.699896, 16.4439216), (97.699857, 16.4425297), (97.700705, 16.4417585), (97.699266, 16.4404319), (97.696817, 16.439585), (97.69468, 16.4391501), (97.690854, 16.439294), (97.686571, 16.4407665), (97.683728, 16.4428458), (97.680647, 16.444719), (97.678369, 16.445322), (97.675195, 16.4448526), (97.672627, 16.4435941), (97.670568, 16.4419727), (97.667276, 16.4410039), (97.666215, 16.439402), (97.66599, 16.43656), (97.664579, 16.435632), (97.66195, 16.4344612), (97.659174, 16.4324549), (97.658693, 16.4290256), (97.659289, 16.4246502), (97.660882, 16.422609), (97.663533, 16.4225057), (97.666402, 16.4210711), (97.67148, 16.4170395), (97.673433, 16.4146478), (97.674184, 16.4124121), (97.6742, 16.4085257), (97.674894, 16.4055148), (97.675906, 16.4019452), (97.675287, 16.3996593), (97.675062, 16.3963334), (97.675798, 16.3936434), (97.675676, 16.3909321), (97.67508, 16.386655), (97.679839, 16.386241), (97.689403, 16.3726191), (97.692011, 16.372909), (97.696359, 16.3679819), (97.699866, 16.360968), (97.697233, 16.3609438), (97.693077, 16.3596272), (97.686631, 16.3584552), (97.68165, 16.3558182), (97.674619, 16.3496653), (97.667588, 16.3482003), (97.664072, 16.3502511), (97.659384, 16.3540599), (97.652353, 16.3578686), (97.649716, 16.3625565), (97.650595, 16.3672443), (97.65206, 16.3701742), (97.65206, 16.3733971), (97.651181, 16.3760339), (97.646493, 16.3763268), (97.6462, 16.3801357), (97.646786, 16.3851165), (97.643563, 16.3883393), (97.638583, 16.3889252), (97.636239, 16.392148), (97.630379, 16.3933199), (97.629132, 16.3964903), (97.624347, 16.4056104), (97.615377, 16.4165245), (97.614779, 16.4229534), (97.611938, 16.4335685), (97.613882, 16.4410439), (97.619713, 16.4461272), (97.62375, 16.4542007), (97.62345, 16.4640683), (97.618965, 16.4793181), (97.617321, 16.4884382), (97.617747, 16.4985751), (97.623301, 16.5026416), (97.629303, 16.5016624), (97.63272, 16.4986048), (97.640862, 16.498226), (97.647134, 16.5006382), (97.650873, 16.5051263), (97.654987, 16.5089598), (97.65639, 16.5118583), (97.658166, 16.5160658), (97.660395, 16.5197566), (97.66612, 16.5140318), (97.668757, 16.507879), (97.66905, 16.5026053)], [(97.666491, 16.5599384), (97.665077, 16.5589283), (97.662417, 16.5607013), (97.659315, 16.5700096), (97.655104, 16.5821991), (97.654882, 16.5855235), (97.654593, 16.5931971), (97.659381, 16.5957754), (97.669927, 16.5995844), (97.683111, 16.6022215), (97.695123, 16.6028077), (97.704206, 16.5984131), (97.704499, 16.5825917), (97.70007, 16.5731793), (97.698976, 16.572997), (97.697211, 16.5717833), (97.692114, 16.5691237), (97.684358, 16.5691235), (97.675936, 16.567572), (97.66818, 16.5611446), (97.666491, 16.5599384)], [(97.653232, 16.574263), (97.652445, 16.5679244), (97.655949, 16.5683449), (97.659594, 16.5627383), (97.659734, 16.5585335), (97.662257, 16.5550293), (97.660855, 16.5512449), (97.658613, 16.5490023), (97.659173, 16.544517), (97.654407, 16.5408727), (97.641933, 16.5363874), (97.63086, 16.5303604), (97.628057, 16.5312014), (97.625954, 16.5415736), (97.63072, 16.5613367), (97.638569, 16.5820811), (97.645017, 16.5892294), (97.649743, 16.5887155), (97.653232, 16.574263)], [(97.625696, 16.5488739), (97.623579, 16.5396268), (97.620589, 16.5423678), (97.616353, 16.5530826), (97.611619, 16.5637974), (97.611
12, 16.5725187), (97.613339, 16.5792777), (97.635042, 16.5874696), (97.64152, 16.5981844), (97.643015, 16.605909), (97.645756, 16.6066565), (97.650989, 16.6034172), (97.644012, 16.5984335), (97.64219, 16.5877556), (97.636038, 16.5804926), (97.63252, 16.570307), (97.628314, 16.5603089), (97.625696, 16.5488739)], [(97.607902, 16.3798949), (97.604911, 16.3719709), (97.602519, 16.3749612), (97.601323, 16.3955933), (97.604014, 16.406059), (97.604762, 16.4084511), (97.607896, 16.4081673), (97.609397, 16.397537), (97.609397, 16.3882674), (97.607902, 16.3798949)], [(97.64902, 16.5107163), (97.645437, 16.5073734), (97.641933, 16.5076538), (97.641933, 16.5108776), (97.645717, 16.5160636), (97.651112, 16.5211243), (97.655721, 16.5238328), (97.656392, 16.5184349), (97.654359, 16.515696), (97.64902, 16.5107163)]) AS dd
┌─dd─┐
│ 1 │
└────┘
SELECT pointInPolygon((97.641933, 16.5076538), [(97.66905, 16.5026053), (97.667878, 16.4979175), (97.661433, 16.4917645), (97.656745, 16.4859047), (97.656745, 16.4818029), (97.658796, 16.4785801), (97.665535, 16.4753572), (97.670808, 16.4730135), (97.676082, 16.4697907), (97.680477, 16.4677398), (97.68575, 16.4686189), (97.689559, 16.4727207), (97.69454, 16.4744788), (97.698055, 16.4747718), (97.702157, 16.4724279), (97.703036, 16.4683261), (97.703036, 16.4633453), (97.702451, 16.4594354), (97.699533, 16.4539205), (97.699106, 16.4521467), (97.699896, 16.4500714), (97.701852, 16.4474887), (97.701272, 16.4460233), (97.699896, 16.4439216), (97.699857, 16.4425297), (97.700705, 16.4417585), (97.699266, 16.4404319), (97.696817, 16.439585), (97.69468, 16.4391501), (97.690854, 16.439294), (97.686571, 16.4407665), (97.683728, 16.4428458), (97.680647, 16.444719), (97.678369, 16.445322), (97.675195, 16.4448526), (97.672627, 16.4435941), (97.670568, 16.4419727), (97.667276, 16.4410039), (97.666215, 16.439402), (97.66599, 16.43656), (97.664579, 16.435632), (97.66195, 16.4344612), (97.659174, 16.4324549), (97.658693, 16.4290256), (97.659289, 16.4246502), (97.660882, 16.422609), (97.663533, 16.4225057), (97.666402, 16.4210711), (97.67148, 16.4170395), (97.673433, 16.4146478), (97.674184, 16.4124121), (97.6742, 16.4085257), (97.674894, 16.4055148), (97.675906, 16.4019452), (97.675287, 16.3996593), (97.675062, 16.3963334), (97.675798, 16.3936434), (97.675676, 16.3909321), (97.67508, 16.386655), (97.679839, 16.386241), (97.689403, 16.3726191), (97.692011, 16.372909), (97.696359, 16.3679819), (97.699866, 16.360968), (97.697233, 16.3609438), (97.693077, 16.3596272), (97.686631, 16.3584552), (97.68165, 16.3558182), (97.674619, 16.3496653), (97.667588, 16.3482003), (97.664072, 16.3502511), (97.659384, 16.3540599), (97.652353, 16.3578686), (97.649716, 16.3625565), (97.650595, 