"In case of a failed verification (RED), the app should only display the reason for the fail, including details such as the specific contents or technical details of the certificate that are preventing the successful verification

[RalicaY]

Describe the bug

Despite a failed verification, the verifier app shows the certificate data set, additionally to the reason for failure.

Expected behaviour

In case of a failed verification (RED), the app should only display the reason for the fail including details such as the specific contents or technical details of the certificate that are preventing the successful verification.

Steps to reproduce the issue

1. Open verifier app;
2. Scan a QR-Code for an invalid certificate.

Technical details

iPhone 8 plus v. Lutz, Model MQ8P2ZD/A, iOS 14.4

Possible Fix

Additional context

[yspreen]

As per @joerg-oppermann-tsi

[rebwalz]

bug is still open. should be fixed in one of the next versions.

[yspreen]

We decided not to fix it since the logic to omit all non-error fields when there is some other error is a bit too much... how does Android handle this

[rebwalz]

see #39
But this behavior is also wrong.

[yspreen]

Removing the label since it's not a "bug", as the behavior is expected but not according to the current specification.

Since the specification is inconsistent, we need to work that out before continuing work on this ticket

[azotlichid]

Verification seems to fail even on some valid certificates. Refusing to give the reason for failure will be disastrous, as several national authorities seem to rely on this implementation.

[RalicaY]

At the moment the iOS and the Android version diverge.

Please, implement the same behaviour in iOS as it is in Android or a decision that the difference should remain should be communicated, in order to close this ticket.