[Bug] Address bar completion is stuck after pressing enter

[w3Abhishek]

Steps to reproduce

• Enter URL or search term in the address bar
• Tap Enter in on-screen keyboard

Expected behavior

Completion section should disappear after clicking enter

Actual behavior

Sometimes closes and sometimes sticks
Ref: https://youtu.be/OR7516clqj4

Device information

• Android device: Realme 5
• Fenix version: Nightly 200926 06:03

┆Issue is synchronized with this Jira Task

[Shamp0o]

Same behavior here on Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 running LineageOS 17.1. Fenix version: 82.0.0-beta.4

[eliserichards]

Same behavior reported here with some additional details: https://www.reddit.com/r/firefox/comments/jiwqal/this_panel_doesnt_go_away_whenever_i_search_by/

[giwrgosmant]

Same behavior on POCO F1 running Pixel Experience Plus Android 10. Firefox Stable Version: 84.1.2 (Build #2015783137)
Really annoying, I had to go back on Chromium base browser because of this.😕 I hope for a fix soon 🤞

[SPLESHER1]

Same behavior on POCO F1. Firefox Stable Version: 84.1.2 (Build #2015783137)

[sflorean]

I wasn't able to reproduce the issue on latest Nightly build with Pixel 3 (Android 11). @giwrgosmant @SPLESHER1 could you check this on Nightly? on stable version will still be reproducible until the bug is landed on release.

[giwrgosmant]

I wasn't able to reproduce the issue on latest Nightly build with Pixel 3 (Android 11). @giwrgosmant @SPLESHER1 could you check this on Nightly? on stable version will still be reproducible until the bug is landed on release.

Hello,

I've just tested it and it persists. Tested with Nightly from Play Store and Firefox Beta 85.0.0-beta.6 from Github.
POCO F1 running Android 10 Pixel Experience Plus.

[mcarare]

Hello,

I've just tested it and it persists. Tested with Nightly from Play Store and Firefox Beta 85.0.0-beta.6 from Github.
POCO F1 running Android 10 Pixel Experience Plus.

@giwrgosmant Nightly 210107?

[giwrgosmant]

Hello,
I've just tested it and it persists. Tested with Nightly from Play Store and Firefox Beta 85.0.0-beta.6 from Github.
POCO F1 running Android 10 Pixel Experience Plus.

@giwrgosmant Nightly 210107?

Seems the nightly version wasn't 210107 at time I tried it. Now I've tried with 210107, all seems fine atm.
I will let you know if I encounter the issue again. Thanks!
EDIT: After I send this post I encounter it again 😕

[mcarare]

I cannot reproduce this (even before the fix) on Nightly or Beta. Also used a Xiaomi Redmi Note 8 Pro, the nearest I have to the reported devices( I do not have a custom OS tough).

[giwrgosmant]

I cannot reproduce this (even before the fix) on Nightly or Beta. Also used a Xiaomi Redmi Note 8 Pro, the nearest I have to the reported devices( I do not have a custom OS tough).

I've recorded a video reproducing that on 210108 Nightly. Check here [link removed]

[mcarare]

@giwrgosmant Do you have gesture navigation enabled and/or customized on your device? Does the issue still occurs when you switch back to 3-button or 2-button navigation?

[giwrgosmant]

@giwrgosmant Do you have gesture navigation enabled and/or customized on your device? Does the issue still occurs when you switch back to 3-button or 2-button navigation?

Yeah I have gesture navigation enabled.
I tried with 3-button and 2-button navigation and the problem seems solved, I switched back to gesture navigation and issue came back. So the problem is with gesture navigation 🤔

[mcarare]

@giwrgosmant Yes, but I think the problem occurs only with a custom OS that implements its own gesture navigation or when using a custom launcher (with a custom gesture navigation as well).
On standard gesture navigation, I am unable to reproduce this.

[giwrgosmant]

@giwrgosmant Yes, but I think the problem occurs only with a custom OS that implements its own gesture navigation or when using a custom launcher (with a custom gesture navigation as well).
On standard gesture navigation, I am unable to reproduce this.

They use the standard Android 10 navigation. There is an option to hide navigation bar pill which I have enabled. I noticed (at least the time I've testing it) if I turned it off I don't have these bar freezes. I don't know if it's related.

[giwrgosmant]

@mcarare I am on Android 11 Pixel Experience now with Navigation bar pill always on and I don't face this issue anymore.
It seems to be related with navigation bar pill which I hide in options back in Android 10 version, but I still don't understand why this affect Firefox at all.

[mcarare]

@giwrgosmant I have tested this in standard Android 10 with different devices and using gesture navigation does not break this feature in Fenix, so I am unable to see what custom OS's change in gestures that interferes with dismissing the dialog fragment.

[mcarare]

Another report, with

My phone is Sony Xperia H3123 running Lineage OS 17.1 (Android 10)

[GottfriedCP]

Another report, with

My phone is Sony Xperia H3123 running Lineage OS 17.1 (Android 10)

@giwrgosmant your suggestion seems to solve my problem

[giwrgosmant]

Another report, with

My phone is Sony Xperia H3123 running Lineage OS 17.1 (Android 10)

@giwrgosmant your suggestion seems to solve my problem

You mean the navigation pill always on?

[stale]

See: #17373 This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

[mariansima]

Could not reproduce this issue on Samsung A8 SM-A530F Android 9 Firefox 93.0a1 2021-08-29