Data team peer review 4/18-4/22

[geochetan]

Starting this week, @mapbox/team-data will open our peer review process to the public (see background information in this diary post). Anyone from the OSM community can review and comment on our edits.

Mapping projects to be reviewed

1. Exit and Destination Mapping.
2. To-fix: Unconnected minor highways
3. To-fix: Overlapping major highways

Instructions

• Download .osm files for last week.
  • 2016-04-18
  • 2016-04-19
  • 2016-04-20
  • 2016-04-21
  • 2016-04-22
• Select any date and extract the files.
• Each team member will have an osm file of edits during the respective date, for example: 2016-04-20-andygol.osm. Select any .osm file and open the data in JOSM.
• If no edits were done during that day, JOSM will notify that no data was exist, load another file.

• Examine user edits in detail. In JOSM, select a random small area edited by the user and press 3 to zoom.
• Download the latest data in OSM as a new layer and add a filter Cmd + F to see only the user's edits, e.g. user:andygol.

• Select a way/node and load the the history (Ctrl + H), the changeset comment will describe what specific project the user was working on.
• To get an OSM link to the object, click Cmd + Shift + H.
• Note down any feedback for each user in this ticket or comment directly in the changeset. Use this format:

username
changeset link - issue to fix

• @karitotp or @chtnha will post the feedback in the ticket (Use Github handle because OSM name is different from Github name) and make necessary changes on the same day.
• Close the ticket once user's have fixed their edits.

For clarifications, discuss with the @mapbox/team-data in this ticket.

[geochetan]

@dannykath

Changing highway tag from living_street to residential would be better

• https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/87320204/history

[geochetan]

@ediyes

Split the road

• https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/411828789/history

[geochetan]

@planemad

Waterway is passing inside the village. Reshaping is necessary

https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/411758585/history

[planemad]

@chtnha fixed! http://osmlab.github.io/changeset-map/#38931501

[ediyes]

Thnks @chtnha fixed here: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/414001371/history

[dannykath]

Thanks @chtnha, fixed https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/38938149

[geochetan]

We had a great peer-review 🎉 No actions here.