-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
dotted line to indicate toll road dependent from too many facts #19087
Comments
I understand that different map styles show different objects, that is no problem for me. |
Hm, not sure I can reproduce the issue, I just looked at Rome and it seems the toll roads around Rome are correctly shown using the Touring View map style: I also cannot find any dependency of this on the presence or not of any other maps, like the any world overview maps... (Toll in Touring View are the purple dashes. The red/orange is the standard for "motorway"): |
Yes, touring view has the problen to see dotted line only with zoom level > ~12, see my first statement.
|
@sonora |
... and i confirm that dependency of the presence of any other maps, like the world overview maps is only a problem with new rendering engine 2, no problem with r.e. 1. |
@pebogufi Ah, ok, yes, in deed I was testing with v1. I noticed that there had been some small changes to the file some months ago obviously trying to fix some Touring View behavior with the v2 engine, which had elapsed me. I have now made an obvious correction which may fix the issue: osmandapp/OsmAnd-resources@3406f45. Does that solve it? |
Ok, thanks. Now the dotted line for touringview is visible also from zoom level 10 like OsmAnd, Mapnik, Desert |
Right, so it sounds the Touring View specific peculiarity has been resolved and now it needs to be checked why with the v2 engine the world map supresses the toll road display for zoom 10 and 11... |
Would need some investigation from @xmd5a2 to understnad whether it map data issue or rendering engine |
Dev notes: looks like Basemap_SimplifyRoads job is broken. |
Basemap was fixed and updated. Please retest this:
1.Turn on "Show toll restrictions" in Configure map - Details. Ensure that rendering engine is OpenGL. |
Confirm fixed, now I like it so much 😃 |
@sonora |
Ok, let's try! ;) Untested, so please let me know if its really worth it and does not provide more clutter than benefit! |
@xmd5a2 |
Perhaps it's not such a good idea to use minzoom=8 for the toll road display? Because that takes the data off the overview map, and I am not sure it's valid rhere and detailed enough... pls let me know. |
I use "8" since your change at Feb 20, just setting it by hand after every app update in Touring-view_(more-contrast-and-details).render.xml |
One more hint.
In Touring-view_(more-contrast-and-details).render.xml this change was NOT made, In map style OsmAnd and Mapnik Edit: I did not find a situation where "show toll restriction" was used for toll detection, allways "show access restriction" is used. |
Regarding the new separation between access restriction and toll: Yes, there's more and more diversification and detailing happening, which increases not only the complexity and effort for code maintenance (and opens new occasions for bugs to occur and performance to slow), but in the end also demands more time from users to configure everything to their liking and usability. :( Oh well, I can take the time to look at it... |
If basemap generated please close it @xmd5a2 |
@pebogufi Please create a different issue for this (#19087 (comment)) |
How to test: #19087 (comment) |
Review
|
Reverted to combined option of toll//access |
Description
The display of the dotted line of toll roads on streets depends on zoom level (ok),
map style (bug?),
presence of world overview map (NOT mini) (bug)
Steps to reproduce
dotted line is visible if
zoom level > ~10 AND
map style is in (OsmAnd, Mapnik, Desert) AND
world overview map (NOT mini) DEactivated
if different map style (touringview, ?)
OR world overview map activated
then
dotted line is visible if
zoom level > ~12
For planing a longer trip it is better to see dotted line on lower zoom levels like 10. So for planning i have to deactivate world overview map to get more overview
Actual result
See above
Expected result
See above
Your Environment (required)
OsmAnd Version: OsmAnd~ 4.7.0#1572m, veröffentlicht: 2024-02-12
Android version: 10
Device model: samsung tab S5e
Crash-Logs: no
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: