You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Here is my feedback. Evaluation forms will be submitted by my co-author.
Excel solution:
This has clearly produced good results, but it is not clear how it uses transformation technologies, instead of existing non-MT optimisation tools.
In addition, the heuristics in Section 3 seem to require tuning of the algorithm to specific CRA problems. The idea of creating a main class could lead to unbalanced class diagrams. Such diagrams are local but not global optima. The approach does not seem to produce optimal solutions (eg., for C, D, E cases), although the efficiency is very impressive.
Henshin solution:
An interesting investigation of GA application to the problem. It is unclear how Henshin rules are integrated into the GA - is the control of these external? Is the GA and rule control coded in Java? Some example code would be helpful. The population sizes used seem quite small.
Section 4: 'CPA' should be 'CRA'
At some point the best results obtained per model should be given.
Section 4.2: explain the abbreviations RS, JSC, etc.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Thanks for the feedback Kevin, but I don't think you were one of our opponents (Excel solution). Please check so that the other solution is not left unreviewed.
Here is my feedback. Evaluation forms will be submitted by my co-author.
Excel solution:
This has clearly produced good results, but it is not clear how it uses transformation technologies, instead of existing non-MT optimisation tools.
In addition, the heuristics in Section 3 seem to require tuning of the algorithm to specific CRA problems. The idea of creating a main class could lead to unbalanced class diagrams. Such diagrams are local but not global optima. The approach does not seem to produce optimal solutions (eg., for C, D, E cases), although the efficiency is very impressive.
Henshin solution:
An interesting investigation of GA application to the problem. It is unclear how Henshin rules are integrated into the GA - is the control of these external? Is the GA and rule control coded in Java? Some example code would be helpful. The population sizes used seem quite small.
Section 4: 'CPA' should be 'CRA'
At some point the best results obtained per model should be given.
Section 4.2: explain the abbreviations RS, JSC, etc.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: