SD card detection broken in pieeprom-2024-01-15

[trejan]

Describe the bug

Bootloader screen shows SD detected when no card is present. Blank space for the CID.

Tested with two separate Pi 5 boards. No hardware attached except for power, HDMI and an active cooler.

SD detection does work with previous pieeprom-2024-01-05.

Steps to reproduce the behaviour

Flash pieeprom-2024-01-05. Plug in power + HDMI only.

Device (s)

Raspberry Pi 5

Bootloader configuration.

[all]
BOOT_UART=1
WAKE_ON_GPIO=1
POWER_OFF_ON_HALT=0
BOOT_ORDER=0xf461

System

2024/01/15 19:02:28
version f0aa07150e6f3ae21a88e5224cb9f57aba147348 (release)
timestamp 1705345348
update-time 1705672184
capabilities 0x0000007f

2024/01/15 19:02:28 
Copyright (c) 2012 Broadcom
version f0aa0715 (release) (embedded)

Bootloader logs

No response

USB boot

No response

NVMe boot

No response

Network (TFTP boot)

No response

[timg236]

Should the title say 2024/01/15 since you say "SD detection does work with previous pieeprom-2024-01-05."

Also, to confirm you saying that the "card detect is broken" rather than doesn't boot. I can see how card-detect could have changed / been broken but boot seems to work for me.

[trejan]

Should the title say 2024/01/15 since you say "SD detection does work with previous pieeprom-2024-01-05."

Oops. Cut and paste fail.

Also, to confirm you saying that the "card detect is broken" rather than doesn't boot. I can see how card-detect could have changed / been broken but boot seems to work for me.

Yes. It is just the bootloader screen showing that the card is detected when its not present. Everything works fine with a card inserted.

[timg236]

Thanks, sounds like fallout from changes support the 2712D0 GPIO register churn.

[timg236]

The changes required were a bit more invasive than expected, I've posted a pre-release. Will need review before pushing to rpi-update.

rpi-eeprom-recovery.zip

[trejan]

The changes required were a bit more invasive than expected, I've posted a pre-release.

Thanks. The SD detection in the bootloader is fixed now.

Will need review before pushing to rpi-update.

I'll have to revert to 2024-01-15 later as net install doesn't work in this debug build. Using HTTP_HOST to point it at my local server doesn't help as it still fails the signature check.

Booting from NVMe and USB is okay.

[timg236]

The changes required were a bit more invasive than expected, I've posted a pre-release.

Thanks. The SD detection in the bootloader is fixed now.

Will need review before pushing to rpi-update.

I'll have to revert to 2024-01-15 later as net install doesn't work in this debug build. Using HTTP_HOST to point it at my local server doesn't help as it still fails the signature check.

Booting from NVMe and USB is okay.

Thanks. I think net-install was broken in the local build. Will push out a proper fix soon.

[timg236]

Fix should now be available in rpi-update

[trejan]

Yep. SD card detection and net install are both working with this new version. Thanks.

[timg236]

Deleted off topic comments and locking since OP verified as fixed.

[pelwell]

(Hint: rpi-update is not the same as rpi-eeprom-update)