Can't build on MacOSX with wxWidgets-3.0 @3.0.0_5 from macports

[newchief]

The error is:

[ 84%] Building CXX object wxc/CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/taskbaricon.cpp.o
[ 85%] Building CXX object wxc/CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/textstream.cpp.o
[ 86%] Building CXX object wxc/CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/treectrl.cpp.o
[ 86%] Building CXX object wxc/CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/wrapper.cpp.o
Linking CXX shared library libwxc.dylib
Undefined symbols:
"wxWindowBase::IsDescendant(wxWindowBase*) const", referenced from:
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in apppath.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in dragimage.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in eljaccelerator.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in eljartprov.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in eljbitmap.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in eljbrush.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in eljbusyinfo.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in eljbutton.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in eljcalendarctrl.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in eljcaret.cpp.o
...and so on

with VERBOSE=1:
make -f wxc/CMakeFiles/wxc.dir/build.make wxc/CMakeFiles/wxc.dir/depend
cd /Users/newchief/wxrust/wxRust/build && /opt/local/bin/cmake -E cmake_depends "Unix Makefiles" /Users/newchief/wxrust/wxRust /Users/newchief/wxrust/wxRust/wxc /Users/newchief/wxrust/wxRust/
build /Users/newchief/wxrust/wxRust/build/wxc /Users/newchief/wxrust/wxRust/build/wxc/CMakeFiles/wxc.dir/DependInfo.cmake --color=
make -f wxc/CMakeFiles/wxc.dir/build.make wxc/CMakeFiles/wxc.dir/build
Linking CXX shared library libwxc.dylib
cd /Users/newchief/wxrust/wxRust/build/wxc && /opt/local/bin/cmake -E cmake_link_script CMakeFiles/wxc.dir/link.txt --verbose=1
/usr/bin/c++ -I/opt/local/Library/Frameworks/wxWidgets.framework/Versions/wxWidgets/3.0/include/wx-3.0 -dynamiclib -Wl,-headerpad_max_install_names -o libwxc.dylib -install_name /Users/ne
wchief/wxrust/wxRust/build/wxc/libwxc.dylib CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/apppath.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/dragimage.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaske
ll/wxc/src/cpp/eljaccelerator.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljartprov.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljbitmap.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wx
c/src/cpp/eljbrush.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljbusyinfo.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljbutton.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/
eljcalendarctrl.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljcaret.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljcheckbox.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljc
hecklistbox.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljchoice.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljclipboard.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljcol
data.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljcolour.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljcolourdlg.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljcombobox.c
pp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljconfigbase.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljcontrol.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljctxhelp.cpp.o
CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljcursor.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljdataformat.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljdatetime.cpp.o CMake
Files/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljdc.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljdcsvg.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljdialog.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir/
/wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljdirdlg.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljdnd.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljdrawing.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wx
c/src/cpp/eljevent.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljfiledialog.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljfilehist.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/
cpp/eljfindrepldlg.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljfont.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljfontdata.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/el
jfontdlg.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljframe.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljgauge.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljgrid.cpp.o
CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljhelpcontroller.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljicnbndl.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljicon.cpp.o CMak
eFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljimage.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljimagelist.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljlayoutconstraints.cpp.o CM
akeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljlistbox.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljlistctrl.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljlocale.cpp.o CMakeFiles
/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljlog.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljmask.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljmdi.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaske
ll/wxc/src/cpp/eljmenu.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljmenubar.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljmessagedialog.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wx
c/src/cpp/eljmime.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljminiframe.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljnotebook.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cp
p/eljpalette.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljpanel.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljpen.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljprintdlg.
cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljprinting.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljprocess.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljradiobox.cpp.o
CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljradiobutton.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljrc.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljregion.cpp.o CMakeFiles
/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljregioniter.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljsash.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljscrollbar.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.d
ir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljscrolledwindow.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljsingleinst.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljsizer.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.d
ir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljslider.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljspinctrl.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljsplitterwindow.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.di
r//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljstaticbox.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljstaticline.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljstatictext.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.di
r//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljstatusbar.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljsystemsettings.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljtextctrl.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.
dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljtimer.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljtipwnd.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljtglbtn.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHas
kell/wxc/src/cpp/eljtoolbar.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljvalidator.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/eljwindow.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wx
c/src/cpp/eljwizard.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/ewxw_main.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/extra.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/glcan
vas.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/graphicscontext.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/image.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/managed.cpp.o C
MakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/mediactrl.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/previewframe.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/printout.cpp.o CMakeFiles
/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/sckaddr.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/socket.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/sound.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskel
l/wxc/src/cpp/stc.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/std.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/taskbaricon.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/textstr
eam.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/treectrl.cpp.o CMakeFiles/wxc.dir//wxHaskell/wxc/src/cpp/wrapper.cpp.o -L/opt/local/Library/Frameworks/wxWidgets.framework/Versions/wx
Widgets/3.0/lib -L/opt/local/Library/Frameworks/wxWidgets.framework/Versions/wxWidgets/3.0/lib -framework IOKit -framework Carbon -framework Cocoa -framework AudioToolbox -framework System -f
ramework OpenGL -lwx_osx_cocoau_gl-3.0 -lwx_baseu-3.0 -Wl,-rpath,/opt/local/Library/Frameworks/wxWidgets.framework/Versions/wxWidgets/3.0/lib
Undefined symbols:
"wxWindowBase::IsDescendant(wxWindowBase*) const", referenced from:
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in apppath.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in dragimage.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in eljaccelerator.cpp.o
wxMDIParentFrameBase::TryBefore(wxEvent&) in eljartprov.cpp.o

... and so on.

[kenz-gelsoft]

Thank you for reporting a problem.
It looks like wxHaskell's wxc which is utilized by this library has not updated for wxWidgets 3.0(.5) yet.

I'll search for updated fork or try to fix.

[kenz-gelsoft]

Next I'm going to look into this.

Latest homebrew's wxmac package installs wx3.0 as well, so maybe I can reproduce this easily.

[kenz-gelsoft]

Hmm, with wxmac 3.0.0 from homebrew just compiles...
What is wrong..?

[kenz-gelsoft]

Would you put the output of wx-config --libs like this? :

$ wx-config --libs
-L/usr/local/Cellar/wxmac/3.0.0.0/lib   -framework IOKit -framework Carbon -framework Cocoa -framework AudioToolbox -framework System -framework OpenGL -framework QuickTime -lwx_osx_cocoau-3.0 

[kenz-gelsoft]

Or can you build with this change?:

diff --git a/wxc/CMakeLists.txt b/wxc/CMakeLists.txt
index 8c7a1b8..25b6f25 100644
--- a/wxc/CMakeLists.txt
+++ b/wxc/CMakeLists.txt
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
 cmake_minimum_required(VERSION 2.8)

 if(APPLE)
-    find_package(wxWidgets REQUIRED gl)
+    find_package(wxWidgets REQUIRED all)
 else(APPLE)
     find_package(wxWidgets REQUIRED all)
 endif(APPLE)

[newchief]

bash-3.2$ wx-config --libs
-L/opt/local/Library/Frameworks/wxWidgets.framework/Versions/wxWidgets/3.0/lib   -framework IOKit -framework Carbon -framework Cocoa -framework AudioToolbox -framework System -framework OpenGL -lwx_osx_cocoau_xrc-3.0 -lwx_osx_cocoau_webview-3.0 -lwx_osx_cocoau_html-3.0 -lwx_osx_cocoau_qa-3.0 -lwx_osx_cocoau_adv-3.0 -lwx_osx_cocoau_core-3.0 -lwx_baseu_xml-3.0 -lwx_baseu_net-3.0 -lwx_baseu-3.0

Indeed, proposed change helped to build and test runned fine (built from recent master).

One note for the test:
I noticed it for Linux too: when I close test application window, for some reason push button action is triggered (on Linux it's with exception thrown) and "Pushed!!" message window is shown. On Linux, pressing OK in such message button terminates test application, on MacOSX it does nothing (not even message button is closed!), therefore "Force quit" must be used to terminate test application on MacOSX...

[kenz-gelsoft]

Thanks. wx-config --libs output and your result helps.

Homebrew's wxmac wx-config --libs returns very few components currently. This was changed at some point of wx2.9.x timeframe. This might be a homebrew's packaging bug. I'll report that for upstream.

For now, I'll prepare a workaround for macports to define a cmake definition to control this behavior(such as -DMACPORTS_WX). Because I want to support homebrew environment as 1st-tier (and want keep its build instruction simpler).

BTW, about your another note. Yes that's known issue to fix. I'll do this right now because its easy.

[kenz-gelsoft]

1c47276 and 28832d2 should stop showing another message dialog.

[newchief]

Yeah it helped, and the application terminates correctly now.