Reload config file without restart

[Luflosi]

What do you think of the possibility of reloading the config file without restarting kitty? While this may be a little difficult for some options, like those which are compiled into the shader code at startup, it should be fairly simple for some options that are just copied to some internal variable. I'm not asking to make most options reloadable, I'd just like to start with a couple easy ones.
What do you think about this idea? If you're ok with this, I could make a pull request but I don't know where to start, maybe you can give me a couple tips.
I've read #343, #635 and #684 but I am not quite satisfied with your answer that it's too much work, maybe you change your mind if someone else (me) is willing to implement it.

[kovidgoyal]

Having reloading for some options but not others is not worth it in my opinion, since that is just confusing. No one will be able to keep track of which options change and which do not. And implementing it for all options is waaay too much work. If you are willing to implement it for all options, then go ahead, I wont refuse the patch, but less than that is not a good idea, IMO.

If you want to implement it, you will basically need to carefully track each option to see how/where it is used and have the reload code change it accordingly. This is basically a lot of boring book-keeping.

[Luflosi]

Both iTerm2 and Alacritty support most config options or settings in case of iTerm2 to be changed without a restart but they don't support that with all of them. Why do you think that it's so confusing? As long as it is well documented, which ones require a restart and which ones don't, it should be ok IMHO.

[kovidgoyal]

Because there is no way for an end user to know to expect whether config
option a will reload or not -- that is entirely dependent on the
implementation details. Which means that if the user is trying to
experiment with reloading the config file it will create another layer
of confusion.

And not to mention that the config options that most people really want
to change regularly, colors and such, are already dynamically changeable.

[devth]

+1 I think the entire world wants reloadable config.

[TheConfuZzledDude]

I think at least having a command to reload keyboard mappings from a config file would be enough, since that wouldn't confuse anyone, but would still be useful for the majority of times you'd want to reload the config for.

[cvsguimaraes]

What if the reload handles only options that have simple side effects, such as margin and padding?
For example, Kitty looks great on i3 with a little padding but that gets in the way when using a "fullscreen" program such as vim. It would be great to have a way of removing that padding on the fly before I launch vim.

@kovidgoyal Would it be possible/ideal to achieve this through a kitten? Should I research into that?

Thanks!

[kovidgoyal]

You can implement it in a kitten or using the remote control facility as
described here: https://sw.kovidgoyal.net/kitty/remote-control.html

[jpmvferreira]

Not sure if i should be asking here, given that the current status is close, but how is the progress going on this feature? Is there a workaround for similar results (such as, having your window manager close and open kitty at the same time such that it looked as if it were reloaded) while this feature is still being developed?

[Luflosi]

Nothing changed regarding the progress of this feature.
Closing and reopening kitty would unfortunately not work well because the state of whatever was in the terminal before closing it can't be restored after opening it again, except with a terminal multiplexer like tmux. But that's not a very elegant/convenient solution.

[jpmvferreira]

Ah right, well hopefully such feature is implemented in the future, as it can be very handy, in my case to switch color schemes on the fly.

Thanks!

[kovidgoyal]

This feature is not being developed. You can control various aspects of
kitty at runtime using the remote control protocol.
https://sw.kovidgoyal.net/kitty/remote-control.html

[Luflosi]

Yeah, colors can be changed using the remote control protocol. See https://github.com/dexpota/kitty-themes#previews for an example.

[JeanMertz]

I can see how it would be difficult to support auto-reloading of all configuration options, and I also understand that "some work, others don't" isn't great, but I do think that "keyboard mappings auto-reload, nothing else" is perfectly explainable.

I'm not making a judgement on the complexity to make this work out of the box, or even the priority of such a feature compared to others on the list (or the desire for any contributor to actually implement it, for that matter), but I did want to add my vote for such a feature, as it greatly improves the workflow while tweaking your Kitty settings.