-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 51
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Mapping Destination signs on US Motorways #169
Comments
Maybe inviting mdroads here to comment on that tag would be the best thing to do. Especially if he has added the tag the most. |
@rickmastfan67 I have sent a message to mdroads asking for the same. |
Received a reply from mdroads: The context for use of destination:street=* is to capture the street name when shown on overhead signage, destination:ref=* for the number, and destination=* only for city or place. destination:street=* is only used when the street name actually appears on the motorway signs. The tag is a proposal on the Exit Info wiki page, alongside destination:ref=* and some others. This page is not well linked to the regular destination=* entry on the wiki (and should probably be merged with it), but does show North American signage tagging examples. The mostly European signage shown on the proposed Destination Details page on the other hand, rarely if ever use street names or cardinal directions. |
We are adding It seems that the Wiki information for some highways is not correct, especially in case of highways in Texas. I was working on I-35 in Texas where there is no Mapilary coverage but a proper Wiki page with all the information related to exit numbers and destination. Here the exit numbers and the destination information were wrongly assigned which I didn't realize at the beginning and mapped the whole stretch. An OpenStreetMap contributor got back to me pointing out the mistake by commenting on my changeset. This is a serious issue and we need to find an alternative source to map destination tags. We also need to validate the one's we mapped since last week. |
@jothirnadh I read the changeset comment differently. Wikipedia might be correct but you were applying the exits in Iowa, not in Texas. If so, that would explain the issue, and we should pay closer attention to where we're mapping. |
@mikelmaron you are right. This mainly happened because, checkautopista downloads all the highways in its bounding box, not limiting it to a state. I was not aware of this and started to add destination tags to all the I 35 highways it downloaded. Will keep track of things from now. |
Project SummaryIn the course of 12 days, the team added 3417 Observation-
Project Statistics-
Closing here. |
I hope you guys paid attention to signs that had the "TO" text in them beside the highway shields and properly tagged them as "destination:ref:to". Case in point: http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/38919762 |
@rickmastfan67 Thanks you for pointing this out. We fixed this particular one and will make sure to keep an eye on these cases during our peer review session. Feel free to post any such case on these peer-review tickets. |
OSM Diary --> http://www.openstreetmap.org/user/nammala/diary/38560 |
I found an issue when a way is both an off ramp and an on ramp. The way will need to be split between an off ramp and an on ramp or it will produce invalid driving directions. |
I made a comment on this changeset: http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/38979964 |
@dgearhart Thank you for bringing this up. Currently, we are working on a tool that can help scale-up the validation work for this and other projects, where we used mapillary as a source to add tags on OSM. |
Imagery source- Mapillary
Task Objective
To add
destination=*
anddestination:ref=*
tags on motorway_link ways representing the guidance signboard using Checkautopista2.Background
destination=*
tag is used to represent the city/town/neighborhood/road that you can reach by switching to the concerned highway.destination:ref=*
tag is used to signifies the motorway number (ref
tag of motorway) that is used to reach the destination. These tags are added on ways and not nodes and thus considered more relevant for navigation purpose when compared toexit_to
tag used on motorway_junction nodeCurrently in the US, there are 25446 ways with
destination=*
tag and 13030 ways withdestination:ref=*
tag (as on 30 March 2016). All exit numbers junctions lead to at least 1 destination with 52,000 exit numbers in the US. This accounts minimum of about 25,000 missingdestination=*
and 39,000 missingdestination:ref=*
tag in the US.Focus area
The 9 States used in exit number mapping are taken as focus area based on mapillary coverage, as it is the primary source.
Mapping Workflow
Gist for detailed workflow
Other tags
Other than
destination
,exit_to
tag is prominently used to represent guidance signboards(see taginfo). For now, we will be only adding missingdestination
anddestination:ref
tag to motorways that don't have relatedexit_to
tag, as adding bothdestination
andexit_to
to the same way will be redundant work and could be solved with an automated approach later.Changeset comment and source
Comment->
Adding missing destination tags https://github.com/mapbox/mapping/issues/169
Source->
Bing;Mapillary;Wikipedia
Team
@mapbox/team-data
Progress
The current estimate is ~4 weeks for 9 states.
Resources
tms:http://d2munx5tg0hw47.cloudfront.net/tiles/{zoom}/{x}/{y}.png
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: