Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Nov 14, 2018. It is now read-only.

Gallery app can't share public via link? [$335 awarded] #1147

Closed
ccoenen opened this issue Jun 6, 2013 · 67 comments · Fixed by #1476
Closed

Gallery app can't share public via link? [$335 awarded] #1147

ccoenen opened this issue Jun 6, 2013 · 67 comments · Fixed by #1476
Labels

Comments

@ccoenen
Copy link

ccoenen commented Jun 6, 2013

I tried sharing a gallery publicly, but the share functionality in files seems to be a different one than the one in pictures.

Under "files" i can Share with either a person, a group or with a link containing a token

Under "pictures" there's just the person / group functionality.

Is it possible to share via link as well? If not, would you consider adding this?

@gilou
Copy link

gilou commented Jun 7, 2013

that would be awesome, or maybe have an option to have thumbnails so we can share a directory of picture in a more convenient way..

@ccoenen
Copy link
Author

ccoenen commented Jun 7, 2013

@gilou I seem to remember that this was possible from the files-view a while back. But i can't figure out how it worked. It may have been droppend vom OC5 or my memory is off.

@tetefolle
Copy link

Please please, solve this problem! I am using already drobpox and I like very much. However, in order to convince my friends of owncloud this problem has to be solved....

@fiedl
Copy link

fiedl commented Jun 18, 2013

+1

@tetefolle
Copy link

äh, sorry, of course I meant "I am using already ownCloud and I like it very much..." You can see how far the monopolz of dropbox is already going!

@idef1x
Copy link

idef1x commented Jun 28, 2013

Indeed sharing to the public should be in gallery view, not a file listing. owncloud can't replace dropbox (or alike) for me if this isn't implemented.

@blub3k
Copy link

blub3k commented Jul 17, 2013

+1

@altiOnGithub
Copy link

Sharing a Gallery with a Link would be really cool !! +1

@ancow
Copy link

ancow commented Jul 28, 2013

According to http://owncloud.org/features/ (see Other Features -> Galleries), it should already be possible to share galleries with random email addresses, which would imply some sort of link sharing functionality in the pictures app.
However, I can't seem to find such a feature, so it might just be a marketing lie/oversight...

@DeepDiver1975
Copy link
Contributor

guys we lost the maintainer of this app long time ago - a major rewrite some month ago pushed the gallery's look and feel pretty much and added sharing within ownCloud.

Feel free to step ahead and implement that feature - THX

@janrudolf
Copy link

Thank you for that information, @DeepDiver1975.
Hopefully someone who is able to implement that feature can be found!

@tetefolle
Copy link

Actually, I would willing to pay some money if someone could solve that problem. How about if we raise some money to motivate the work? If everyone of us who is interested pays 10€$ then it would be maybe easier to get this done. I would do it, if I had the programming knowledge, but unfortunately I don't.

@micfra
Copy link

micfra commented Aug 17, 2013

@tetefolle Do you think this will work? I'd like to start small fund raise at kickstarter to get this thing and maybe some other issues of gallery/images done. I've seen a similar approach over here http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/2080075632/the-grails-resources-plugin-12-blitz which was not successful - think he wanted to much money to be raised.

@tetefolle
Copy link

Hi micfra, I think it is worth trying. What do you think would be an appropriate amount?

@dretek
Copy link

dretek commented Aug 22, 2013

@micfra @tetefolle I would also be willing to pay for this feature. It seems to me like its pretty an essential feature. Also it looks as though at one point it was in place. Any how I can suggest possibly a crowd source funder for this - http://coinfunder.com/ I am more than willing to pay in Bitcoin. - Plus it is far easier than using boring slow and expensive fiat.

@dretek
Copy link

dretek commented Aug 22, 2013

+2

@tetefolle
Copy link

@dretek, @micfra, whether it is coinfunder or kickstarter, I don't care, can we start either? I have no experience with crowdfunding, so you both might discuss this.

