dotted line to indicate toll road dependent from too many facts

[pebogufi]

Description

The display of the dotted line of toll roads on streets depends on zoom level (ok),
map style (bug?),
presence of world overview map (NOT mini) (bug)

Steps to reproduce

dotted line is visible if
zoom level > ~10 AND
map style is in (OsmAnd, Mapnik, Desert) AND
world overview map (NOT mini) DEactivated

if different map style (touringview, ?)
OR world overview map activated
then
dotted line is visible if
zoom level > ~12

For planing a longer trip it is better to see dotted line on lower zoom levels like 10. So for planning i have to deactivate world overview map to get more overview

Actual result

See above

Expected result

See above

Your Environment (required)

OsmAnd Version: OsmAnd~ 4.7.0#1572m, veröffentlicht: 2024-02-12
Android version: 10
Device model: samsung tab S5e
Crash-Logs: no

[yuriiurshuliak]

I tried to reproduce the problem by comparing two map styles, OsmAnd and Touringview and with the world overview map enabled. At zoom level 12, the dashed toll line is displayed in both styles and with the world overview map enabled. However, at zoom level 10 the Access Toll is represented by a dashed line exclusively in the OsmAnd map style, while in Touringview it is shown as solid orange-yellow lines. And when the world overview map is turned on, it is not displayed at all.

It is worth noting that different map styles satisfy different requirements, and the variations observed may be influenced by the specific characteristics of each style.

OsmAnd~ 4.7.0#1627m, released: 2024-02-19

OsmAnd	Touringview	Activated world overview map

OsmAnd	Touringview	Activated world overview map

[pebogufi]

I understand that different map styles show different objects, that is no problem for me.
But i don't understand that the presence (visibility) of world overview map inhibits the dotted line for some map styles for zoom level 11 and 12.
Is it possible that world overview map overwrites regional map (dotted line) at theese two zoom levels with the motorway line red/yellow/red ?

[sonora]

Hm, not sure I can reproduce the issue, I just looked at Rome and it seems the toll roads around Rome are correctly shown using the Touring View map style: I also cannot find any dependency of this on the presence or not of any other maps, like the any world overview maps... (Toll in Touring View are the purple dashes. The red/orange is the standard for "motorway"):

[pebogufi]

Yes, touring view has the problen to see dotted line only with zoom level > ~12, see my first statement.
Please try with map style in (OsmAnd, Mapnik, Desert) AND then
world overview map (NOT mini) DEactivated
Or activated.

• DEactivated - dotted line visible when zoom level > ~10

• activated - dotted line visible when zoom level > ~12

[pebogufi]

@sonora
Looks like you use rendering engine 1, I can confirm that it shows dotted line wth Touring View from zoom 10, thats ok, i love it !
But with rendering engine 2 it shows dotted line with Touring View only from zoom level 12.

[pebogufi]

... and i confirm that dependency of the presence of any other maps, like the world overview maps is only a problem with new rendering engine 2, no problem with r.e. 1.
Sorry since some months I use only the new r.e. 2, i did not report that or check it before.

[sonora]

@pebogufi Ah, ok, yes, in deed I was testing with v1.

I noticed that there had been some small changes to the file some months ago obviously trying to fix some Touring View behavior with the v2 engine, which had elapsed me. I have now made an obvious correction which may fix the issue: osmandapp/OsmAnd-resources@3406f45. Does that solve it?

[pebogufi]

Ok, thanks. Now the dotted line for touringview is visible also from zoom level 10 like OsmAnd, Mapnik, Desert
BUT ONLY if world overview maps is DEactivated.
If activated, it is visible only from zoom level 12.
For me, that is the major problem.

[sonora]

Right, so it sounds the Touring View specific peculiarity has been resolved and now it needs to be checked why with the v2 engine the world map supresses the toll road display for zoom 10 and 11...

[vshcherb]

Would need some investigation from @xmd5a2 to understnad whether it map data issue or rendering engine

[xmd5a2]

Dev notes: looks like Basemap_SimplifyRoads job is broken.

[xmd5a2]

Basemap was fixed and updated. Please retest this:

Right, so it sounds the Touring View specific peculiarity has been resolved and now it needs to be checked why with the v2 engine the world map supresses the toll road display for zoom 10 and 11...

1.Turn on "Show toll restrictions" in Configure map - Details. Ensure that rendering engine is OpenGL.
2.Download full basemap
3.Download Russia_moskovskaya-oblast_asia map
4.Go to https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/870545810 and see that it has dots on it at zoom 10-11
Zoom 10:

Zoom 11:

[pebogufi]

Confirm fixed, now I like it so much 😃
Thanks a lot, Peter

[pebogufi]

@pebogufi Ah, ok, yes, in deed I was testing with v1.

I noticed that there had been some small changes to the file some months ago obviously trying to fix some Touring View behavior with the v2 engine, which had elapsed me. I have now made an obvious correction which may fix the issue: osmandapp/OsmAnd-resources@3406f45. Does that solve it?

@sonora
Due to your fix I know where the zoom factor can be set. Thanks a lot. Currently I set it after every update to 8 which is fantastic for planing long travel.
Could you please set it to 8 in the resources ?
This would be really great 🌞

[sonora]

Ok, let's try! ;) Untested, so please let me know if its really worth it and does not provide more clutter than benefit!

[pebogufi]

@xmd5a2
NEW BUG in new version of new created "world overview map".
In France a part of a motorway is now tagged as "with toll" which is wrong, see detail local maps.
E11 (A 75) south of Clemont-Ferrand
Wrong part starting near Brioude 45.29450 N, 3.24316 E
to south
Beziers 43.33950 N, 3.29621 E
Between theese two points is only a smal part WITH TOLL, the bridge in the west of Millau "Viaduc de Millau" 44.07866 N, 3.02333 E.

[sonora]

Perhaps it's not such a good idea to use minzoom=8 for the toll road display? Because that takes the data off the overview map, and I am not sure it's valid rhere and detailed enough... pls let me know.

[pebogufi]

I use "8" since your change at Feb 20, just setting it by hand after every app update in Touring-view_(more-contrast-and-details).render.xml
line 1321 and I am absolutely happy with it.
I am traveling through south of france since 3 weeks.
It is perfect for planing over some distance and of course also present when zooming more in.

[pebogufi]

One more hint.
The option "show access restriction" was divided into

• "show access restriction"
  and
• "show toll restriction"

In Touring-view_(more-contrast-and-details).render.xml this change was NOT made,
toll works with "show access restriction" until now.

In map style OsmAnd and Mapnik
toll works with "show access restriction" until now.

Edit: I did not find a situation where "show toll restriction" was used for toll detection, allways "show access restriction" is used.

[sonora]

Regarding the new separation between access restriction and toll: Yes, there's more and more diversification and detailing happening, which increases not only the complexity and effort for code maintenance (and opens new occasions for bugs to occur and performance to slow), but in the end also demands more time from users to configure everything to their liking and usability. :( Oh well, I can take the time to look at it...

[vshcherb]

If basemap generated please close it @xmd5a2

[xmd5a2]

@pebogufi Please create a different issue for this (#19087 (comment))

[xmd5a2]

How to test: #19087 (comment)

[dmpr0]

Review

• Proper instructions are required. Mentioned one dotted line to indicate toll road dependent from too many facts #19087 (comment), mention menu item that doesn't exist anymore.

[vshcherb]

Reverted to combined option of toll//access