You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Currently, emoji are recorded by shortcode and domain name. This means that a remote emoji will:
overwrite a local emoji with the same name
be added to a domain that doesn't own it
The domain name should, instead, be the domain of the emoji's id field, verifying that it matches the actual document before storing it in the database similar to how boosted posts aren't implicitly trusted.
Additionally, emoji are not able to be discovered via a search for the ActivityPub URL the way that posts and users can be discovered.
A third issue is that remote emoji and local emoji cannot be referenced in the same post if they have the same name, but this isn't really that big of a problem.
This wouldn't immediately make any user-visible changes, but it would make room for future enhancements:
Using remote emoji would be most immediately useful in replies to posts from other domains with content warnings that contain emoji.
It would also allow centralized storage of an emoji library that is shared between multiple domains but none of those domains own the emoji library. In this example, I could use the entirety of Guild Wars 2's item list as an emoji source rather than having to upload thousands of PNGs to my instance before they were available.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.
Pitch
Currently, emoji are recorded by shortcode and domain name. This means that a remote emoji will:
The domain name should, instead, be the domain of the emoji's
id
field, verifying that it matches the actual document before storing it in the database similar to how boosted posts aren't implicitly trusted.Additionally, emoji are not able to be discovered via a search for the ActivityPub URL the way that posts and users can be discovered.
A third issue is that remote emoji and local emoji cannot be referenced in the same post if they have the same name, but this isn't really that big of a problem.
Test case: https://ben.lubar.me/dump/emoji-test-68702b2a-cbdc-4d39-858e-f1b22fcc48a5/post.json (search for
@testuser@ben.lubar.me
first if this returns no results in Mastodon)Motivation
This wouldn't immediately make any user-visible changes, but it would make room for future enhancements:
Using remote emoji would be most immediately useful in replies to posts from other domains with content warnings that contain emoji.
It would also allow centralized storage of an emoji library that is shared between multiple domains but none of those domains own the emoji library. In this example, I could use the entirety of Guild Wars 2's item list as an emoji source rather than having to upload thousands of PNGs to my instance before they were available.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: