Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Update divideSeries handling of missing denominators #73

Merged
merged 2 commits into from
Aug 22, 2022

Conversation

carrieedwards
Copy link
Collaborator

@carrieedwards carrieedwards commented Aug 22, 2022

This PR updates the divideSeries function's handling of the case in which the denominator(s) are missing. Previously, CarbonAPI would return an error if the length of denominators was equal to zero. This appears to be inconsistent with how Graphite web handles this scenario, in which a value of None was returned for each value in the returned series (see here). In this case, instead of None, math.NaN() is returned. This is consistent with how asPercent handles missing values.

@grafanabot

This comment has been minimized.

@grafanabot

This comment has been minimized.

Copy link

@npazosmendez npazosmendez left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

LGTM

@grafanabot
Copy link

Go coverage report:

Click to expand.
File %
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/capability.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/enrichcontext.go 6.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/find_handlers.go 33.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/functions_handler.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/helper.go 27.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/info_handlers.go 53.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/init.go 84.6%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/lbcheck_handler.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/metrics.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/render_handler.go 50.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/tags_handler.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/usage_handler.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/cmd/carbonapi/http/version_handler.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/date/date.go 78.9%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/consolidations/consolidations.go 44.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/expr.go 31.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/absolute/function.go 80.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/aggregate/function.go 82.2%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/aggregateLine/function.go 81.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/aggregateSeriesLists/function.go 73.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/aggregateWithWildcards/function.go 86.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/alias/function.go 83.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/aliasByBase64/function.go 88.6%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/aliasByMetric/function.go 92.9%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/aliasByNode/function.go 84.2%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/aliasByRedis/function.go 72.1%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/aliasSub/function.go 80.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/asPercent/function.go 77.6%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/averageOutsidePercentile/function.go 89.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/averageSeriesWithWildcards/function.go 89.4%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/below/function.go 91.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/cactiStyle/function.go 88.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/changed/function.go 92.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/constantLine/function.go 88.2%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/delay/function.go 90.6%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/derivative/function.go 93.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/divideSeries/function.go 87.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/ewma/function.go 90.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/exclude/function.go 81.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/exp/function.go 90.9%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/exponentialMovingAverage/function.go 72.2%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/fallbackSeries/function.go 86.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/filter/function.go 84.4%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/grep/function.go 81.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/groupByNode/function.go 86.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/groupByTags/function.go 90.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/heatMap/function.go 86.4%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/heatMap/helpers.go 84.6%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/highestLowest/function.go 87.1%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/hitcount/function.go 93.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/identity/function.go 89.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/integral/function.go 94.4%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/integralByInterval/function.go 85.4%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/integralWithReset/function.go 86.1%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/interpolate/function.go 92.1%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/invert/function.go 93.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/isNotNull/function.go 93.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/join/function.go 89.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/keepLastValue/function.go 92.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/legendValue/function.go 90.9%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/limit/function.go 82.4%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/linearRegression/function.go 80.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/logarithm/function.go 90.9%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/logit/function.go 91.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/lowPass/function.go 89.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/mapSeries/function.go 88.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/minMax/function.go 86.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/mostDeviant/function.go 88.6%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/moving/function.go 82.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/movingMedian/function.go 86.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/multiplySeriesWithWildcards/function.go 90.2%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/nPercentile/function.go 90.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/nonNegativeDerivative/function.go 90.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/offset/function.go 88.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/offsetToZero/function.go 94.1%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/pearson/function.go 86.1%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/pearsonClosest/function.go 75.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/perSecond/function.go 90.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/percentileOfSeries/function.go 81.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/polyfit/function.go 87.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/pow/function.go 88.9%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/powSeries/function.go 95.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/rangeOfSeries/function.go 94.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/removeBelowSeries/function.go 92.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/removeBetweenPercentile/function.go 89.2%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/removeEmptySeries/function.go 90.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/round/function.go 90.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/scale/function.go 88.6%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/scaleToSeconds/function.go 88.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/seriesList/function.go 65.2%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/sigmoid/function.go 91.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/sinFunction/function.go 86.2%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/slo/function.go 84.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/slo/helpers.go 72.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/smartSummarize/function.go 90.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/sortBy/function.go 85.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/sortByName/function.go 85.2%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/squareRoot/function.go 90.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/substr/function.go 85.4%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/sumSeriesWithWildcards/function.go 89.1%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/summarize/function.go 91.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/timeShift/function.go 78.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/timeShiftByMetric/function.go 89.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/timeShiftByMetric/misc.go 93.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/transformNull/function.go 88.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/tukey/function.go 80.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/unique/function.go 88.9%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/functions/weightedAverage/function.go 85.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/helper/align.go 60.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/helper/helper.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/helper/metric/extract.go 72.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/helper/sort.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/rewrite/aboveSeries/function.go 79.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/sort.go 96.1%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/tags/helper.go 100.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/types/extract.go 82.4%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/types/list.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/types/metricheap.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/types/types.go 33.9%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/expr/types/windowed.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/pkg/parser/define.go 76.9%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/pkg/parser/interface.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/pkg/parser/internal.go 9.4%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/pkg/parser/interval.go 83.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/pkg/parser/parser.go 44.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/broadcast/broadcast_group.go 38.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/helper/requests.go 13.3%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/protocols/graphite/msgpack/type_gen.go 57.2%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/protocols/irondb/irondb_group.go 2.5%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/protocols/irondb/irondb_helpers.go 81.1%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/protocols/prometheus/helpers/helpers.go 17.1%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/protocols/victoriametrics/feature_set.go 19.7%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/protocols/victoriametrics/fetch.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/protocols/victoriametrics/find.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/protocols/victoriametrics/tags.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/protocols/victoriametrics/victoriametrics_group.go 7.8%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/types/backend.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/types/errors.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/types/lbmethod.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/types/requests.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/types/response.go 6.4%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/types/stats.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/zipper.go 0.0%
github.com/grafana/carbonapi/zipper/zipper_pb3.go 0.0%
total 55.5%

Go lint report:

No issues found. 😎

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

divideSeries function not handling missing denominators the same as Graphite web
3 participants