Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

does not work ENABLE_TX_WHEN_AM := 0 allow TX (always FM) when RX is set to AM #65

Closed
lohtse opened this issue Sep 28, 2023 · 27 comments
Closed

Comments

@lohtse
Copy link

lohtse commented Sep 28, 2023

So as the title says

ENABLE_TX_WHEN_AM := 0 allow TX (always FM) when RX is set to AM

Does not work properly

It will work until you recieve and AM TX after that it will continue to say TX disabled no matter what FRQ you are using. only way to resolve in most cases is to reboot radio. Sometimes it will work after around a 30sec or so if NO AM has been recieved.

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

if it's set to '0', then it should always say TX DISABLED if you try and transmit on a channel/freq that is set to AM mode ?

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Sep 28, 2023

if it's set to '0', then it should always say TX DISABLED if you try and transmit on a channel/freq that is set to AM mode ?

TX on an FM band.. will work if no AM trans or no AM trans for quite some time.. BUt if there has been an AM tran it will either take 20-30s before I can TX or will not let me till I reboot radio... Noticed it the other day but forgot to mention. To day was using K5 and was listeninig on AM and FM but could not trans on FM band when I needed

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

oh right, it wasn't letting you TX on an FM chan/freq .. okey doke

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Sep 28, 2023

oh right, it wasn't letting you TX on an FM chan/freq .. okey doke

It used to work.. so it is a recent thing(I think lol)

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

I did recently edit that bit of code, I'll go look in a bit, doing too many things at once at the mo

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Sep 28, 2023

I did recently edit that bit of code, I'll go look in a bit, doing too many things at once at the mo

LOL thats what happens when you have possible the best FW for the K5/6 range lol

Whilst it is import, Just take your time buddy.. I can work with it for now...

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

:)

I think I've fixed it, let me know if not

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Sep 28, 2023

:)

I think I've fixed it, let me know if not

stows as TXing but nothing is actually happening.. And now actually notice that I am not recieving FM trans from other radios... Must be due to AM

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

I don't suppose you can do a quick video ?

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Sep 28, 2023

I don't suppose you can do a quick video ?

just flashing stock.27

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Sep 28, 2023

confirmed the issue is still on .27 I suspect it possibly due to switching modulation from FM to AM and back.. so possible not fixable

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Sep 28, 2023

slightly offtopic but just been posted in telegram group

Bricky, [28/09/2023 19:06]
Think I noticed a mistake in 1o11's lower squelch-1 code. The close RSSI is bigger than the open when it's not airband. Changing it to be smaller makes my radio closer to what my stock 5R picks up.

Bricky, [28/09/2023 19:07]
I'm glad I have a supermarket warehouse nearby to test it out. Spent way too much time trying to make it better.

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

The NOISE and GLITCH squelch setting are the inverse of the RSSI squelch.
so ..
Lower RSSI value = more sensitive squelch.
Higher NOISE value = more sensitive squelch.
Higher GLITCH value = more sensitive squelch.

@bricky149
Copy link
Contributor

Not sure if I'm missing something but I can't reproduce this on latest git build.

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Sep 30, 2023

Not sure if I'm missing something but I can't reproduce this on latest git build.

set chan 1 to AM band

now set chan to to any FM (You can switch the chans it makes no dfference)

Make sure your TX chan is the Fm one

Now trans

Now try trans during or just after an AM RX

it will fail and it will either continue to fail(warning text states TX disabled) or after a 10-20 seconds you can TX again providing you had not RX any further AM band

I fond this happened on even Stock so I would guess it ia a limitation due to the fact it does not have a true AM chip

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

OneOfEleven commented Oct 1, 2023

Is Dual-RX (Dual Watch, TDR) enabled, and if it is, which is set to the main one (solid black little triangle marker) ?

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Oct 1, 2023

Is Dual-RX (Dual Watch) enabled, and if it is, which is set to the main one (solid black little triangle marker) ?

For me with or withot dual watch it happens. the main channel wil always be FM for trans(Black triangle) I never trans on AM band... I have a proper HT for that

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

OneOfEleven commented Oct 1, 2023

The radio does as you say if dual-watch is enable, when it stops/pauses on the AM channel/VFO thats when the TX is disabled when you try to transmit.

If I disable dual-watch, the 'problem' vanishes because you will always transmit on the FM channel.

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

I'll have to see how the original QS firmware operates.

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Oct 1, 2023

I'll have to see how the original QS firmware operates.

Actually stated it is the same (see above)

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

I can't reproduce this when dual-watch is disable :(

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Oct 1, 2023

I can't reproduce this when dual-watch is disable :(

hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm odd but ok..

Actually not odd really as DW watch is listen to two channels where as no DW means you are only listenning on highlighted channel... BUt If I flick back to the AM channel it does happen fromtime to time... But on DW it always happens regardless .

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

Try it now, just uploaded

@lohtse
Copy link
Author

lohtse commented Oct 1, 2023

Try it now, just uploaded

Given the AM issues on current FW's for me I am now using older comps, So even though there is the issue (but not a major one) I don't use newer builds....

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

okey doke

@bricky149
Copy link
Contributor

I don't use DW, might be why I couldn't reproduce. Will try after the compile errors are fixed.

@OneOfEleven
Copy link
Owner

There is still a slight problem with TX'ing when dual-watch is enabled. I'll find the bug, just trying to chill today, so being lazy :)

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants