comparison.md

title	description	excerpt	date	lastmod	draft	images	menu	weight	toc
Comparison with other projects	See how Pomsky compares to similar projects		2022-07-10 16:21:58 +0000	2023-03-21 20:29:00 +0000	false		docs parent appendix	10001	true

This wiki has a list of projects with similar goals to Pomsky. Here's a list of the most popular projects:

{{< alert icon="⚠️" text="Disclaimer that as the maintainer of Pomsky, I am obviously biased. If you find any incorrect or misleading information, please open an issue." />}}

Project	Types	GitHub
Melody	Transpiled	{{}}
Pomsky	Transpiled	{{}}
Egg Expressions	Transpiled App: Oil shell
Rx Expressions	Transpiled App: Emacs
Raku Grammars	App: Raku
Rosie	App: Rosie
SRL	DSL: PHP	{{}}
Super Expressive	DSL: JS	{{}}
Verbal Expressions	DSL: JS	{{}}
Swift RegexBuilder	DSL: Swift

Since this content is likely to get out of date, I encourage you to update it.

Types

Transpiled

These languages are transpiled to "normal" regular expressions and can therefore be used anywhere. They usually have command-line interface to compile expressions.

Application specific

Some regex languages are specific to a certain application or programming language. For example, Raku grammars can only be used in Raku; egg expressions are transpiled, but they are only available in the Oil shell.

DSLs

DSLs (domain-specific languages) are languages that are embedded in another language using the host language's syntax. For example, Verbal Expressions uses JavaScript methods:

const tester = VerEx()
  .startOfLine()
  .then('http')
  .maybe('s')
  .then('://')
  .maybe('www.')
  .anythingBut(' ')
  .endOfLine()

This page currently only discusses transpiled languages, but I welcome contributions.

Compatibility

Let's see what Regex flavors are supported by transpiled languages.

Flavor	Melody	Pomsky	Egg Expr.	Rx Expr.
ERE			✅	✅
ECMAScript	✅	✅
PCRE	✅*	✅
.NET	✅*	✅
Java	✅*	✅
Ruby	✅*	✅
Python		✅
Rust		✅

^*Melody can only emit ECMAScript regexes, but they also happen to be compatible with several other flavors.

Explanation of the flavors

• ERE (extended regular expressions) are used by tools such as GNU grep and awk. Because ERE supports only the most basic features, it is mostly forward compatible with other regex flavors.

• ECMAScript is the syntax used in JavaScript and related languages (TypeScript, Elm, Dart, etc.) that are compiled to JS.

• PCRE (an acronym for "Perl compatible regular expression") is the syntax used by the PCRE2 regex engine, which is the default in at least Crystal, Delphi, Elixir, Erlang, Hack, Julia, PHP, R and Vala. It's also a popular choice in other languages like C and C++ and is used in many applications such as the Apache server, nginx, MariaDB, MongoDB, and optionally in GNU grep.

• .NET refers to the Regex class in .NET languages such as C# and F#.

• Java refers to the Pattern class in Java's standard library. Equivalent to Kotlin's and Scala's regular expressions.

• Ruby refers to built-in regular expressions in Ruby.

• Python refers to Pythons re module. Note that Python 3 is required for good Unicode support.

• Rust refers to Rust's popular regex crate (used by ripgrep)

Many more flavors exist, which are not (or only partially) supported by Pomsky and other languages.

Features

Let's see what Regex features are supported by languages that are transpiled to regular expressions.

Basic regex features

Feature	Melody	Pomsky	Egg Expr.	Rx Expr.
Greedy repetition	✅	✅	✅	✅
Lazy repetition	✅	✅	✅	✅
Dot	✅	✅	✅	✅
Character escape	✅	✅	✅	✅
Character class	✅	✅	✅	✅
Anchor	✅	✅	✅	✅
Word boundary	✅	✅	✅	✅
Negated word boundary	✅	✅	✅	✅
Character range	partly*	✅	✅	✅
Character set		✅	✅	✅
Negated character set	partly*	✅	✅	✅
Capturing group	✅	✅	✅	✅
Alternation	✅	✅	✅	✅
POSIX class		✅	✅	✅
Non-capturing group	✅	✅	✅

^*Character ranges and negated sets in Melody only support ASCII letters, digits and a few special characters.

Advanced features

Feature	Melody	Pomsky	Egg Expr.	Rx Expr.
Variable/macro	✅	✅	✅	✅
Line comment	✅	✅	✅	✅
Block comment	✅
Code point		✅	✅
Lookaround	✅	✅
Named capturing group	✅	✅	✅
Backreference		✅		✅
Named backreference		✅
Relative backreference		✅
Unicode category	✅	✅
Unicode script/block		✅		partly
Other Unicode property		✅
Any code point	partly*	✅	partly*	partly*
Any grapheme		✅
Atomic group		✅
Character set intersection				✅
Character set subtraction
Possessive quantifier
Conditional
Recursion
Modifier
Inline regex	✅	✅
Optimization		some**

Note that Melody and Pomsky support inline regexes. Because of this, all Regex features are technically supported in Melody and Pomsky, but using inline regexes may be less ergonomic and more dangerous to use than properly supported features.

^*All languages can match a code point with the dot, if multiline mode is enabled in the regex engine.

^**Pomsky can currently optimize repetitions, remove redundant or empty groups and deduplicate code points in character sets. More optimizations are planned.

Tooling

Tool	Melody	Pomsky	Egg Expr.	Rx Expr.
CLI	✅	✅
REPL	✅		✅
Online playground	✅	✅
VSCode extension	✅
IntelliJ extension	✅
JavaScript bunder	Babel	Vite, Rollup, ESBuild, Webpack
Rust macro		✅
Linter
Formatter

Language integrations

Packages

Tool	Melody	Pomsky
Homebrew	✅	✅
AUR	✅	✅
Nix	✅	✅
GitHub release binary (Apple)	✅	✅
GitHub release binary (Windows)		✅
GitHub release binary (Linux)		✅
Node module	✅	✅
Python module	✅

IDE features

Feature	Melody	Pomsky
Syntax highlighting	✅	✅
Error highlighting		✅
Code folding	✅1	✅1
Auto indentation	✅	✅
Snippets	✅	✅
Matching brackets and quotes	✅2	✅
Keyword autocomplete	✅2	✅
Variable autocomplete		✅3
Backreference autocomplete
Character class autocomplete		✅
Unicode property autocomplete		✅
Hover tooltips
Apply suggestions
Share link (playground)	✅	✅

¹ indentation based
² works in playground VSCode, but not in the playground
³ does not take scopes into account

---

Found a mistake? Please fix it on GitHub.