Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on May 13, 2024. It is now read-only.

Fix Windows/SDL builds #250

Merged
merged 5 commits into from
Oct 13, 2023
Merged

Fix Windows/SDL builds #250

merged 5 commits into from
Oct 13, 2023

Conversation

numberZero
Copy link
Contributor

@numberZero numberZero commented Oct 7, 2023

This PR replaces all direct calls to the OpenGL library from the unified driver with calls via OpenGLProcedures. There are also a few fixes required for it to compile.

This is inspired by #232 but is much simpler. Also not all calls are replaced, those in e.g. COpenGLCoreTexture (shared with other drivers) remain. That shouldn’t be a problem as these drivers do that too and work (it might be the cause of some obscure bugs though).

I can’t test whether this Windows/SDL build actually works but given that it didn’t even compile, it is definitely better than before ;)

@numberZero numberZero marked this pull request as draft October 7, 2023 16:48
@numberZero numberZero marked this pull request as ready for review October 7, 2023 17:41
Copy link
Member

@sfan5 sfan5 left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

seems good

@grorp
Copy link
Member

grorp commented Oct 8, 2023

I tested this PR on Windows together with minetest/minetest#13321, it crashed on startup. I hope this output from "Microsoft (R) Windows Debugger" helps a bit. I had to skip through tons of "Debug Assertion Failed!" before it got to the actual crash.

windows.debugger.txt

Output:

8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
GL_INVALID_VALUE: 851
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
GL_INVALID_VALUE: 851
PNG warning: Interlace handling should be turned on when using png_read_image
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
GL_INVALID_VALUE: 597
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
8246 824c 501 9146 Error has been generated. GL error GL_INVALID_VALUE in VertexAttribPointer: (ID: 3708630069) Generic error
2023-10-08 19:25:13: [Main]:  >> === FATAL ERROR ===
2023-10-08 19:25:13: [Main]:  >> Access violation (Exception 0xC0000005) at 0x00007FFAE246AAB1

Stacktrace:

[0x0]   ig11icd64!RegisterProcTableCallback+0x2ca841   0xea1bbc7a80   0x7ffae1caf26c   
[0x1]   ig11icd64 + 0xcf26c!ig11icd64+0xcf26c   0xea1bbc8f90   0x7ffae1c1a238   
[0x2]   ig11icd64 + 0x3a238!ig11icd64+0x3a238   0xea1bbcb330   0x7ffae21b8213   
[0x3]   ig11icd64!RegisterProcTableCallback+0x17fa3   0xea1bbcbb00   0x7ffae260e03b   
[0x4]   ig11icd64!RegisterProcTableCallback+0x46ddcb   0xea1bbcbb50   0x7ffae24de78e   
[0x5]   ig11icd64!RegisterProcTableCallback+0x33e51e   0xea1bbcbbc0   0x7ffae26ace6e   
[0x6]   ig11icd64!RegisterProcTableCallback+0x50cbfe   0xea1bbcbc00   0x7ffae26adc2d   
[0x7]   ig11icd64!RegisterProcTableCallback+0x50d9bd   0xea1bbcbc40   0x7ffae24fe59d   
[0x8]   ig11icd64!RegisterProcTableCallback+0x35e32d   0xea1bbcbcd0   0x7ffae25b3cc0   
[0x9]   ig11icd64!RegisterProcTableCallback+0x413a50   0xea1bbcbd20   0x7ff65a66d405   
[0xa]   minetest!irr::video::COpenGL3DriverBase::drawElements+0x65   0xea1bbcbd70   0x7ff65a666b76   
[0xb]   minetest!irr::video::COpenGL3DriverBase::draw2DImageBatch+0x756   0xea1bbcbdc0   0x7ff65a0d8fea   
[0xc]   minetest!irr::gui::CGUITTFont::draw+0xfba   0xea1bbcc030   0x7ff65a0d7ff4   
[0xd]   minetest!irr::gui::CGUITTFont::draw+0xd4   0xea1bbcc5d0   0x7ff65a6b535c   
[0xe]   minetest!irr::gui::CGUITabControl::draw+0x60c   0xea1bbcc6d0   0x7ff65a02dbc2   
[0xf]   minetest!GUIFormSpecMenu::drawMenu+0x612   0xea1bbcca50   0x7ff65a0ce48d   
[0x10]   minetest!GUIModalMenu::draw+0xdd   0xea1bbccfc0   0x7ff65a003ab3   
[0x11]   minetest!irr::gui::IGUIElement::draw+0xb3   0xea1bbcd020   0x7ff65a6a5dfe   
[0x12]   minetest!irr::gui::CGUIStaticText::draw+0x87e   0xea1bbcd0a0   0x7ff65a003ab3   
[0x13]   minetest!irr::gui::IGUIElement::draw+0xb3   0xea1bbcd300   0x7ff65a624c17   
[0x14]   minetest!irr::gui::CGUIEnvironment::drawAll+0x177   0xea1bbcd380   0x7ff65a024d12   
[0x15]   minetest!GUIEngine::run+0x402   0xea1bbcd420   0x7ff65a0242cf   
[0x16]   minetest!GUIEngine::GUIEngine+0xa2f   0xea1bbcd6e0   0x7ff659da0b89   
[0x17]   minetest!ClientLauncher::main_menu+0x349   0xea1bbcda20   0x7ff659d9faad   
[0x18]   minetest!ClientLauncher::launch_game+0x50d   0xea1bbcdca0   0x7ff659d9e9ed   
[0x19]   minetest!ClientLauncher::run+0x14cd   0xea1bbce580   0x7ff65a3ebbdb   
[0x1a]   minetest!main+0xcdb   0xea1bbceff0   0x7ff65a7522e9   
[0x1b]   minetest!invoke_main+0x39   0xea1bbcf890   0x7ff65a7521ce   
[0x1c]   minetest!__scrt_common_main_seh+0x12e   0xea1bbcf8e0   0x7ff65a75208e   
[0x1d]   minetest!__scrt_common_main+0xe   0xea1bbcf950   0x7ff65a75237e   
[0x1e]   minetest!mainCRTStartup+0xe   0xea1bbcf980   0x7ffb26747344   
[0x1f]   KERNEL32!BaseThreadInitThunk+0x14   0xea1bbcf9b0   0x7ffb26da26b1   
[0x20]   ntdll!RtlUserThreadStart+0x21   0xea1bbcf9e0   0x0   