I am getting really annoyed with my photo galleries. For reasong of personal security I don't want to use dropbox but still want to show photos to friends. I have rented my own server for this purpose. However, photo management on my wordpress blog is quite tidious. With owncloud it could be so easy, if only, if you could share it also with non-owncloud-users.

@ccverg
Copy link

ccverg commented Aug 22, 2013

@tetefolle @dretek @micfra have you heard of Bountysource? You can start a bounty for this issue (and all other issues within this project) here: https://www.bountysource.com/issues/831597

@tetefolle
Copy link

@ccvergara I think this seems to be the perfect platform. @micfra @dretek what do you think? If you don't mind, I'd start something on bountysource.

@micfra
Copy link

micfra commented Aug 25, 2013

@ccvergara thank you for that hint. I will try that and will get in touch with the apps maintainers to get it pulled after its done. So please get some backers in there: Having a bounty of at least 100$ total would be enough! Go for https://www.bountysource.com/issues/831597

@tetefolle
Copy link

just put $15 in. Please contribute!

@ccverg
Copy link

ccverg commented Aug 26, 2013

@micfra @tetefolle you're welcome. Glad it worked out!

@0x4a
Copy link

0x4a commented Sep 1, 2013

$5 from me. lets spread the link to other places!

@bwalter
Copy link

bwalter commented Sep 4, 2013

It would indeed be a killer feature and additionally be a good way to make OwnCloud more famous! Have just given $10 and hope that more people will follow. https://www.bountysource.com/issues/831597

@dinobert
Copy link

I've just placed a bounty of $10!

@tetefolle
Copy link

cool!

On 13/09/2013 15:48, dinobert wrote:

I've just placed a bounty of $10!


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#1147 (comment).

@lcsiki
Copy link

lcsiki commented Sep 20, 2013

Is this really that complicated to realise? For me it would work via the "Files" sharing as well, you just need to implement to go to the next image.

@ccverg
Copy link

ccverg commented Sep 22, 2013

The bounty is up to $235 now!

@tetefolle
Copy link

Why doesn't it show our initiative on the page with bounty projects? That would be certainly useful to promote our initiative...
https://www.bountysource.com/trackers/47-bountysource-frontend
Also, when you search bountysource.com, our bounty is not found.
@ccvergara : do you have a solution?
You are affiliated with bountysource.com, aren't you?
Cheers

@EricReiche
Copy link

I just installed the 6 beta 2, the link sharing for the gallery is STILL missing. WTF?

@EricReiche
Copy link

As I commented a few comments above, I was thinking of doing it until someone here said it will come with OC6. So I thought: OK, I can wait a few more weeks.
Trying the beta lead to disappointment.
Sorry if my comment seemed rude, but this feature is on the feature list for months and feels like a marketing lie.
As far as I understand, there is also a company behind this project. Of course I also understand the idea of open source.

This is literally the only thing which keeps me using dropbox, and as you can see from the mentioned bounty, I'm not the only one.
At the moment I have to invest all my time at work and can't work on this feature before december.

@tetefolle
Copy link

Hi Eric, I absolutely agree about the necessity to implement this feature. However, as far I understand it was not "promised" for the v6 release
https://github.com/owncloud/core/wiki/ownCloud-6-Features

@karlitschek what's your opinion?

@EricReiche
Copy link

No, it is even promised for the current version: http://owncloud.org/features/

Share Your Data
Share your data with others, and give them access to your latest photo galleries, your calendar, your music, or anything else you want them to see. Share it publicly, or privately. It is your data, do what you want with it.

@dosch
Copy link

dosch commented Nov 4, 2013

OC: If this doesn't get build anytime soon, just take it of the features page until it does. It will save you a lot of trouble... People are annoyed that the feature isn't there, but advertising that it is, is just lying. Don't be surprised when people get upset then.

Wow. There is $1,855 in total in Bountysource. And $310 for this feature. That is a huge part of the total funds of the site.

