dbus-call-method: D-Bus error: "The name org.gnome.Shell was not provided by any .service files"

[yglukhov]

Describe the bug
Getting errors in Messages buffer:

dbus-call-method: D-Bus error: "org.freedesktop.DBus.Error.ServiceUnknown", "The name org.gnome.Shell was not provided by any .service files"

To Reproduce
Open eaf-browser

Expected behavior
No errors in Messages

Versions (please complete the following info):

• Distro and DE/WM: Arch, KDE Plasma, X11
• M-x emacs-version:

Error logs
No errors in *eaf*

Additional context
I'm suspecting the error I'm seeing is because I'm using KDE instead of Gnome?

[manateelazycat]

What's result of (eaf-emacs-running-in-wayland-native) in your system?

[yglukhov]

What's result of (eaf-emacs-running-in-wayland-native) in your system?

nil

[manateelazycat]

Did you running EAF in terminal ?

[yglukhov]

No, I'm running it in emacs gui on KDE, X11.

[manateelazycat]

Strange...

[Szkered]

I am having the same issue. Running emacs gui on Xmonad.

[hirn-lego]

I am having this issue too.
Running emacs gui on qtile with X11

[tylerwolf35]

I am also having this issue with emacs gui on xmonad when I use emacs daemon.

When I do not use emacs daemon, I don't get this issue, however I cannot use eaf as whenever I try to open it it just says "opening in status bar" and nothing happens. If I do open in new window I get the same thing and the new window just has my start screen.

[manateelazycat]

Something wrong on checking DE or WM, that cause Gnome3 dbus check on non-Gnome3.

I use Gnome XWayland, I haven't time to digg other WM recently, sorry guys.

PR are welcome!

[tylerwolf35]

I have been able to get around this error, yet launching an EAF application still loads infinitely.

Should I open a new issue?

[jvdydev]

Just chiming in as someone who found this while troubleshooting for another Emacs user.
For sway users, XDG_CURRENT_DESKTOP may not be set for some reason, so setting that to "sway" should work.

As for other WM/DEs, it seems these two functions seem to be the culprit (or at least one of them):

• eaf--topmost-focus-change in eaf.el (line 1053)
• eaf--get-frame-coordinate in eaf.el (line 1178)

Unless you're on macOS, sway or Hyprland, these default to a dbus call to org.gnome.Shell.

I personally do not use EAF, just figured I'd share my findings.

[EdmondFrank]

Just chiming in as someone who found this while troubleshooting for another Emacs user. For sway users, XDG_CURRENT_DESKTOP may not be set for some reason, so setting that to "sway" should work.

As for other WM/DEs, it seems these two functions seem to be the culprit (or at least one of them):

• eaf--topmost-focus-change in eaf.el (line 1053)
• eaf--get-frame-coordinate in eaf.el (line 1178)

Unless you're on macOS, sway or Hyprland, these default to a dbus call to org.gnome.Shell.

I personally do not use EAF, just figured I'd share my findings.

Indeed it is basically caused by these functions, other WMs can try to refer to this PR #1119 to tweak the implementation.
Generally just implement eaf--topmost-focus-change is enough, for another similar method, there will be a default value and it usually works