org create command returns different results in json depending on command syntax

[Brian-Triplett]

Summary

When you run sfdx org create scratch <other args> --json the orgId field returned in the results json output was previously the created scratch org’s id (00D....). However, the "orgId" node recently changed to be the scratch org record id 2SR*****. Interestingly using the same sfdx cli version, if I run sfdx force:org:create the orgId returned in the results json output is the actual org Id 00D*****. It seems like something with the new command format vs. old so maybe a bug?

Steps To Reproduce:

1. Run sfdx org create scratch --json command and examine result json
2. Run sfdx force:org:create and compare the ordId result

Expected result

Expected the ordId field to remain the scratch org Id (00D...)

Actual result

ScratchOrg record in DevHub is returned (2SR....).

System Information

sfdx force:org:create -f config/project-scratch-def.json -d 1 --json
{
  "status": 0,
  "result": {
    "username": "test-h91ejsplehpc@example.com",
    "scratchOrgInfo": {
      "attributes": {
        "type": "ScratchOrgInfo",
        "url": "/services/data/v57.0/sobjects/ScratchOrgInfo/2SR3n000000HRduGAG"
      },
      "Id": "2SR3n000000HRduGAG",
      "OwnerId": "005a000000AGU0pAAH",
      "IsDeleted": false,
      "Name": "00371243",
      "CurrencyIsoCode": "USD",
      "CreatedDate": "2023-05-09T18:37:58.000+0000",
      "CreatedById": "005a000000AGU0pAAH",
      "LastModifiedDate": "2023-05-09T18:38:30.000+0000",
      "LastModifiedById": "00530000005lmrRAAQ",
      "SystemModstamp": "2023-05-09T18:38:30.000+0000",
      "LastViewedDate": "2023-05-09T18:37:58.000+0000",
      "LastReferencedDate": "2023-05-09T18:37:58.000+0000",
      "Edition": "Partner Developer",
      "Username": null,
      "AdminEmail": null,
      "OrgName": "force-nPORTAL",
      "DurationDays": 1,
      "ConnectedAppConsumerKey": "PlatformCLI",
      "ConnectedAppCallbackUrl": "http://localhost:1717/OauthRedirect",
      "Namespace": "nPORTAL",
      "Features": "API;AuthorApex;Communities;DebugApex;PlatformEncryption",
      "Snapshot": null,
      "Country": "US",
      "Language": "en_US",
      "Instance": null,
      "Package2AncestorIds": null,
      "SourceOrg": null,
      "HasSampleData": true,
      "Release": "Current",
      "SignupUsername": "test-h91ejsplehpc@example.com",
      "Status": "Active",
      "ErrorCode": null,
      "ScratchOrg": "00D8G0000006s7k",
      "SignupInstance": "CS219",
      "AuthCode": "*****",
      "SignupCountry": "US",
      "SignupLanguage": "en_US",
      "SignupEmail": "******",
      "SignupTrialDays": 1,
      "LoginUrl": "https://platform-force-7271-dev-ed.scratch.my.salesforce.com/",
      "Description": "force-nPORTAL",
      "ExpirationDate": "2023-05-10",
      "LastLoginDate": null,
      "DeletedBy": null,
      "DeletedDate": null
    },
    "authFields": {
      "accessToken": "*****",
      "instanceUrl": "https://platform-force-7271-dev-ed.scratch.my.salesforce.com",
      "orgId": "00D8G0000006s7kUAA",
      "username": "test-h91ejsplehpc@example.com",
      "loginUrl": "https://CS219.salesforce.com",
      "refreshToken": "*****",
      "clientId": "PlatformCLI",
      "isDevHub": false,
      "devHubUsername": "kevin.watson@ncino.com",
      "created": "1683657478000",
      "expirationDate": "2023-05-10",
      "createdOrgInstance": "CS219",
      "snapshot": null,
      "instanceApiVersion": "57.0",
      "instanceApiVersionLastRetrieved": "5/9/2023, 2:38:32 PM",
      "tracksSource": true
    },
    "warnings": [],
    "orgId": "00D8G0000006s7kUAA"
  },
  "warnings": []
}


