Routing for RV (motorhomes), Cargo Trucks and Buses

[biodranik]

There should be an easy UI to somehow input the current car parameters and take them into an account while building a route.
See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:incline, https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:maxweight and https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:maxheight for more details.

Max car speed should be also taken into an account.

[TheAdventurer64]

This is what Waze does:

[pastk]

I wonder what is the difference of these options?

[biodranik]

Yes, the main value is to understand, what exactly should be tuned in the algorithm, and which restrictions should be analyzed/taken from the OSM data.

[SirTypesALot]

Could we also add routing support for mopeds?

[biodranik]

Everything is possible if you can list all differences from car navigation. If we have such a list, then it is possible to develop a proper algorithm. From my understanding, one is that there are some roads where only mopeds are allowed. What else?

[SirTypesALot]

Yes, that is correct. In the Netherlands, mopeds are sometime permitted to use cycling paths, and sometimes not. Do note that there are different classifications of mopeds in the Netherlands. I'll follow up soon when I can give you a clear answer about the classification.

[gtrus21]

Есть ещё ограничения для автобусов. А автобус это или нет - зависит от количества мест в салоне

[gtrus21]

Есть параметр нагрузки на ось (причем на каждую отдельную в зависимости от количества осей). Допустимая общая нагрузка на авто

[gtrus21]

Запрет обгона для грузовиков. Длина грузовика

[gtrus21]

Everything is possible if you can list all differences from car navigation. If we have such a list, then it is possible to develop a proper algorithm. From my understanding, one is that there are some roads where only mopeds are allowed. What else?

Мопеды должны двигаться только по правой полосе, значит в зависимости от количества полос им может быть запрещен поворот налево

[gtrus21]

То есть нужна возможность создавать предметы транспортных средств (машина 1, машина 2) и прицепов. Если у человека две машины (на работу едет на Ладе, а на работе водит грузовик), то переключается между машинами в один клик.
У каждой машины нужна возможность указывать ее тип (обязательно, ведь это может быть как легковушка на 4 тонны, так и грузовик на 3 тонны), количество осей, вес транспорта, длину.
К каждой машине нужна возможность добавлять заготовленные (заранее созданные пользователем) профили прицепов в любом количестве (не забывайте про автопоезда с 5 прицепами).
Ну а уже в быстром доступе нужна кнопка добавления веса груза, который добавится к весу машины

[gtrus21]

Ну и нужна галочка, что данное средство является общественным или такси, чтобы ему разрешалось движение по выделенной полосе

[DavyLandman]

For driving with a car that has a lower limit than the roads allow, for example an legal limit for a trailer, or a physical limit of an older camper for example, it would be great to say: hey, I can only drive 90km/h max, so please take that into account with the estimated total time.

Not many apps have this, and it would be so nice to have a better estimate. Especially if your for example driving on roads in Germany, that allow for 130km/h, but you have a trailer that restricts you to 80km/h

I was looking at graphhopper and noticed they provide you a way to say: hey this is my custom speed limit:

[MBj1703]

Any progress on this?
How can I help?

[pastk]

An elaborated UI/UX design is needed first (preferably in Figma or Penpot or Quant-UX).

Then if you're a developer you can start implementing it 🙏

[MBj1703]

Example from MagicEarth:

[MBj1703]

OsmAnd is also able: https://osmand.net

[Lin-Admin]

Has any expert an estimate how much time it would take to implement this fantastic idea?

[Lin-Admin]

@MBj1703: > OsmAnd is also able: https://osmand.net

I would not mind you to advertise for OsmAnd if they would not charge for the cards :-(