Homographs in slugs for different pages and different languages should not raise MultipleObjectsReturned

[evildmp]

Your site has two sibling pages:

# a page about sticks
/it/bastone
/fr/canne
/en/cane

# a page about dogs
/it/cane
/fr/chien
/en/dog

At present, as soon as you try to publish (it will let you save a draft) the Italian translation, you'll get:

MultipleObjectsReturned at /it/cane/
get() returned more than one Page -- it returned 2!

Issues to be decided:

• should we allow the creation of the slug? We would need to stop ignoring the language prefix when processing URLs.
• if we do, how would we decide what serve when the user asked for /fr/cane/ - should it serve up chien or canne (see We should redirect when serving a "guessed" page #3547 on django CMS's page-guessing behaviour)
• if we don't, we should advise the user of a slug conflict, instead of raising the MultipleObjectsReturned error.

[yakky]

To me the right solution here is to change https://github.com/divio/django-cms/blob/develop/cms/utils/page_resolver.py#L64 to match the path honouring to the current language (so cane will return /it/cane/ if the current language is italian and /en/cane/ if it's english)

[yakky]

@evildmp @ojii @mkoistinen further opinion on this?
I don't think we could handle this in 3.1

[mkoistinen]

I have no further opinion, the way you outlined it above is the correct way this should be done, IMO.

[stale]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

[stale]

This will now be closed due to inactivity, but feel free to reopen it.