Skip to content

Towards making candidate libraries testable in Compiler Explorer #130

@akrzemi1

Description

@akrzemi1

This is more like an idea, as I do not have a concrete recipe for the moment.
The ultimate goal would be to have libraries that are candidates for inclusion into Boost, especially during the review period, to be testable in an online environment, such as Compiler Explorer.
This would enable the feedback from people who do not have time or capabilities to install a candidate library in their environments.
Potential reviewers are volunteers, have their private lives and they $dayjobs, and the review period is relatively short. They are often put off by the time it is required to perform a review. Writing the report is time consuming itself. Environment setup is an additional unnecessary effort.
Of course, library authors are also volunteers with similar constraints, so burdening them with the additional requirement is also not a good option.
But maybe Boost website could offer an instruction or scripts for making the online access to the testing environment easier. Maybe a hot line channel with Matt Godbolt? Something that would make it easy for library authors to install their library in the testing environment. Or something for the reviewers to do so. Or a server similar in spirit to Compiler Explorer where the candidate libraries can be tested. This would be useful not only during reviews. Official Boost libraries would also benefit from such online demos. This would help developers decide if they want to use Boost.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions