Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Feb 8, 2018. It is now read-only.

(1.0.5) small suggestions, many #321

Closed
drandreaskrueger opened this issue Jun 22, 2016 · 2 comments
Closed

(1.0.5) small suggestions, many #321

drandreaskrueger opened this issue Jun 22, 2016 · 2 comments

Comments

@drandreaskrueger
Copy link

drandreaskrueger commented Jun 22, 2016

First impressions of mix-ide

Great tool! Really like it.

Sorry if the following are newb problems. A fresh perspective helps sometimes.

My system is Debian 8 (my manual: ethereum_debian8.txt.)

Some suggestions:


Pressing "debug transaction":

Segmentation fault with:
qrc:/qml/Watchers.qml:79: Error: Cannot assign [undefined] to bool
qrc:/qml/Watchers.qml:79: Error: Cannot assign [undefined] to bool

had to restart it.


Starting mix-ide, intuitive first step (with the sample contract) is to use the HTML page (with the lilac background).

The "query get" works, great!
But "Store 17 Save" results in a yellow-red "web3.js - line 3885 - Uncaught Error: Invalid address".
Have I missed anything?

EDIT (-: web3.eth.defaultAccount = web3.eth.accounts[0]

Yes I know, RTFM; but once a GUI matures, not needed anymore.

Suggestion, check at start:

if not web3.eth.defaultAccount: 
    yes = alert ("defaultAccount not set. Shall I set it for you?")
    if yes:
        web3.eth.defaultAccount = web3.eth.accounts[0]

Before, instead I had to

1 press the PLUS
2 add transaction
3 transact with contract
4 function set()
5 v 17
6 ok
7 press the PLUS
8 Seal block

right?

--> Please make two buttons of the one PLUS:

1 add transaction
2 seal block

Easier to use, and to understand.


Inside "add transaction":
Default "Type of transaction" --> "Transact with contract"
not "create contract" (because the latter is used only once).


The Debian 8 rendering of Qt window and dialogs has choosen a different(-from-windows) font?
Because most your default window & panel sizes are too small, so they all have scrollbars. Only surface issue, but still.

EDIT: Later found the menu "Decrease Application Fontsize". Helps.
Default smaller?


When I call Sample.set() it returns a value - but I cannot see that value anywhere.

until I
1 find the tx with the call
2 find the tiny down-triangle at the right, which (on Debian) is half-hidden
3 click the triangle
4 scroll down
5 find the gray "Output"
-->
output:

undefined 17

== many steps.

Please introduce one more panel, showing return results.


Everything below is the "Rating"-DApp from the mix-tutorial.


https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/Mix:-The-DApp-IDE#setting-up-scenario

Manual: "Apply changes" --> "Press 'update'"


Crash

☍ ℹ 23:23:56.371|Thread (pooled) Imported and best 2 (# 2 ). Has 0 siblings. Route: [#cfb7f0ae…, #ca9e68f7…]
qml: {"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"eth_call","params":[{"to":"0xf025d81196b72fba60a1d4dddad12eeb8360d828","data":"0x6d4ce63c","from":"0x38f388fadf4a6a35c61c3f88194ec5ae162c8944"},"latest"],"id":7}
qml: {"id":7,"jsonrpc":"2.0","result":"0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000011"}
Segmentation fault


Crash

when copypasting into the "Store" field

qml: {"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"eth_call","params":[{"to":"0xf025d81196b72fba60a1d4dddad12eeb8360d828","data":"0x6c71d01d4669676874436c75620000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","from":"0x38f388fadf4a6a35c61c3f88194ec5ae162c8944"},"latest"],"id":26}
qml: {"id":26,"jsonrpc":"2.0","result":"0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000"}
Segmentation fault


Typing into the 'query' field (on lilac HTML page) is slow. And caused that crash ^

Why immediately query? Wait until I finish typing, and show a "submit" button?


Deploy to network:

Pick scenario to deploy: name shown is "New_scenario_1", not my renamed name.


No message in GUI when account is not

--unlock "0"

Seen that in cosmo.

Show password dialog if not unlocked?


Make blue "Deploy contracts" column wider. Not all text readable.


"contracts deployment verified" - great. Has worked.

First I overlooked step 3. Then found package.
Idea: Perhaps auto-start step 3, when verified?

When all ready, make "cancel" button into "OK", or "ready", or "leave".


Simplemost instructions in package would be nice, something like:

cd package/www
geth attach
loadScript("deployment.js")
RC = contracts["Rating"].contract
RC.setRating.sendTransaction("matrix", "87", {from: eth.coinbase})
RC.ratings("matrix")

(for user data, perhaps use scenario input?)


Some of my ideas good?

Great tool, very happy about it. Keep up the good work!

@drandreaskrueger
Copy link
Author

drandreaskrueger commented Jun 24, 2016

Just learned in gitter that this is "slated for death", so I stop my list of improvements. But this pt2 I had already typed.


This is a follow up on #321


feature request: Larger/choosable font size in code editor


Deploy Step 2: ... press Deploy Scenarion

Idea: As soon as the TXid is known, show it in the GUI.
Then I can check e.g. etherchain for confirmations etc


Deploy Step 3:

"Save packaged DApp to": "..." copypaste button does nothing


qml: Closing project
Segmentation fault


What is the key to repeat a search?
Suggestion: New menu ... Help ... keyboard shortcuts.
Or: Introduce "Edit" menu for copypaste, find, replace, etc.


... 21:33:37.072|mix-ide Closing blockchain DB
ℹ 21:33:37.073|mix-ide Killing blockchain & extras database (WithExisting::Kill).
... 21:33:37.607|mix-ide Opened blockchain DB. Latest: #ab0d1405… (rebuild not needed)
ℹ 21:33:37.608|mix-ide Killing state database (WithExisting::Kill).
... 21:33:37.853|mix-ide Opened state DB.
Segmentation fault


qml: editor: qrc:///qml/html/codeeditor.js:350:Uncaught TypeError: undefined is not a function
qml: editor: qrc:///qml/html/codeeditor.js:350:Uncaught TypeError: undefined is not a function
qml: editor: qrc:///qml/html/codeeditor.js:350:Uncaught TypeError: undefined is not a function
qml: editor: qrc:///qml/html/codeeditor.js:350:Uncaught TypeError: undefined is not a function
Segmentation fault


gitter ethereum/mix
bobsummerwill ...
Also be aware that Mix is slated for death, to be replace by remix. https://blog.ethereum.org/2016/05/04/c-dev-update-announcing-remix/


What about maintaining a positive list of tools that will have long term support?

@yann300
Copy link
Contributor

yann300 commented Aug 11, 2016

The case of mix is a bit special. and I am pretty sure that remix will stay for long.
I've created an issue in the remix repo https://github.com/ethereum/remix/issues/84
This might be helpful for remix as well.

@yann300 yann300 closed this as completed Aug 11, 2016
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants