Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Defining a method that has the same name as a command breaks the command #1407

Closed
kyrylo opened this issue Mar 31, 2015 · 2 comments
Closed
Labels

Comments

@kyrylo
Copy link
Member

kyrylo commented Mar 31, 2015

I tested this on the ls command. Broken.

[1] pry(main)> def ls
             |   :wqeqw
             | end  
=> :ls
[2] pry(main)> ls
NoMethodError: undefined method `ceiling' for :wqeqw:Symbol
from /home/kyrylo/.gem/ruby/2.2.0/gems/pry-0.10.1/lib/pry/commands/ls/methods.rb:50:in `below_ceiling'

However, if you do the same with, say, the whereami command, it works well.

@kyrylo kyrylo added the bug label Mar 31, 2015
@egwspiti
Copy link
Contributor

[1] pry(main)> def ls ; 5 ; end
=> :ls
[2] pry(main)> _pry_.config.ls
=> 5

_pry_.config, being an instance of Pry::Config, uses #method_missing to traverse a chain of parents in order to locate 'ls' key and then install a method for it. However, having 'ls' defined on Object prevents #method_missing from being called. This is further exemplified by noticing the following behavior:

[1] pry(main)> class X ; end
=> nil
[2] pry(main)> ls X
Object.methods: yaml_tag
[3] pry(main)> def ls ; 5; end
=> :ls
[4] pry(main)> ls X
Object.methods: yaml_tag
[5] pry(main)> 

We can see that using the ls command before defining an #ls method on Object doesn't break ls command when we use it afterwards.

Thus the only way to solve this bug is to redesign Pry::Config to not rely on #method_missing.

@kyrylo
Copy link
Member Author

kyrylo commented Jul 22, 2015

@strcmp is a Pry::Config veteran. Let him speak.

@0x1eef 0x1eef closed this as completed in 0a84449 Jul 24, 2015
0x1eef pushed a commit that referenced this issue Jul 27, 2015
netbsd-srcmastr pushed a commit to NetBSD/pkgsrc that referenced this issue Mar 14, 2018
pkgsrc change: add support for pkg_alternatives

### HEAD

#### Features

* Add Pry::Testable, an improved modular replacement for PryTestHelpers.
  **breaking change**.

See pull request [#1679](pry/pry#1679).

* Add a new category module: "Pry::Platform". Loosely related to #1668 below.

See pull request [#1670](pry/pry#1670)

* Add `mac_osx?` and `linux?` utility functions to Pry::Helpers::BaseHelpers.

See pull request [#1668](pry/pry#1668).

* Add utility functions for drawing colorised text on a colorised background.

See pull request [#1673](pry/pry#1673).

#### Bug fixes

* Fix a case of infinite recursion in `Pry::Method::WeirdMethodLocator#find_method_in_superclass`
  that users of the [Hanami](http://hanamirb.org/) web framework experienced and
  reported since 2015.

See pull request [#1639](pry/pry#1689).

* Fix a bug where Method objects were not returned for setters inherited
  from a default (Pry::Config::Default). Eg, this is no longer an error:

      pry(main)> d = Pry::Config.from_hash({}, Pry::Config::Default.new)
      pry(main)> d.method(:exception_whitelist=) # Error

See pull request [#1688](pry/pry#1688).

* Do not capture unused Proc objects in Text helper methods `no_color` and `no_paging`,
  for performance reasons. Improve the documentation of both methods.

See pull request [#1691](pry/pry#1691).

* Fix `String#pp` output color.

See pull request [#1674](pry/pry#1674).

### 0.11.0

* Add alias 'whereami[?!]+' for 'whereami' command. ([#1597](pry/pry#1597))
* Improve Ruby 2.4 support ([#1611](pry/pry#1611)):
  * Deprecated constants are hidden from `ls` output by default, use the `-d` switch to see them.
  * Fix warnings that originate in Pry while using the repl.
* Improve completion speed in large applications. ([#1588](pry/pry#1588))
* Pry::ColorPrinter.pp: add `newline` argument and pass it on to PP. ([#1603](pry/pry#1603))
* Use `less` or system pager pager on MS Windows if it is available. ([#1512](pry/pry#1512))
* Add `Pry.configure` as an alternative to the current way of changing configuration options in `.pryrc` files. ([#1502](pry/pry#1502))
* Add `Pry::Config::Behavior#eager_load!` to add a possible workaround for issues like ([#1501](pry/pry#1501))
* Remove Slop as a runtime dependency by vendoring v3.4 as Pry::Slop.
  People can depend on Slop v4 and Pry at the same time without running into version conflicts. ([#1497](pry/pry#1497))
* Fix auto-indentation of code that uses a single-line rescue ([#1450](pry/pry#1450))
* Remove "Pry::Config#refresh", please use "Pry::Config#clear" instead.
* Defining a method called "ls" no longer breaks the "ls" command ([#1407](pry/pry#1407))
* Don't raise when directory permissions don't allow file expansion ([#1432](pry/pry#1432))
* Syntax highlight <tt> tags in documentation output.
* Add support for BasicObject subclasses who implement their own #inspect (#1341)
* Fix 'include RSpec::Matchers' at the top-level (#1277)
* Add 'gem-readme' command, prints the README file bundled with a rubygem
* Add 'gem-search' command, searches for a gem with the rubygems.org HTTP API
* Fixed bug in the `cat` command where it was impossible to use line numbers with files ([#1349](pry/pry#1349))
* Fixed uncaught Errno::EOPNOTSUPP exception when $stdout is a socket ([#1352](pry/pry#1352))
* Display a warning when you cd'ed inside a C object and executed 'show-source' without arguments ([#691](pry/pry#691))
* Make the stagger_output method more reliable by reusing possibly available Pry instance ([#1364](pry/pry#1364))
* Make the 'gem-install' message less confusing by removing backticks ([#1350](pry/pry#1350))
* Fixed error when Pry was trying to load incompatible versions of plugins ([#1312](pry/pry#1312))
* Fixed bug when `hist --clear` led to ArgumentError ([#1340](pry/pry#1340))
* Fixed the "uninitialized constant Pry::ObjectPath::StringScanner" exception during autocomplete ([#1330](pry/pry#1330))
* Secured usage of colours with special characters (RL_PROMPT_START_IGNORE and RL_PROMPT_END_IGNORE) in Pry::Helpers::Text ([#493](pry/pry#493 (comment)))
* Fixed regression with `pry -e` when it messes the terminal ([#1387](pry/pry#1387))
* Fixed regression with space prefixes of expressions ([#1369](pry/pry#1369))
* Introduced the new way to define hooks for commands (with `Pry.hooks.add_hook("{before,after}_commandName")`). The old way is deprecated, but still supported (with `Pry.commands.{before,after}_command`) ([#651](pry/pry#651))
* Removed old API's using `Pry::Hooks.from_hash` altogether
* Removed hints on Foreman support (see [this](ddollar/foreman#536))
* Fixed support for the tee command ([#1334](pry/pry#1334))
* Implemented support for CDPATH for ShellCommand ([#1433](pry/pry#1433), [#1434](pry/pry#1434))
* `Pry::CLI.parse_options` does not start Pry anymore ([#1393](pry/pry#1393))
* The gem uses CPU-less platforms for Windows now ([#1410](pry/pry#1410))
* Add `Pry::Config::Memoization` to make it easier to implement your own `Pry::Config::Default` class.([#1503](pry/pry#1503))
* Lazy load the config defaults for `Pry.config.history` and `Pry.config.gist`.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants