-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 102
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
4.0 Sounds #50
Comments
@Porrumentzio any suggestions on what category use for Train? Should we change nature/interiors to outdoors/indoors? |
I think What do you think? And @haggen88? |
What about |
IMHO the train sound is recorded from inside the locomotive, even though it is moving outside [it is not a passing train]. |
Could be 😆 Doesn't uncivilized cultures make fire? Or is it so clear that that fire is in a chimney fireplace? |
I think that is more understandable to have an object-centred view of sounds, because our minds in current culture thought that way, not depending on the subject. |
What is civilized or uncivilized is more complex [depending on who defines the level of culture]. Perhaps another selection criterion could be according to the mobility of the environment [static - in transit]. Perhaps a category of in transit / travel is easier to understand. Maybe in the future more sounds can be added such as boat or car travel [or car traffic / soft city noise]. Some examples:
|
That's good. Something as Travel or Transport would be good I think |
What about writing down somewhere the possible future sounds? That way we could add them by groups and more organizedly |
Yeah, that looks good. But, what I don't want is the sound catalog to be very large. Currently we have 9 sounds (removing noise sounds that will be generated) witch are Probably later we can create an extended online catalog of curated sounds, and users can download those sounds inside the app. |
It has something to see the length of files. Does the app cycle through all the length of each file or does only take a piece of it? If the second case, the sound comfortability will decrease but the files could be cut. |
The app loop the whole audio file. |
Okay, so it would be good to put a limit of disk, although I don't really understand the reason. Other possibility would be to work with plugin-packages: |
Personally, I would leave this new category with only 3 sounds:
In that case there would be a catalog of 13 sounds [if pink and white noise are not eliminated]. What do you think @Porrumentzio @rafaelmardojai ? |
I'm fine about adding those. We don't want the new
I just don't want to bloat users with a lot of sounds that they are not going to use. We should ship the sounds that people expect in this kind of program.
Yeah, that is another option. But having an online catalog allows us to add new sounds without releasing new versions. |
No matter the how, it's okay :) |
I have a doubt ... does the reproduction of the current loop of the sounds have some kind of crosfade? Or are the sound clips edited in such a way as to make the sounds more "continuous" and without volume drops / silences?. |
They have not such a think AFAIK. Most sounds coincide that the beginning and ending are similar and match. I'm just gonna change the new rain clip because the loop limit is noticeable. Do you dislike that? |
When I created the app, edited some sounds to avoid gaps when looping. |
By the way, @haggen88, could you add the links to those new transport sounds please? |
It is just an appreciation. I downloaded the sounds from the web that I proposed and some have small gaps that can be improved. It's nothing really serious.
|
Thanks for the links @haggen88! The clips are edited to fit in the loop. @rafaelmardojai, what about |
|
It doesn't really matter to me. For me City is more accurate, because the streets on my tiny village doesn't sound that way, but only those of cities 😅🤣 |
You got a point. Let's go with |
Just added the new sounds to the UI. I need to get some free time to work on icons. |
I'm testing them. Test by yourself too and say if the level is okay. Seems to me that the volume is maybe a bit low, but maybe that's because before they were too loud. |
Overall sounds good to me. The only detail is that the new rain is too soft for what I'm used 😅️, but not a real issue. |
It's possible that it's due to the new has a greater range (the perception is a lower volume). We'll have to test and test since have a good level of each sound, this is more a subjective issue than a mathematic. So use it more and if in three days of use it's still too low, I'll change it :) |
Technically is fine. The issue is that I live in rain forest, and rain sometimes doesn't sounds like that 😂 |
We should so name that sound as "Non-rainforest Rain" 😉 |
The sound concept of rain varies according to the experience given by the place where you live [intensity / regularity]. I don't think there can be such a thing as a universal rain: P.S. If Blanket is able to expand the catalog or work with "add-on packages" in the future, I suggest a couple of clips as a concept:
|
Would it be possible to add Brown noise along side the Pink and White noise? |
New sounds
Nature
Travel
Noise
Icons
Sound improvements
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: