Call for Input: how should we decide whether a PR updating author list of a Final EIP/ERC/RIP be merged or rejected?

[xinbenlv]

Call for Input

Decision: How should we decide whether a PR updating author list of a Final EIP/ERC/RIP be merged or rejected?

• Option 1: approve at editor discretion
• Option 2: approve at editor consensus
• Option 3: approve by lead author or author consensus
• Option 4: other, please suggest

Method: Rough Consensus
Deadline: April 29th, 2024

Background

#325 (comment)

[SamWilsn]

I don't think modifying a final proposal should be any different than any other potentially contentious decision: open a rough consensus call for input.

[g11tech]

simple reject call for input as well

[SamWilsn]

@xinbenlv's preferred option is 3 I think?

[xinbenlv]

I recognize @g11tech and @SamWilsn 's preferences to use call for input. While I reserve my preference, I am ok with proceed with majority view.