Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
Improve trait safety documentation (#283)
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
For each of our unsafe traits, clarify who can skip reading the Safety
section.

For each of our unsafe traits (except for `Unaligned`):
- Clarify that it must be sound to construct `&[u8]` and `&T` to the
  same memory region (this addresses #8)
- Clarify that, in order to implement the trait, the type's fields need
  to satisfy the same requirements, but don't actually need to implement
  the trait
- Clarify that, in order to implement the trait, the type must not
  contain any `UnsafeCell`s

Closes #8
  • Loading branch information
joshlf committed Sep 2, 2023
1 parent b724152 commit c979289
Showing 1 changed file with 88 additions and 20 deletions.
108 changes: 88 additions & 20 deletions src/lib.rs
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -215,19 +215,40 @@ mod zerocopy {
///
/// # Safety
///
/// If `T: FromZeroes`, then unsafe code may assume that it is sound to treat
/// any initialized sequence of zero bytes of length `size_of::<T>()` as a `T`.
/// *This section describes what is required in order for `T: FromZeroes`, and
/// what unsafe code may assume of such types. `#[derive(FromZeroes)]` only
/// permits types which satisfy these requirements. If you don't plan on
/// implementing `FromZeroes` manually, and you don't plan on writing unsafe
/// code that operates on `FromZeroes` types, then you don't need to read this
/// section.*
///
/// If `T: FromZeroes`, then unsafe code may assume that:
/// - It is sound to treat any initialized sequence of zero bytes of length
/// `size_of::<T>()` as a `T`.
/// - Given `b: &[u8]` where `b.len() == size_of::<T>()`, `b` is aligned to
/// `align_of::<T>()`, and `b` contains only zero bytes, it is sound to
/// construct a `t: &T` at the same address as `b`, and it is sound for both
/// `b` and `t` to be live at the same time.
///
/// If a type is marked as `FromZeroes` which violates this contract, it may
/// cause undefined behavior.
///
/// If a type has the following properties, then it is safe to implement
/// If a type has the following properties, then it is sound to implement
/// `FromZeroes` for that type:
/// - If the type is a struct, all of its fields must implement `FromZeroes`
/// - If the type is a struct, all of its fields must satisfy the requirements
/// to be `FromZeroes` (they do not actually have to be `FromZeroes`).
/// - If the type is an enum, it must be C-like (meaning that all variants have
/// no fields) and it must have a variant with a discriminant of `0` (see [the
/// reference] for a description of how discriminant values are chosen)
/// no fields) and it must have a variant with a discriminant of `0`. See [the
/// reference] for a description of how discriminant values are chosen.
/// - The type must not contain any [`UnsafeCell`]s (this is required in order
/// for it to be sound to construct a `&[u8]` and a `&T` to the same region of
/// memory). The type may contain references or pointers to `UnsafeCell`s so
/// long as those values can themselves be initialized from zeroes
/// (`FromZeroes` is not currently implemented for, e.g.,
/// `Option<&UnsafeCell<_>>`, but it could be one day).
///
/// [the reference]: https://doc.rust-lang.org/reference/items/enumerations.html#custom-discriminant-values-for-fieldless-enumerations
/// [`UnsafeCell`]: core::cell::UnsafeCell
///
/// # Rationale
///
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -436,22 +457,43 @@ pub unsafe trait FromZeroes {
///
/// # Safety
///
/// If `T: FromBytes`, then unsafe code may assume that it is sound to treat any
/// initialized sequence of bytes of length `size_of::<T>()` as a `T`. If a type
/// is marked as `FromBytes` which violates this contract, it may cause
/// undefined behavior.
/// *This section describes what is required in order for `T: FromBytes`, and
/// what unsafe code may assume of such types. `#[derive(FromBytes)]` only
/// permits types which satisfy these requirements. If you don't plan on
/// implementing `FromBytes` manually, and you don't plan on writing unsafe code
/// that operates on `FromBytes` types, then you don't need to read this
/// section.*
///
/// If `T: FromBytes`, then unsafe code may assume that:
/// - It is sound to treat any initialized sequence of bytes of length
/// `size_of::<T>()` as a `T`.
/// - Given `b: &[u8]` where `b.len() == size_of::<T>()` and `b` is aligned to
/// `align_of::<T>()`, it is sound to construct a `t: &T` at the same address
/// as `b`, and it is sound for both `b` and `t` to be live at the same time.
///
/// If a type is marked as `FromBytes` which violates this contract, it may
/// cause undefined behavior.
///
/// If a type has the following properties, then it is safe to implement
/// If a type has the following properties, then it is sound to implement
/// `FromBytes` for that type:
/// - If the type is a struct, all of its fields must implement `FromBytes`
/// - If the type is a struct, all of its fields must satisfy the requirements
/// to be `FromBytes` (they do not actually have to be `FromBytes`)
/// - If the type is an enum:
/// - It must be a C-like enum (meaning that all variants have no fields)
/// - It must be a C-like enum (meaning that all variants have no fields).
/// - It must have a defined representation (`repr`s `C`, `u8`, `u16`, `u32`,
/// `u64`, `usize`, `i8`, `i16`, `i32`, `i64`, or `isize`).
/// - The maximum number of discriminants must be used (so that every possible
/// bit pattern is a valid one). Be very careful when using the `C`,
/// `usize`, or `isize` representations, as their size is
/// platform-dependent.
/// - The type must not contain any [`UnsafeCell`]s (this is required in order
/// for it to be sound to construct a `&[u8]` and a `&T` to the same region of
/// memory). The type may contain references or pointers to `UnsafeCell`s so
/// long as those values can themselves be initialized from zeroes
/// (`FromBytes` is not currently implemented for, e.g., `Option<*const
/// UnsafeCell<_>>`, but it could be one day).
///
/// [`UnsafeCell`]: core::cell::UnsafeCell
///
/// # Rationale
///
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -562,27 +604,46 @@ pub unsafe trait FromBytes: FromZeroes {
///
/// # Safety
///
/// If `T: AsBytes`, then unsafe code may assume that it is sound to treat any
/// instance of the type as an immutable `[u8]` of length `size_of::<T>()`. If a
/// type is marked as `AsBytes` which violates this contract, it may cause
/// *This section describes what is required in order for `T: AsBytes`, and what
/// unsafe code may assume of such types. `#[derive(AsBytes)]` only permits
/// types which satisfy these requirements. If you don't plan on implementing
/// `AsBytes` manually, and you don't plan on writing unsafe code that operates
/// on `AsBytes` types, then you don't need to read this section.*
///
/// If `T: AsBytes`, then unsafe code may assume that:
/// - It is sound to treat any `t: T` as an immutable `[u8]` of length
/// `size_of_val(t)`.
/// - Given `t: &T`, it is sound to construct a `b: &[u8]` where `b.len() ==
/// size_of_val(t)` at the same address as `t`, and it is sound for both `b`
/// and `t` to be live at the same time.
///
/// If a type is marked as `AsBytes` which violates this contract, it may cause
/// undefined behavior.
///
/// If a type has the following properties, then it is safe to implement
/// `AsBytes` for that type
/// If a type has the following properties, then it is sound to implement
/// `AsBytes` for that type:
/// - If the type is a struct:
/// - It must have a defined representation (`repr(C)`, `repr(transparent)`,
/// or `repr(packed)`).
/// - All of its fields must be `AsBytes`
/// - All of its fields must satisfy the requirements to be `AsBytes` (they do
/// not actually have to be `AsBytes`).
/// - Its layout must have no padding. This is always true for
/// `repr(transparent)` and `repr(packed)`. For `repr(C)`, see the layout
/// algorithm described in the [Rust Reference].
/// - If the type is an enum:
/// - It must be a C-like enum (meaning that all variants have no fields)
/// - It must be a C-like enum (meaning that all variants have no fields).
/// - It must have a defined representation (`repr`s `C`, `u8`, `u16`, `u32`,
/// `u64`, `usize`, `i8`, `i16`, `i32`, `i64`, or `isize`).
/// - The type must not contain any [`UnsafeCell`]s (this is required in order
/// for it to be sound to construct a `&[u8]` and a `&T` to the same region of
/// memory). The type may contain references or pointers to `UnsafeCell`s so
/// long as those values can themselves be initialized from zeroes (`AsBytes`
/// is not currently implemented for, e.g., `Option<&UnsafeCell<_>>`, but it
/// could be one day).
///
/// [type-layout]: https://doc.rust-lang.org/reference/type-layout.html
/// [Rust Reference]: https://doc.rust-lang.org/reference/type-layout.html
/// [`UnsafeCell`]: core::cell::UnsafeCell
pub unsafe trait AsBytes {
// The `Self: Sized` bound makes it so that this function doesn't prevent
// `AsBytes` from being object safe. Note that other `AsBytes` methods
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -708,6 +769,13 @@ pub unsafe trait AsBytes {
///
/// # Safety
///
/// *This section describes what is required in order for `T: Unaligned`, and
/// what unsafe code may assume of such types. `#[derive(Unaligned)]` only
/// permits types which satisfy these requirements. If you don't plan on
/// implementing `Unaligned` manually, and you don't plan on writing unsafe code
/// that operates on `Unaligned` types, then you don't need to read this
/// section.*
///
/// If `T: Unaligned`, then unsafe code may assume that it is sound to produce a
/// reference to `T` at any memory location regardless of alignment. If a type
/// is marked as `Unaligned` which violates this contract, it may cause
Expand Down

0 comments on commit c979289

Please sign in to comment.