bicycle=dismount is not evaluated

[polarbearing]

While graphhopper knows the idea of pushing a bike on path, footway, pedestrian and steps, the explicit access tag bicycle=dismount (used about 40000 times) is not evaluated. If found on any highway, it should create such pushing section.

E.g. I have a highway=secondary here which is for a long time access=no, foot=yes, bicycle=dismount.

[karussell]

Thanks that is indeed missing!

Regarding your example if access=no and foot=yes is already set GraphHopper should already tell you about getting off the bike. Or do you have a example link?

[polarbearing]

See here and switch between bike, car and foot. Maybe the issue is the highway=secondary ? The access evaluation appears to be rather complex.

[karussell]

Ah, okay this way. Maybe the current implementation would use 'get off the bike' if there is no access=no and just a foot:yes. We need to check this and make it working.

[polarbearing]

Yes, I should have given you the way number.

The evaluation order in OSM is typically that first access=no forbids everything, then individual permissions are opened case by case. Thus you do not need a long list of *=no tags.
Thanks.

[polarbearing]

Just for the records, I just removed a bunch of unnecessary turn restrictions from a newbie a the northern end of the road segment. But it seems the issue is still within the road, if I get the start/stop point narrower only on the affected segment, I get the same results.

[ratrun]

I think that this issue can be closed, it should be solved for a while.