#################################################


sfdx org create scratch -f config/project-scratch-def.json --json
{
  "status": 0,
  "result": {
    "username": "test-ahkksl3yg3qc@example.com",
    "scratchOrgInfo": {
      "attributes": {
        "type": "ScratchOrgInfo",
        "url": "/services/data/v57.0/sobjects/ScratchOrgInfo/2SR3n000000HRe9GAG"
      },
      "Id": "2SR3n000000HRe9GAG",
      "OwnerId": "005a000000AGU0pAAH",
      "IsDeleted": false,
      "Name": "00371246",
      "CurrencyIsoCode": "USD",
      "CreatedDate": "2023-05-09T18:40:31.000+0000",
      "CreatedById": "005a000000AGU0pAAH",
      "LastModifiedDate": "2023-05-09T18:44:46.000+0000",
      "LastModifiedById": "00530000005lmrRAAQ",
      "SystemModstamp": "2023-05-09T18:44:46.000+0000",
      "LastViewedDate": "2023-05-09T18:44:46.000+0000",
      "LastReferencedDate": "2023-05-09T18:44:46.000+0000",
      "Edition": "Partner Developer",
      "Username": null,
      "AdminEmail": null,
      "OrgName": "force-nPORTAL",
      "DurationDays": 7,
      "ConnectedAppConsumerKey": "PlatformCLI",
      "ConnectedAppCallbackUrl": "http://localhost:1717/OauthRedirect",
      "Namespace": "nPORTAL",
      "Features": "API;AuthorApex;Communities;DebugApex;PlatformEncryption",
      "Snapshot": null,
      "Country": "US",
      "Language": "en_US",
      "Instance": null,
      "Package2AncestorIds": null,
      "SourceOrg": null,
      "HasSampleData": true,
      "Release": "Current",
      "SignupUsername": "******",
      "Status": "Active",
      "ErrorCode": null,
      "ScratchOrg": "00D52000000ZsvS",
      "SignupInstance": "CS170",
      "AuthCode": "*****",
      "SignupCountry": "US",
      "SignupLanguage": "en_US",
      "SignupEmail": "********",
      "SignupTrialDays": 7,
      "LoginUrl": "https://strawberry-sagittarius-2235-dev-ed.scratch.my.salesforce.com/",
      "Description": "force-nPORTAL",
      "ExpirationDate": "2023-05-16",
      "LastLoginDate": null,
      "DeletedBy": null,
      "DeletedDate": null
    },
    "authFields": {
      "accessToken": "****",
      "instanceUrl": "https://strawberry-sagittarius-2235-dev-ed.scratch.my.salesforce.com",
      "orgId": "00D52000000ZsvSEAS",
      "username": "****",
      "loginUrl": "https://CS170.salesforce.com",
      "refreshToken": "******",
      "clientId": "PlatformCLI",
      "isDevHub": false,
      "devHubUsername": "kevin.watson@ncino.com",
      "created": "1683657631000",
      "expirationDate": "2023-05-16",
      "createdOrgInstance": "CS170",
      "snapshot": null,
      "instanceApiVersion": "57.0",
      "instanceApiVersionLastRetrieved": "5/9/2023, 2:44:48 PM",
      "tracksSource": true
    },
    "warnings": [],
    "orgId": "2SR3n000000HRe9GAG"
  },
  "warnings": []
}

[github-actions]

Thank you for filing this issue. We appreciate your feedback and will review the issue as soon as possible. Remember, however, that GitHub isn't a mechanism for receiving support under any agreement or SLA. If you require immediate assistance, contact Salesforce Customer Support.

[Kevmo92]

It's odd the field orgId would not have the actual org id but the org record id instead. Seems like a goof.

[mshanemc]

yep, that's a bug!

[git2gus]

This issue has been linked to a new work item: W-13191817

[mshanemc]

fix is now live in all the current releases, thanks for reporting