Fastlane deliver ignoring increment_version_number for Xcode 13.4.1

[michaelmoneypenny]

Discussed in #20464

^{Originally posted by michaelmoneypenny July 13, 2022}
For some reason fastlane has started ignoring the dynamic version number we pass in to the pipeline and using the marketing version defined in xcodeproj (9.9.9 in my case)

We haven't changed anything in fastlane around versioning (we have updated Xcode to 13.4.1 and upped the minor version of the app)

What's strange is we can see the correct version at various stages in the pipeline logs but when it gets to deliver it chooses 9.9.9.

Update - reverting to Xcode 13.1 and the correct version is set again - is this a bug or something I need to configure on the build machine for 13.4.1?

[16:34:28]: $ cd /Users/****/appname && agvtool new-marketing-version 2.11.1
[16:34:28]: ▸ Setting CFBundleShortVersionString of project appname to:
[16:34:28]: ▸ 2.11.1.
[16:34:28]: ▸ Updating CFBundleShortVersionString in Info.plist(s)...
[16:34:28]: ▸ Updated CFBundleShortVersionString in "appname.xcodeproj/../Info.plist" to 2.11.1

+--------------------------------------+-----------------------------------+
|                         deliver 2.207.0 Summary                          |
+--------------------------------------+-----------------------------------+
| ipa                                  | ./build/appname.ipa         |
| precheck_include_in_app_purchases    | false                             |
| submit_for_review                    | false                             |
| force                                | true                              |
| metadata_path                        | .fastlane/metadata                |
| api_key                              | ********                          |
| screenshots_path                     | ./.fastlane/screenshots           |
| app_version                          | 9.9.9                    

| LATEST_TESTFLIGHT_VERSION          | 2.11.1                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| BUILD_NUMBER                       | 1                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            |
| VERSION_NUMBER                     | 2.11.1                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| IPA_OUTPUT_PATH                    | /Users/****/build/appname.ipa                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| XCODEBUILD_ARCHIVE                 | ./archive/appname2022-07-12 16.35.38.xcarchive                                                                                                                                                                                        |
                                                                                                                                                                        |
+------------------------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
[16:42:44]: Error uploading ipa file: 
 [Transporter Error Output]: ERROR ITMS-90189: Redundant Binary Upload. You've already uploaded a build with build number '1' for version number '9.9.9'.

Section of fast file (we haven't changed anything here)

  increment_build_number_from_appstore(
      app_version: options[:app_version],
      asc_key_id: options[:asc_key_id],
      asc_issuer_id: options[:asc_issuer_id],
      asc_key: options[:asc_key])
  increment_version_number(
      version_number: options[:app_version],
      xcodeproj: @xcode_project)
  build_app(
      scheme: @scheme,
      export_method: "app-store",
      export_options: {
         provisioningProfiles: {
           "com.xxxxx" => "match AppStore com.xxxxx
         }
      },
      configuration: "Release",
      include_symbols: true,
      project: @xcode_project,
      build_path: @archive_directory,
      output_directory: @output_directory,
      cloned_source_packages_path: options[:cloned_source_packages_path],
      output_name: "appname")
  deliver(
      ipa: @ipa,
      precheck_include_in_app_purchases: false,
      submit_for_review: false,
      force: true,
      metadata_path: ".fastlane/metadata")

Versioning section in Xcode:

Fastlane env:

✅ fastlane environment ✅

Stack

Key	Value
OS	12.4
Ruby	2.6.8
Bundler?	false
Git	git version 2.32.1 (Apple Git-133)
Installation Source	/usr/local/bin/fastlane
Host	macOS 12.4 (21F79)
Ruby Lib Dir	/System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/2.6/usr/lib
OpenSSL Version	LibreSSL 2.8.3
Is contained	false
Is homebrew	false
Is installed via Fabric.app	false
Xcode Path	/Applications/Xcode.app/Contents/Developer/
Xcode Version	13.4.1
Swift Version	5.6.1

System Locale

Variable	Value
LANG	en_GB.UTF-8	✅
LC_ALL
LANGUAGE

fastlane files:

No Fastfile found

No Appfile found

fastlane gems

Gem	Version	Update-Status
fastlane	2.207.0	✅ Up-To-Date

Loaded fastlane plugins:

