Limit cluster to 3 nodes #2905
Limit cluster to 3 nodes #2905
Conversation
| @@ -129,6 +129,12 @@ func (s *Store) IDPath() string { return filepath.Join(s.path, "id") } | |||
|
|
|||
| // Open opens and initializes the raft store. | |||
| func (s *Store) Open() error { | |||
| // Verify that no more than 3 peers. | |||
| // https://github.com/influxdb/influxdb/issues/2750 | |||
| if len(s.peers) > 3 { | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
When is s.peers increased? When does it hit 4?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
What I mean is that for this to work, peers must include the guy who is joining, correct?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Peers are hardcoded in the configuration file. All nodes need to have the same set of peers so there's not really a sense of "joining" anymore. If you start the first server up and you list 4 peers then it'll immediately fail.
|
Does this actually stop it from joining or does it just error the server out if they've joined more than 3 to the raft cluster? |
benbjohnson
force-pushed
the
limit-cluster-size
branch
from
33aab71
to
0c0859f
Compare
|
@pauldix You have to specify all peers in the config file so it will fail immediately even when the first node tries to start up. |
This commit restricts the maximum number of nodes in a cluster to 3. Fixes influxdata#2750
|
@benbjohnson ugh, that's really ugly. I guess this means a bunch of work needs to be done in 0.9.1 to add joining a cluster back in as a concept? The config file thing won't work in the real world. Otherwise how are new nodes going to join a cluster? |
benbjohnson
force-pushed
the
limit-cluster-size
branch
from
0c0859f
to
405ec78
Compare
|
@pauldix I don't think it'll be a bunch of work. We still need the initial peer set so that nodes can wait for a quorum before creating the initial cluster. |
|
@benbjohnson cool, I just want to make sure that when we add that in, people running an 0.9.0 cluster will be able to upgrade without breaking config files or anything like that. |
Overview
This pull request restricts the maximum number of nodes in a cluster to 3.
Fixes #2750