Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Little things broken with #5335 #5499

Closed
Nilvus opened this issue Jun 16, 2020 · 13 comments
Closed

Little things broken with #5335 #5499

Nilvus opened this issue Jun 16, 2020 · 13 comments
Assignees
Labels
bug: pending someone needs to start working on that
Milestone

Comments

@Nilvus
Copy link
Contributor

Nilvus commented Jun 16, 2020

@dterrahe: 2 minor issues shown, probably related to your recent PR #5335.

  • On contrast module, detail line on both modes have the default pointer (white point below slider) not aligned on the left. By default, should be aligned on the left (to 0%) as other ones.
    2020-06-16_19-30

  • On filmic rvb, go to look tab. See contrast slider. Before it was set with 3 digits after point, so for example 1.360 instead of 1.36. It's better for that setting as before. But more of that (maybe related), it was possible to increase/decrease by 0.01 only with mouse wheel. Now it increase/decrease by 0.05. Not suitable for that setting. And if using mouse wheel with Ctrl shortcut, it's only possible to increase by 0.01 but not to decrease.

Expected behavior

Just as before, default pointer on detail in contrast module aligned on the left of the slider
And for filmic rvb, possibility to increase/decrease by 0.01 directly with mouse wheel and so having 3 digits after point instead of 2.

@dterrahe
Copy link
Member

Thanks @Nilvus for the detailed comments. It is very easy to tailor stepsizes and number of digits, so I can add these no sweat. Have you gone over all modules you care most about or shall I wait and include these in a slightly bigger patch?

There definitely other cases where the granularity changed. Sometimes I intentionally didn't replicate the original settings because I wanted confirmation that they were really sensible, rather than just copied through without thought from a different setting. The number of digits sometimes looked crazy for example (for the order of magnitude of the parameter).

@Nilvus
Copy link
Contributor Author

Nilvus commented Jun 16, 2020

Thanks @Nilvus for the detailed comments. It is very easy to tailor stepsizes and number of digits, so I can add these no sweat. Have you gone over all modules you care most about or shall I wait and include these in a slightly bigger patch?

I have quickly gone over modules I care about the most and don't see by now anything else.

There definitely other cases where the granularity changed. Sometimes I intentionally didn't replicate the original settings because I wanted confirmation that they were really sensible, rather than just copied through without thought from a different setting. The number of digits sometimes looked crazy for example (for the order of magnitude of the parameter).

Probably. For contrast I rarely use the third digit but that could sometimes help on this slider.

Another thing: on local contrast, detail string seems to not be translated anymore. I use french translation and we lost (as you can see on screenshot) accent on the e of the string. I update and check fr.po and no more detail string alone on it.

@dterrahe
Copy link
Member

There may indeed be some issues with strings being marked for translation at the moment; working on it #5498

Thanks for the careful testing. Much appreciated!

@TurboGit TurboGit self-assigned this Jun 16, 2020
@TurboGit TurboGit added the bug: pending someone needs to start working on that label Jun 16, 2020
@TurboGit TurboGit added this to the 3.2 milestone Jun 16, 2020
@hgmarty
Copy link

hgmarty commented Jun 16, 2020

Hello,

I have compiled tonight the latest master version of the 3.1 2162.
I have keyboard shortcuts to manage the usual modules as color balance with contrast. The shortcuts are reversed with the + key which decreases the contrast and - which increases it. Same behaviour when I have changed with other touches.

On the other hand, on color balance where I am sure but also on the others, it seems that the step of change is higher, I would say multiplied by two. For example, before saturation with one click went from 100 to 100.5 but now to 101.

Thank you.
Have a nice evening.

@AxelG-DE
Copy link

AxelG-DE commented Jun 16, 2020

* On filmic rvb, go to look tab. See contrast slider. Before it was set with 3 digits after point, so for example 1.360 instead of 1.36. It's better for that setting as before. But more of that (maybe related), it was possible to increase/decrease by 0.01 only with mouse wheel. Now it increase/decrease by 0.05. Not suitable for that setting. And if using mouse wheel with Ctrl shortcut, it's only possible to increase by 0.01 but not to decrease.

Darned; why I did not find that 😢

@TurboGit
Copy link
Member

@dterrahe : Another little thing (maybe related).

On the shadi module (local contrast), the slider highlights and shadows have wrong increment.

  • using scroll gives + or - 50% (it was 1%)
  • using shift-scroll gives + or - more than 200% - don't know it goes from min to max (was 10%)
  • using ctrl-scroll gives + or - 10% (it was not working)

On the details slider a ctrl or scroll seems ok, but ctrl-scroll does nothing.

@TurboGit
Copy link
Member

With #5505 the simple scroll now move the slider by 100%

@dterrahe
Copy link
Member

@TurboGit you mean bilat? Fixing it now. Easy.

That module is a bit funky because two sets of sliders link to the same params field. So the "sensible" defaults are based on "the other one". Meant to adjust for this (thought I had, sorry).

@AxelG-DE
Copy link

Actually several modules appear odd when using mouse-wheel (incl color balance, demosaic and others).

Sorry I did not test this at all, just dragging or typing the numbers to exceed the limits...

@dterrahe
Copy link
Member

@AxelG-DE please provide specific instances. Not just where different from previous, but where now bad. Many thanks. These are easy to fix so I'm collecting a bunch in one PR.

@Nilvus
Copy link
Contributor Author

Nilvus commented Jun 16, 2020

Actually several modules appear odd when using mouse-wheel (incl color balance, demosaic and others).

Could you be more precise by what you mean with odd? color balance works as expected (so as before) with mouse-wheel. I mainly use mouse-wheel to set them. I see no issue on those modules.

@AxelG-DE
Copy link

Could you be more precise by what you mean with odd?

just one excample, unfortuantely there are more:

  • input saturation: normal scroll increments by 1%
  • shift-scroll increments by 10%
  • ctrl-scroll no reaction
    (where contrast fulcrum works as expected)

@TurboGit
Copy link
Member

Fixed, closing.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
bug: pending someone needs to start working on that
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

5 participants