EIPIP Meeting 62 Agenda

[poojaranjan]

Date and Time

Wednesday, August 10, 2022, at 14:00 UTC

Location

Zoom: TBA in the Discord #eip-editing channel

YouTube Live Stream/Recording: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL4cwHXAawZxpLrRIkDlBjDUUrGgF91pQw

Agenda

1. Make EIP authorship depend on ENS

2. From GitHub Issue or Pull Request

1. How should we pick EIP numbers? ethereum/EIPs#5294
2. Fix EIP Bot
3. Use settings.yml ethereum/EIPs#5414 & Add settings.yml ethereum/EIPs#5422 Discussion Thread
4. Update EIP-1: Add License Checker ethereum/EIPs#5379
5. Add ECH Discord Channel to EIP Page Index ethereum/EIPs#5415
6. EIP editors should explain that ERC was renamed to EIP ethereum/EIPs#5424
7. Create an EIP External Link Archive ethereum/EIPs#5408

Misc.

• PandaPip1 added as a maintainer of the EIP-Bot repository. Discord
• Remove Contributors section from README

3. EIP bots related discussion, updates, agreement on merging PRs & closing Issues.

• eip-bot Issues and Pull Request
  • Remove contributors list ethereum/EIP-Bot#111 (Doesn't change code)
  • Remove Outdated Assertions ethereum/EIP-Bot#109 (Fully E2E tested, confirmed working)
  • Require multiple editor approvals to merge unknown files ethereum/EIP-Bot#105 (Added test cases, they pass)

4. Past meeting discussion continued

a. One-time NFT Sale of unused EIP numbers Ref: Issue
b. Meta EIP for the Executable Spec process for Core EIPs

5. EIPs Insight - Monthly EIPs status reporting.

6. EIP editor apprenticeship meeting

• Meeting 23

7. Review action items from the previous meeting

• Sam Wilson and Tim Beiko will create a Meta EIP for the Executable Spec process before showing the proposal to the core devs. Remaining EIP editors to give their view on using the executable spec in the EIP process

Next meeting - Aug 24, 2022

(Anything else, please add a comment)

[gcolvin]

I must have missed a some discussion on EIP vs ERC, as it seems we have made a decision I didn't noticed go by and don't agree with.

[poojaranjan]

Closing in favor of #170

[xinbenlv]

I must have missed a some discussion on EIP vs ERC, as it seems we have made a decision I didn't noticed go by and don't agree with.

I think the summary is that the EIPIP meeting have not converge to a consensus on whether to refer to EIP or ERC yet.