New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
For a shop both cafe and bakery #4008
Comments
This relates to PR #4005 and Juan Valdez Cafe too. There are no perfect answers to these questions, but I will try to explain my thinking about what the tags mean. We mostly try to assign a single
I agree that there are places where both things are equally true and where assigning both tags would be appropriate - but most places lean towards one or the other. We try to add whichever single tag best matches the businesses. We also are ok with changing the tags later if mappers picked an imperfect tag initially, or if a new better tag gains acceptance. Just because a customer can buy snacks or coffee beans at a coffeehouse and leave , doesn't make a cafe into a Additionally, sometimes it is more appropriate to tag the different parts of a business as different features (a point for the shop and a point for the cafe). This is true when the different parts have different phone numbers, opening hours, etc.. There have been some related issues where people have either asked for support for dual tagging, or asked for a way to hint to the user that features should split into separate POIs - neither of these are really easy to do. So all that said, if you really want to add both |
Should this be closed? |
I had to make a similar decision about GAIL's in the UK and went with bakery as that's what they market themselves as. |
Few days ago when I mapping a bakery/cafe (85°C bakery cafe) nearby my home, I found that the brand is classified as cafe without shop=bakery. And when I checked the cafe.json I found that none of the cafe have shop=bakery tag.
name-suggestion-index/brands/amenity/cafe.json
Lines 24 to 37 in 77d562a
Then I found Paul, a French bakery branch. I Google a lot and found that in many of the Paul customers buy bread and some of them may sit there and have a cup of coffee, matching the description of amenity=cafe but only in bakery.json
name-suggestion-index/brands/shop/bakery.json
Lines 671 to 680 in 77d562a
I also checked taginfo there are more than 3000 elements have amenity=cafe + shop=bakery at the same time. I believe that bakery cafe is a common type of store all around the world and amenity=cafe + shop=bakery is a good way to tag them.
So I have few questions:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: