Bosh cannot update CF quotas

[mtekel]

When you define quotas in CF manfest, e.g.

    quota_definitions:
      default:
        memory_limit: 10240
        non_basic_services_allowed: true
        total_routes: 1000
        total_services: 100

BOSH will create them. But when you change any values, BOSH will apply your changes - which will finish successfully, but the quota in CF will not be updated. In cc logs, you can find quota collision logs:

{
    "data": {
        "name": "default",
        "values": {
            "memory_limit": 2048,
            "non_basic_services_allowed": false,
            "total_routes": 1000,
            "total_services": 10
        }
    },
    "fiber_id": 47214725162920,
    "file": "/var/vcap/data/packages/cloud_controller_ng/6d32e116fa47763d6885214954e0d737c28b29e5.1-aa02996eae5e64a4ff823957b8ec5baf64d0b2b5/cloud_controller_ng/lib/cloud_controller/seeds.rb",
    "lineno": 20,
    "log_level": "warn",
    "message": "seeds.quota-collision",
    "method": "block in create_seed_quota_definitions",
    "process_id": 10857,
    "source": "cc.seeds",
    "thread_id": 47214699944340,
    "timestamp": 1460386421.1394439
}

and

{
    "data": {
        "existing_quota_name": "default"
    },
    "fiber_id": 47214725162920,
    "file": "/var/vcap/data/packages/cloud_controller_ng/6d32e116fa47763d6885214954e0d737c28b29e5.1-aa02996eae5e64a4ff823957b8ec5baf64d0b2b5/cloud_controller_ng/lib/cloud_controller/seeds.rb",
    "lineno": 46,
    "log_level": "warn",
    "message": "seeds.system-domain-organization.collision",
    "method": "create_seed_organizations",
    "process_id": 10857,
    "source": "cc.seeds",
    "thread_id": 47214699944340,
    "timestamp": 1460386421.1927507
}

CF release 228, BOSH version 253

Updating quotas with cf update-quota works normally.

[cppforlife]

I'll close this issue here since you've opened one against capi-release. BOSH just passes properties to the releases and it's up to releases to define what happens then. Not sure if it ever was supported by cloud controller to update quotas via manifest.