[PRE REVIEW]: Org-Coursepack #24
Comments
|
|
👋 @csev — The submitting author suggested you as editor. Since this will be your first editing assignment, let me know if you need to bounce ideas about selecting reviewers. Check out the Editor's Guide I put together, if you haven't. It describes the editor workflow, including needed |
|
Reviewer suggestion: I think Stefania Druga (@stefania11) would be a suitable reviewer for this submission. Thank you very much. |
|
Hey @joonro - sorry for the delay. Thanks for your submission. I like the paper and topic a lot. I think we need to explore new ways or authoring, reusing, and remixing each other's content - and in particular doing so though github. A couple of quick questions. (1) There is a ?? in the paper - does that need to be resolved? (2) looking at both the paper and your Repo, I was hoping to find a link to an example web site / course that uses this approach, and (3) if you have an example of any kind of remix / reuse of course materials I think that it would be s nice addition. I understand that even if we prepare for (3) it does not always happen - I just thought I would ask. |
|
Dear @csev - thank you so much for the comments and sorry for the late reply. I have been away for a conference and just got back. I will respond to your comments soon! |
|
@csev, Regarding your question (1), I just fixed the citation with joonro/Org-Coursepack@d667599 - I removed underscores in the BibTeX Key. I'm not sure how to update the compiled pdf file so I cannot verify that the issue is fixed at the moment, but I hope this was the issue. |
|
@whedon generate pdf |
|
|
@csev, the typo (??) in the citation is indeed fixed. Thank you for pointing this out. Regarding your point (2), I created the documentation for Org-Coursepack as a mini-course using Org-Coursepack. The link to the course materials (https://joonro.github.io/Org-Coursepack/) is on the In terms of (3), I have used this to create content for two courses, Marketing Research and Marketing Analytics. These two courses share a significant amount of materials, so I use and mix the modules to meet the need for each course. If these are what you are looking for, I would be happy to provide parts of them (e.g., a couple of lectures) as examples, as some course materials (e.g., exam questions) are private. I hope I understood your questions correctly, if not, please let me know so I can provide you with further information or materials. |
|
@joonro - Thanks for the updates. I just want to go from the paper to some sample course materials with the fewest possible clicks. And while the Org-Coursepack documentation technically is a course - a link to a real course would be more satisfying. I think the best solution would be to add another section to https://github.com/joonro/Org-Coursepack README.md titled "Courses that Use This" (or something similar) and have the links there. You could put one or two links in the paper as well - but to me the most important thing is in the README. |
|
@csev Understood! Thank you very much for your input - I agree I think an actual course content would be ideal here. I will let you know once I add this. |
|
Dear @csev, Thank you again for the constructive suggestion. Per your request, I have updated the repo with two example courses: We believe these example courses are ideal to showcase the Org-Coursepack, since they share a large portion of course materials (both courses involve teaching fundamental statistical concepts, such as hypothesis testing and regression) but also includes some course-specific materials (one course uses Excel and the other uses Python as computational tools for analyses). Users can easily see how to mix and match course content using the Org-Coursepack from these two example courses,. Please note that we added links to these example courses in README as you instructed. Thank you very much for your input. Please feel free to let us know should you have any questions or requests. |
|
Dear @csev, It has been a while since I pushed the updates following your request. I was wondering if you need anything else? Please let me know - thank you so much! |
|
OK, the reviewer is @pschloss |
|
@joonro We re looking for a second reviewer. Stay tuned! |
|
@labarba Thank you very much! Looking forward to working with reviewers to improve the paper. |
|
@gregcaporaso : Might you consider volunteering to review this submission for JOSE? |
|
I'd be happy to, apologies for the delayed response. |
|
@whedon add @gregcaporaso as reviewer |
|
OK, @gregcaporaso is now a reviewer |
|
@whedo start review |
|
@whedon start review |
|
OK, I've started the review over in #34. Feel free to close this issue now! |
Submitting author: @joonro (Joon Ro)
Repository: https://github.com/joonro/Org-Coursepack
Version: v1.0.1
Editor: @csev
Reviewers: @pschloss, @gregcaporaso
Author instructions
Thanks for submitting your paper to JOSE @joonro. The JOSE editor (shown at the top of this issue) will work with you on this issue to find a reviewer for your submission before creating the main review issue.
@joonro if you have any suggestions for potential reviewers then please mention them here in this thread. In addition, this list of people have already agreed to review for JOSE and may be suitable for this submission.
Editor instructions
The JOSE submission bot @whedon is here to help you find and assign reviewers and start the main review. To find out what @whedon can do for you type:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: