Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Possible English recombinant descended from Omicron and Delta (UKHSA "signal under monitoring") #422

Closed
yexiao-cheng opened this issue Jan 31, 2022 · 12 comments
Labels
not accepted A proposal for a new lineage has not been accepted recombinant recombinant proposal

Comments

@yexiao-cheng
Copy link

Sequences:
hCoV-19/England/ALDP-2F86D33/2021|EPI_ISL_8166781|2021-12-19
hCoV-19/England/QEUH-312A66E/2022|EPI_ISL_8610834|2022-01-02
hCoV-19/England/ALDP-31AE19E/2022|EPI_ISL_8865709|2022-01-06
hCoV-19/England/ALDP-325CFB2/2022|EPI_ISL_8898412|2022-01-11

The ORF1ab region of these 4 genomes is more similar to Delta, while the remaining regions are more similar to Omicron. It seems that these genomes are recombinants of Delta and Omicron. Or just contamination?

recom

@yexiao-cheng yexiao-cheng changed the title Possible recombinant descended from Omicron and Delta. Possible recombinant descended from Omicron and Delta Jan 31, 2022
@vviala
Copy link

vviala commented Jan 31, 2022

Dear @yexiao-cheng , you must map the sequencing reads of this sample to the assembled genome and look at the regions of interests. No or very low polymorphism indicate there is no contamination. Check for regions with unique Omicron or Delta deletions, they are usually better to find contamination polymorphism in your data. One way to verify your hypothesis is to design primers that will generate an amplicon that will cross from the unique Omicron-like region to the unique Delta-like region and sequence this amplicon to prove its contiguity.

@yexiao-cheng
Copy link
Author

Hi @vviala
Thanks for your advice. It would be very helpful if corresponding deep sequencing data were available. But I only found these consensus sequences on GISAID.
It's also worth noting that these sequences were originated from different labs according to GISAID. Given the similar genomic patterns, I think contamination is less likely.

@vviala
Copy link

vviala commented Jan 31, 2022

I guess they are all from the same originating lab: Wellcome Sanger Institute for the COVID-19 Genomics UK (COG-UK) Consortium. Only the reads info will helps us out with that

@yexiao-cheng
Copy link
Author

Agreed that we need more evidence.

@amniewiadomska
Copy link

I see ambiguous bases in at least 2 of these genomes. May be the result of a mixed sequences (either contamination or co-infection).

@LVerdurme
Copy link

It could be a sequencing bias in co-infected patients: some parts of the genome are better amplified when they are delta (for example around Spike:400) and lead to a "delta-like" spike protein " in a globally omicron fasta. In Europe, especially in France with the intense circulation of delta and Omicron from December 15 to January 15, we saw a lot of samples like that.

@SVN-PhD
Copy link

SVN-PhD commented Feb 3, 2022

Raw reads for these strains are here:
hCoV-19/England/ALDP-2F86D33/2021: https://www.ebi.ac.uk/ena/browser/view/SAMEA12081130
hCoV-19/England/QEUH-312A66E/2022: https://www.ebi.ac.uk/ena/browser/view/SAMEA12286794
hCoV-19/England/ALDP-31AE19E/2022: https://www.ebi.ac.uk/ena/browser/view/SAMEA12516829
hCoV-19/England/ALDP-325CFB2/2022: https://www.ebi.ac.uk/ena/browser/view/SAMEA12531205

@SVN-PhD
Copy link

SVN-PhD commented Feb 13, 2022

UKHSA listed Delta x Omicron as a variant under monitoring/investigation: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/sars-cov-2-variants-of-public-health-interest/sars-cov-2-variants-of-public-health-interest-11-february-2022

@hsnguyen
Copy link

hsnguyen commented Feb 13, 2022

Edit by @corneliusroemer: this comment talks about a different cluster for which an issue has been opened here #437, please continue discussion of the Australian cluster there

We've seen several sequences collected early this year in Queensland, Australia being called Omicron unassigned by Pangolin and show similar patterns: ORF1ab mutations are more like from Delta with high alternate freq. However they're far away from the aforementioned UK sequences (>20 SNPs):

  • Australia/QLD5084/2022 (Illumina)
  • Australia/QLD39476/2022 (ONT low qual.)
  • Australia/QLD37984/2022 (Illumina)
  • Australia/QLD0x00C42F/2022 (Illumina)

Not all of them are available on GISAID so here is the FASTA and VCF

A rough analysis based on scorpio haplotype of above 4 UK sequences and these 4 QLD sequences using AY.4 and BA.1 constellations:

image

suggesting that there're 2 different breakpoints from 2 independent recombinant events for UK and QLD sequences.

The low number of sequences may not strong enough for new lineage atm but will keep update if situation changes.

@hsnguyen
Copy link

hsnguyen commented Feb 14, 2022

Edit by @corneliusroemer: this comment talks about a different cluster for which an issue has been opened here #437, please continue discussion of the Australian cluster there

Additional 3 sequences make it 7 for this small cluster.

  • Australia/QLD0x00C580/2022
  • Australia/QLD5084/2022
  • Australia/QLD37717/2022
  • Australia/QLD37563/2022
  • Australia/QLD39476/2022
  • Australia/QLD37984/2022
  • Australia/QLD0x00C42F/2022

fasta-sequences.zip

@corneliusroemer corneliusroemer changed the title Possible recombinant descended from Omicron and Delta Possible English recombinant descended from Omicron and Delta (UKHSA under investigation) Feb 14, 2022
@corneliusroemer corneliusroemer changed the title Possible English recombinant descended from Omicron and Delta (UKHSA under investigation) Possible English recombinant descended from Omicron and Delta (UKHSA "signal under monitoring") Feb 14, 2022
@thomasppeacock
Copy link

Just confirming that this cluster is one of the two under monitoring in the UK along with #441

@chrisruis
Copy link
Collaborator

Thanks @yexiao-cheng It doesn't look like there's any more genomes from this lineage so will close this for now

@chrisruis chrisruis added not accepted A proposal for a new lineage has not been accepted and removed monitor currently too small, watch for future developments labels May 11, 2022
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
not accepted A proposal for a new lineage has not been accepted recombinant recombinant proposal
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

9 participants