Support for Firmata Library (was: Error on uploading firmatta to tiva C)

[cjdg]

when i load the StandardFirmata i get the next error

StandardFirmata.cpp.o: In function setPinModeCallback(unsigned char, int)': StandardFirmata.cpp:(.text._Z18setPinModeCallbackhi+0x5a): undefined reference toServo::attached()'
StandardFirmata.cpp:(.text._Z18setPinModeCallbackhi+0x1ec): undefined reference to Servo::attached()' StandardFirmata.cpp.o: In functionsysexCallback(unsigned char, unsigned char, unsigned char*)':
StandardFirmata.cpp:(.text._Z13sysexCallbackhhPh+0x1d6): undefined reference to `Servo::attached()'
collect2: error: ld returned 1 exit status

[rei-vilo]

Please refer to #384 and #457 and #608.

[chintanp]

So, there is no solution to the error .. correct ? I read those issues, and couldnt find anything relevant.

[rei-vilo]

It seems Firmata has been ported to Energia.

[chintanp]

Does that mean, we dont have to separately download the folder and add it to libraries ? I did as instructed in https://github.com/energia/Energia/tree/master/libraries/Firmata for initialising Firmata example - StandardFirmata, but I got the error as OP.

[rei-vilo]

If you have a look at the Boards.h file, only __TM4C123GH6PM__ i.e. LaunchPad Tiva C Series is supported, not __LM4F120H5QR__ i.e. LaunchPad Stellaris.

Just edit the corresponding line and add the missing board:

#elif (defined(__TM4C123GH6PM__) || defined(__LM4F120H5QR__))

[chintanp]

I am using a TM4C123GXL Launchpad, and when I read the boards.h in the firmata library, it has following definitions in TM4C123GXL section

// Tiva C TM4C123G - EK-TM4C123GXL
#elif defined(TM4C123GH6PM)
#define TOTAL_ANALOG_PINS 13
#define TOTAL_PINS 41
#define VERSION_BLINK_PIN 40
#define IS_PIN_DIGITAL(p) ((p)>=2 && (p)<=TOTAL_PINS && (p)!=16 && (p)!=20 && (p)!=21 && (p)!=22)
#define IS_PIN_ANALOG(p) ((p)>=23 && (p)<=29) || (p==2) || (p==5) || (p==6) || (p==7) || (p==18)
#define IS_PIN_PWM(p) ((p)==2 || (p)==3 || (p)==4 || (p)==7) ||
(p)==14 || (p)==15 || (p)==17 || (p)==19 ||
((p)>=23 && (p)<=26) || (p)==30 ||
((p)>=31 && (p)<=40)
#define IS_PIN_SERVO(p) (IS_PIN_PWM(p) && (p) >= 0 && (p) < MAX_SERVOS)
#define IS_PIN_I2C(p) ((p) == 19 || (p) == 38)
#define PIN_TO_DIGITAL(p) (p)
#define PIN_TO_ANALOG(p) ((p)>=23 && (p)<=26)?(30-(p)):
((p)>=27&&(p)<=29)?(29-p):
((p)==18)?(3):
((p)==2)?(11):
((p)==5)?(9):
((p)==6)?(8):(10)
#define PIN_TO_PWM(p) PIN_TO_DIGITAL(p)
#define PIN_TO_SERVO(p) (p)

What more can I do ?

[chintanp]

Actually, I understood what you meant when I saw the changes you had made to boards.h, even using the new version results in the same error, which I present verbatim:

StandardFirmata.cpp.o: In function `setPinModeCallback(unsigned char, int)':
StandardFirmata.cpp:(.text._Z18setPinModeCallbackhi+0x5a): undefined reference to     `Servo::attached()'
StandardFirmata.cpp:(.text._Z18setPinModeCallbackhi+0x1ec): undefined reference to `Servo::attached()'
StandardFirmata.cpp.o: In function `sysexCallback(unsigned char, unsigned char, unsigned char*)':
StandardFirmata.cpp:(.text._Z13sysexCallbackhhPh+0x1d6): undefined reference to `Servo::attached()'
collect2.exe: error: ld returned 1 exit status

[rei-vilo]

Are you using the servo library?

Try and comment the lines related to the servo on the Firmata library.

Also, check TM4C123GH6PM or __TM4C123GH6PM__ is duly defined by Energia with Serial.println(TM4C123GH6PM);.

The Firmata library hasn't been updated for the last 6 months, so I guess it is not widely used and no longer maintained.

[chintanp]

I am not doing anything with servo. I just want to run the vanilla code as in the example, it just gives me these errors. I tried commenting out the Library: Servo.h, but that creates so many errors, as the code is highly dependent on this library.

I did Serial.println(TM4C123GH6PM); and it worked.

Sorry to bother u, if you are not the maintainer, but suggest keeping the issue open,

[rei-vilo]

The Firmata library isn't part of the compiled Energia.

A simple sketch compiled against the Stellaris LaunchPad as well as other boards throws the error

sketch_jun22a.ino:1:21: fatal error: Firmata.h: No such file or directory
compilation terminated.

#include "Firmata.h"

void setup() { }

void loop() { }

So, IMHO, this library is no longer part of the package.

[rei-vilo]

Adding the Firmata folder manually to the Library sub-folder of the sketchbook makes it available.

Compilation against the Stellaris LaunchPad completes successfully. I can't replicate your issue.

Are you using other libraries that may conflict with Firmata?

[rei-vilo]

Renamed as Support for Firmata Library

[robertinant]

This issue was moved to energia/tivac-core#26