No plugins Loaded

Loaded gems

Gem	Version
did_you_mean	1.3.0
rouge	2.0.7
xcpretty	0.3.0
terminal-notifier	2.0.0
unicode-display_width	1.8.0
terminal-table	1.8.0
plist	3.6.0
addressable	2.8.0
multipart-post	2.0.0
word_wrap	1.0.0
optparse	0.1.1
tty-screen	0.8.1
tty-cursor	0.7.1
tty-spinner	0.9.3
artifactory	3.0.15
babosa	1.0.4
colored	1.2
highline	2.0.3
commander	4.6.0
faraday-cookie_jar	0.0.7
gh_inspector	1.1.3
mini_magick	4.11.0
naturally	2.2.1
rubyzip	2.3.2
security	0.1.3
xcpretty-travis-formatter	1.0.1
dotenv	2.7.6
simctl	1.6.8
rexml	3.2.5
nanaimo	0.3.0
colored2	3.1.2
claide	1.1.0
CFPropertyList	3.0.5
atomos	0.1.3
xcodeproj	1.22.0
public_suffix	4.0.7
excon	0.92.3
ruby2_keywords	0.0.5
faraday-retry	1.0.3
faraday-rack	1.0.0
faraday-patron	1.0.0
faraday-net_http_persistent	1.2.0
faraday-net_http	1.0.1
faraday-multipart	1.0.4
faraday-httpclient	1.0.1
faraday-excon	1.1.0
faraday-em_synchrony	1.0.0
faraday-em_http	1.0.0
faraday	1.10.0
unf_ext	0.0.8.2
unf	0.1.4
domain_name	0.5.20190701
http-cookie	1.0.5
faraday_middleware	1.2.0
fastimage	2.2.6
json	2.6.2
bundler	2.2.32
jwt	2.4.1
webrick	1.7.0
httpclient	2.8.3
multi_json	1.15.0
signet	0.17.0
os	1.1.4
memoist	0.16.2
googleauth	1.2.0
mini_mime	1.1.2
retriable	3.1.2
trailblazer-option	0.1.2
declarative	0.0.20
uber	0.1.0
representable	3.2.0
google-apis-core	0.7.0
google-apis-playcustomapp_v1	0.10.0
google-apis-androidpublisher_v3	0.24.0
rake	13.0.6
digest-crc	0.6.4
google-apis-storage_v1	0.17.0
google-apis-iamcredentials_v1	0.13.0
google-cloud-errors	1.2.0
google-cloud-env	1.6.0
google-cloud-core	1.6.0
google-cloud-storage	1.37.0
emoji_regex	3.2.3
aws-eventstream	1.2.0
aws-sigv4	1.5.0
aws-partitions	1.603.0
jmespath	1.6.1
aws-sdk-core	3.131.2
aws-sdk-kms	1.57.0
aws-sdk-s3	1.114.0
forwardable	1.2.0
logger	1.3.0
date	2.0.0
stringio	0.0.2
ipaddr	1.2.2
openssl	2.1.2
zlib	1.0.0
mutex_m	0.1.0
ostruct	0.1.0
strscan	1.0.0
io-console	0.4.7
fileutils	1.1.0
etc	1.0.1
libxml-ruby	3.2.1
psych	3.1.0

generated on: 2022-07-13

[fastlane-bot]

It seems like you have not included the output of fastlane env
To make it easier for us help you resolve this issue, please update the issue to include the output of fastlane env 👍

[max-ott]

I think there's a new option in Xcode that is called "automatic version numbering" or similar. Here Xcode will "hijack" and automatically increase the build/version number by itself. Probably we need to switch to some kind of manual numbering here, which has not been implemented.

[WilliamAlexander]

Same-ish problem on Xcode 13.4.1
Seems to be related to no info.plist file now as this is generated (although you can still go back to having a real plist file)
The MARKETING_VERSION is used for the version and this is no longer incremented

[michaelmoneypenny]

Should manually setting the version in xcode work for now then? So I can still build with 13.4.1

[fastlane-bot]

There hasn't been any activity on this issue recently. Due to the high number of incoming GitHub notifications, we have to clean some of the old issues, as many of them have already been resolved with the latest updates.

Please make sure to update to the latest fastlane version and check if that solves the issue. Let us know if that works for you by adding a comment 👍

Friendly reminder: contributions are always welcome! Check out CONTRIBUTING.md for more information on how to help with fastlane and feel free to tackle this issue yourself 💪

This issue will be auto-closed if there is no reply within 1 month.

[michaelmoneypenny]

Just adding that problem persists on latest fastlane + Xcode 14.0.1

[darrylyoung]

I'm currently setting up fastlane, and I came across this issue as well. The only solution I've found is to use the fastlane-plugin-versioning plugin. In the docs, they mention supporting $(MARKETING_VERSION).

[michaelmoneypenny]

Thanks for this, it would be good to get some clarification on whether this is going to be handled in a future version of fastlane or is something we'll need to accommodate ourselves - I currently manually set the marketing (and any extension) version in Xcode but it feels rubbish :)

[fastlane-bot]

There hasn't been any activity on this issue recently. Due to the high number of incoming GitHub notifications, we have to clean some of the old issues, as many of them have already been resolved with the latest updates.

Please make sure to update to the latest fastlane version and check if that solves the issue. Let us know if that works for you by adding a comment 👍

Friendly reminder: contributions are always welcome! Check out CONTRIBUTING.md for more information on how to help with fastlane and feel free to tackle this issue yourself 💪

This issue will be auto-closed if there is no reply within 1 month.

[Ayonge]

We started encountering this but with the build number, it always gets set to (1) for some reason. Is there a fix for this? I tried setting Xcode to 13.1 but no success.