groupby.apply datetime bug affecting 0.17

[hadjmic]

Exception is raised when
a) the original dataframe has a datetime column
b) the groupby.apply function returns a series object with a new datetime column

Code to reproduce:

import pandas as pd
import datetime

df = pd.DataFrame([['1', datetime.datetime.today()], 
                   ['2', datetime.datetime.today()],
                   ['2', datetime.datetime(2010, 1, 1)]],
                   columns=['record', 'date'])
dd = df.groupby('record').apply(lambda x: pd.Series({'max_date': x['date'].max()}))

This is a new issue affecting 0.17

[jreback]

canonical way of selection a max column (and way way more efficient)

In [59]: df.groupby('record').date.max()
Out[59]: 
record
1   2015-10-14 07:59:04.094327
2   2015-10-14 07:59:04.094343
Name: date, dtype: datetime64[ns]

[jreback]

I guess this a bug. You are doing a really really odd thing here though.

[hadjmic]

Imagine it in the following context:
you have a massive apache event log that you import in a pandas dataframe. The dataframe has as columns:
event_id, user_identifier, event_type, timestamp, other stuff

Objective is to create a new dataframe to see what the users have done. Thus, need to group by the user_identifier and somehow aggregate the events of each user. One of the things you need to find is the first and last timestmap the user interacted with the server.

Hope this clarifies things a bit.

Pandas is awesome by the way, you guys rule.

[TomAugspurger]

@hadjmic would

df.groupby(['user_identifier']).timestamp.agg(['min, 'max'])

work for you? You can also control the naming with .timestamp.agg({'max_date': 'max', 'min_date': 'min'}) (I might have the keys and values of that dictionary backward).
That will give the first (min) and last (max) timestamp per user. I guess you said that's just one of the things you need.

[jreback]

did my example in [59] not clarify? my point is technically using apply like this is ok, but canonically it is quite confusing.

[hadjmic]

Perhaps it would have been clearer if I said I have a processUserEvents function. The function takes a dataframe of user events as input (i.e. each group of the groupby operation) and returns back a Series with specific user characteristics. Among those, are the min and max of the timestamp, but there are a lot of other stuff involved, such as values extracted from url paths, query strings, flow paths, etc.

[jreback]

closed by #11548