16.3672443), (97.65206, 16.3701742), (97.65206, 16.3733971), (97.651181, 16.3760339), (97.646493, 16.3763268), (97.6462, 16.3801357), (97.646786, 16.3851165), (97.643563, 16.3883393), (97.638583, 16.3889252), (97.636239, 16.392148), (97.630379, 16.3933199), (97.629132, 16.3964903), (97.624347, 16.4056104), (97.615377, 16.4165245), (97.614779, 16.4229534), (97.611938, 16.4335685), (97.613882, 16.4410439), (97.619713, 16.4461272), (97.62375, 16.4542007), (97.62345, 16.4640683), (97.618965, 16.4793181), (97.617321, 16.4884382), (97.617747, 16.4985751), (97.623301, 16.5026416), (97.629303, 16.5016624), (97.63272, 16.4986048), (97.640862, 16.498226), (97.647134, 16.5006382), (97.650873, 16.5051263), (97.654987, 16.5089598), (97.65639, 16.5118583), (97.658166, 16.5160658), (97.660395, 16.5197566), (97.66612, 16.5140318), (97.668757, 16.507879), (97.66905, 16.5026053)], [(97.666491, 16.5599384), (97.665077, 16.5589283), (97.662417, 16.5607013), (97.659315, 16.5700096), (97.655104, 16.5821991), (97.654882, 16.5855235), (97.654593, 16.5931971), (97.659381, 16.5957754), (97.669927, 16.5995844), (97.683111, 16.6022215), (97.695123, 16.6028077), (97.704206, 16.5984131), (97.704499, 16.5825917), (97.70007, 16.5731793), (97.698976, 16.572997), (97.697211, 16.5717833), (97.
692114, 16.5691237), (97.684358, 16.5691235), (97.675936, 16.567572), (97.66818, 16.5611446), (97.666491, 16.5599384)], [(97.653232, 16.574263), (97.652445, 16.5679244), (97.655949, 16.5683449), (97.659594, 16.5627383), (97.659734, 16.5585335), (97.662257, 16.5550293), (97.660855, 16.5512449), (97.658613, 16.5490023), (97.659173, 16.544517), (97.654407, 16.5408727), (97.641933, 16.5363874), (97.63086, 16.5303604), (97.628057, 16.5312014), (97.625954, 16.5415736), (97.63072, 16.5613367), (97.638569, 16.5820811), (97.645017, 16.5892294), (97.649743, 16.5887155), (97.653232, 16.574263)], [(97.625696, 16.5488739), (97.623579, 16.5396268), (97.620589, 16.5423678), (97.616353, 16.5530826), (97.611619, 16.5637974), (97.61112, 16.5725187), (97.613339, 16.5792777), (97.635042, 16.5874696), (97.64152, 16.5981844), (97.643015, 16.605909), (97.645756, 16.6066565), (97.650989, 16.6034172), (97.644012, 16.5984335), (97.64219, 16.5877556), (97.636038, 16.5804926), (97.63252, 16.570307), (97.628314, 16.5603089), (97.625696, 16.5488739)], [(97.607902, 16.3798949), (97.604911, 16.3719709), (97.602519, 16.3749612), (97.601323, 16.3955933), (97.604014, 16.406059), (97.604762, 16.4084511), (97.607896, 16.4081673), (97.609397, 16.397537), (97.609397, 16.3882674), (97.607902, 16.3798949)], [(97.64902, 16.5107163), (97.645437, 16.5073734), (97.641933, 16.5076538), (97.641933, 16.5108776), (97.645717, 16.5160636), (97.651112, 16.5211243), (97.655721, 16.5238328), (97.656392, 16.5184349), (97.654359, 16.515696), (97.64902, 16.5107163)]) as dd;
┌─dd─┐
│ 0 │
└────┘
If my format of script is not correct or pointInPolygon does not support MultiPolygon fully?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: