Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Create 221022-retweet-shibcmemes-meme.tweet #116

Closed
wants to merge 1 commit into from
Closed

Create 221022-retweet-shibcmemes-meme.tweet #116

wants to merge 1 commit into from

Conversation

decentdanoz
Copy link

Sorry for any mess I might have made with this - I am but a simple shib, still learning how to do serious things :)

@github-actions
Copy link
Contributor

Found 1 new .tweet file(s)

✅ Valid Tweet

Retweeting https://twitter.com/ShibcMemes/status/1583632771477823488

This tweet was suggested by @shibcmemes via #ETCtweets.


Preview using 20b3322 generated by Twitter, together!

Copy link
Member

@TheCrowbill TheCrowbill left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

While funny, I don't think this meets even the loosest criteria for a retweet.

@decentdanoz
Copy link
Author

decentdanoz commented Oct 22, 2022

#90 (comment)

"presumably with less restrictions and more memes and/or project promotion."

I am glad you think it's funny - I didn't mean to be rude (we're clean and tidy and do respect the "lawn").
It's both intended as a light hearted meme and some promotion for both the eco and SHIBC.

I fail to see how: https://github.com/ethereumclassic/tweets-etc_network/blob/main/tweets/221020-god.tweet "ETC is a gift from God" is any better, divisive, really.

@IstoraMandiri
Copy link
Collaborator

IstoraMandiri commented Oct 22, 2022

When submitting tweets from #ETCtweets, please copy the content of the tweet rather than retweeting.

I think this would be OK if it was specific to ETC rather than Shiba Classic.

Also, only tweets submitted via #ETCtweets should include the "This tweet was suggested by..." follow up.

@decentdanoz
Copy link
Author

decentdanoz commented Oct 22, 2022

I think this would be OK if it was specific to ETC rather than Shiba Classic.

It tells the world why we're here on ETC, and why that's important

Code is Law isn't a slogan or a meme, it's a righteous statement and commitment - it's serious.

I don't consider it a gift, but a responsibility.

That's the juxtaposition - the serious meme, and SHIBC intends to "bark" this at everyone.

No disrespect was intended with this, just some meme flavour, ie: coleslaw, code is lawn, etc.

We do offer other meme gems of a less serious calibre: https://twitter.com/ShibcMemes/status/1583042491515015171 but the one submitted is definitely the one that has the effect.

@IstoraMandiri
Copy link
Collaborator

IstoraMandiri commented Oct 22, 2022

It tells the world why we're here on ETC, and why that's important

This twitter account is about Ethereum Classic itself, and we are avoiding promoting third party projects unless linked to via the ethereumclassic.org website, as it contains disclaimers.

IMO it would be fine if it wasn't promoting Shiba Classic, but then the imagery wouldn't be that relevant.

Sorry this isn't clear in the rules yet, but we are waiting for community approval on ethereumclassic/tweets-eth_classic#18 to get it merged, which this account will extend from.

@decentdanoz
Copy link
Author

decentdanoz commented Oct 22, 2022

This twitter account is about Ethereum Classic itself, and we are avoiding promoting third party projects unless linked to via the ethereumclassic.org website, as it contains disclaimers.

So it's a centralised thing to go through another centralised thing to hit Twitter, which is more decentralised than both 1) applying for the website (which we'll do, sure) and 2) using this repo, something you put on Twitter to encourage engagement with - which I have!

Today I've uploaded all of the great SHIBC memes and ETC image resources to GitHub so other people can do the same for whatever they are working on, and continue to grow and promote the ecosystem - hopefully this can benefit the eco in itself.

But where does promoting God fall into this? Which God? Religious baiting is some of the most known troll activity on the internet (even asking this, I feel like I'm trolling). That's the optics of that Tweet.

It completely undermines the effort and dedication to maintaining "Code is Law" - it wasn't a gift, it was responsibility forced when a centralised group decided to roll back what was meant to be immutable, few people stood up and more continue to join - that's more righteous than any religious/God based crusade I've ever learned of.

You could interact with projects on your ecosystem instead you're gatekeeping even retweeting a meme.

IMO it would be fine if it wasn't promoting Shiba Classic.

It promotes ETC and SHIBC, and ETC is first - it's not my fault this dawgy can poop gems, again, we tidy up after it, we bring our bags.

I close this out with this, at this point, I don't even care for the meme. It's not even funny.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

None yet

3 participants