@MrCustomizer
Copy link

This seems to be related to issue #411. If the core of owncloud has to be enhanced for public gallery sharing, the people implementing this, should have that issue in mind, too. I think it could also profit from such a modification of the core.

@jancborchardt
Copy link
Contributor

This will be reintroduced with the pull request #1476 – if you are interested in this feature, please test that code! :)

@tetefolle
Copy link

I am interested, how do I test the code? Can I implement the code in my existing OC installation?

@DeepDiver1975
Copy link
Contributor

@tetefolle #1476 has been implemented for OC6 - do you have an OC6 instance at hand? THX

@tetefolle
Copy link

How do I update to OC6? My update center says "up to date" but I am
still at OC5...

On 19/11/2013 14:20, Thomas Müller wrote:

@tetefolle https://github.com/tetefolle #1476
#1476 has been implemented for
OC6 - do you have an OC6 instance at hand? THX


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#1147 (comment).

@karlitschek
Copy link
Contributor

@tetefolle ownCloud 6 is not released yet. Will be in the next 3-4 weeks.

@tetefolle
Copy link

ok, I will wait then so long. If gallery sharing works. What are we
supposed to do with the bounty then?

On 19/11/2013 15:32, Frank Karlitschek wrote:

@tetefolle https://github.com/tetefolle ownCloud 6 is not released
yet. Will be in the next 3-4 weeks.


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#1147 (comment).

@karlitschek
Copy link
Contributor

I hink @DeepDiver1975 implemented it so he should get the bounty IMHO. What do others think?

@tetefolle
Copy link

I would be happy with that solution. Can we wait until the release of
the final version to see whether it is working to the satisfaction of
the respective donors?

cheers jakob

On 21/11/2013 12:15, Frank Karlitschek wrote:

I hink @DeepDiver1975 https://github.com/DeepDiver1975 implemented it
so he should get the bounty IMHO. What do others think?


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#1147 (comment).

@0x4a
Copy link

0x4a commented Nov 21, 2013

I think thats the way it should go: wait with the bounty until a final version with this feature is released.
I think the actual process is tied to the issue on github being resolved

@tetefolle
Copy link

ok, I am just a newbie to this entire process...

On 21/11/2013 13:58, Jekyll wrote:

I think thats the way it should go: wait with the bounty until a final
version with this feature is released.
I think the actual process is tied to the issue on github being resolved


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#1147 (comment).

@DeepDiver1975
Copy link
Contributor

haha - yes there is a bounty on that - lol

In case my implementation is considered good enough to claim the bounty I'll donate this to some social organization or project. I'm already getting paid for hacking ownCloud

@tetefolle
Copy link

nice move!

On 21/11/2013 14:08, Thomas Müller wrote:

haha - yes there is a bounty on that - lol

In case my implementation is considered good enough to claim the bounty
I'll donate this to some social organization or project. I'm already
getting paid for hacking ownCloud


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#1147 (comment).

@etiess
Copy link

etiess commented Nov 21, 2013

Nice @DeepDiver1975 !

What about putting the bounty on owncloud/client#994, which is the most commented issue ever on Owncloud? Or has it been fixed in OC6?

@DeepDiver1975
Copy link
Contributor

Putting a bounty on that issue is pointless - this really touches the core mechanisms of syncing which involves client and server knowhow and many more.

We already spent a lot of time to analyze this issue - some fixes have been pushed to oc6.
Let's see if it will help at the end.

@tetefolle
Copy link

I'd like to wait with accepting the claim request until OwnCloud 6 final has been published in order to test this feature...

@tetefolle
Copy link

ok...

On 26/11/2013 13:55, Thomas Müller wrote:

@tetefolle https://github.com/tetefolle FYI
http://daily.owncloud.com/master/owncloud/public.php?service=gallery&t=5e83853da71bce022dd0119f04f260bc


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#1147 (comment).

@DeepDiver1975 DeepDiver1975 changed the title Gallery app can't share public via link? Gallery app can't share public via link? [$335 awarded] Jan 30, 2017
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.