@numberZero
Copy link
Contributor Author

numberZero commented Oct 8, 2023

@grorp GL_INVALID_VALUE isn’t something in any way expected here. Maybe there is some subtlety in VertexType initialization (did I read that lifetime extension clause carefully enough?). Can you retest with the following debug patch, please?
The expected output is lots of
beginDraw({36, {0, 3, 0x1406, 0, 0}, {2, 4, 0x1401, 1, 24}, {3, 2, 0x1406, 0, 28}}, some-pointer-value-here)
and
beginDraw({36, {0, 3, 0x1406, 0, 0}, {2, 4, 0x1401, 1, 24}}, some-pointer-value-here).

diff --git a/source/Irrlicht/OpenGL/Driver.cpp b/source/Irrlicht/OpenGL/Driver.cpp
index 6a8217e6..5294e481 100644
--- a/source/Irrlicht/OpenGL/Driver.cpp
+++ b/source/Irrlicht/OpenGL/Driver.cpp
@@ -1106,14 +1106,17 @@ COpenGL3DriverBase::~COpenGL3DriverBase()
 
        void COpenGL3DriverBase::beginDraw(const VertexType &vertexType, uintptr_t verticesBase)
        {
+               printf("beginDraw({%d", vertexType.VertexSize);
                for (auto attr: vertexType) {
                        GL.EnableVertexAttribArray(attr.Index);
+                       printf(", {%d, %d, %#04x, %d, %d}", attr.Index, attr.ComponentCount, attr.ComponentType, attr.mode, attr.Offset);
                        switch (attr.mode) {
                        case VertexAttribute::Mode::Regular: GL.VertexAttribPointer(attr.Index, attr.ComponentCount, attr.ComponentType, GL_FALS>
                        case VertexAttribute::Mode::Normalized: GL.VertexAttribPointer(attr.Index, attr.ComponentCount, attr.ComponentType, GL_T>
                        case VertexAttribute::Mode::Integral: GL.VertexAttribIPointer(attr.Index, attr.ComponentCount, attr.ComponentType, verte>
                        }
                }
+               printf("}, %p)\n", (void*)verticesBase);
        }
 
        void COpenGL3DriverBase::endDraw(const VertexType &vertexType)

@sfan5 sfan5 added the WIP Work-in-Progress label Oct 9, 2023
@numberZero
Copy link
Contributor Author

Also am I right you’re testing an MSVC build? MinGW build may behave differently.

@grorp
Copy link
Member

grorp commented Oct 10, 2023

Also am I right you’re testing an MSVC build? MinGW build may behave differently.

Yes, I am.

Can you retest with the following debug patch, please?

Debug build (window opens, but stays all black): Debug_output.txt

RelWithDebInfo build (window opens and is filled with sky blue): RelWithDebInfo.txt

@numberZero
Copy link
Contributor Author

numberZero commented Oct 10, 2023

Thanks. Now it’s clear what happens: the Attributes list in the VertexType is not valid by the time it is used. I have several suggestions but not sure which one is needed to make this work on MSVC:

  1. In VertexType, replace initializer_list with vector. Should work, but may be an overkill.
  2. In initialization of VertexType vt..., remove the equals sign. Shouldn’t matter but who knows...
  3. Try my gl3-vertex-type-literal branch, it has a slightly different approach.

@numberZero
Copy link
Contributor Author

I replaced initializer_list with vector. Now lifetime shouldn’t be a problem. VertexType became heavier though.

@sfan5 sfan5 removed the WIP Work-in-Progress label Oct 12, 2023
@sfan5 sfan5 merged commit 645b51a into minetest:master Oct 13, 2023
14 checks passed
@grorp
Copy link
Member

grorp commented Oct 16, 2023

Works 👍

Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

None yet

3 participants