Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Github Copilot integration with RStudio #10148

Closed
kojix2 opened this issue Nov 28, 2021 · 78 comments
Closed

Github Copilot integration with RStudio #10148

kojix2 opened this issue Nov 28, 2021 · 78 comments
Assignees
Labels
copilot Integration with GitHub Copilot enhancement vcs Version control such as git and svn/subversion

Comments

@kojix2
Copy link

kojix2 commented Nov 28, 2021

Hi!

Are there any plans to make Github Copilot available in RStudio?

RStudio is definitely a great development environment. It's just a pity that Copilot is not available.
I've been using Copilot with the Ruby language for the past 1-2 weeks and I'm convinced that I can't imagine programming without an aid like Copilot for the next decade.

I found several threads in the community mentioning copilot, but they were all closed.

@ronblum
Copy link
Contributor

ronblum commented Nov 29, 2021

@kojix2 Thank you for the suggestion! I'm not aware of current plans to support, but we'll keep this in mind for consideration. In the meantime, FWIW, one of the ways to increase likelihood of new enhancements is to get more thumbs-ups in the original post (there's one already).

@ronblum ronblum added enhancement vcs Version control such as git and svn/subversion labels Nov 29, 2021
@kojix2
Copy link
Author

kojix2 commented Nov 30, 2021

I found two posts in the discussion section of github/feedback requesting a Copilot for RStudio.

@github-actions
Copy link

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs, per https://github.com/rstudio/rstudio/wiki/Issue-Grooming. Thank you for your contributions.

@github-actions github-actions bot added the stale Issues which have been closed automatically due to inactivitiy. label May 30, 2022
@mikebessuille mikebessuille removed the stale Issues which have been closed automatically due to inactivitiy. label May 31, 2022
@asolisc-gbm
Copy link

Man, we really need this! Especially now that it's been released to all developers!

@hwangQ
Copy link

hwangQ commented Jun 24, 2022

Yes, it would be really great if we can use the copliot in R studio.

@mokdur
Copy link

mokdur commented Jul 7, 2022

R is a great language and it definitely deserves more attention from copilot developers.

@JimKChi
Copy link

JimKChi commented Jul 10, 2022

Bring it on!

@sweetarts
Copy link

Totally want this. Stats community (Python and R) both need representation

@DataStrategist
Copy link

+1. Enabling copilot through RStudio would be great for the community, but there's another arguably more important strategic reason. If code suggestions "become a thing" that changes how we code forever (still to be seen, but possible), it behooves the R community to write a bunch of R code using copilot (and whatever else may come) to improve the prediction accuracy.

One of R's strengths vs python is that it's easy to use, what w/ the tidyverse, better documentation/examples, less brittle in terms of R/package versions etc. It's just "easier". But if we can add code suggestions to Python and R falls behind because it's not widely implemented, and when it is, the predictions suck... I think we might see a shift to where people think Python is easier to use.

I don't want to conflate R with RStudio, but I do think it's safe to say that RStudio is one of the most popular IDEs for R, and thus provides a solid steer to the whole community.

@hangangmagazine
Copy link

+1. Enabling copilot through RStudio would be great for the community, but there's another arguably more important strategic reason. If code suggestions "become a thing" that changes how we code forever (still to be seen, but possible), it behooves the R community to write a bunch of R code using copilot (and whatever else may come) to improve the prediction accuracy.

One of R's strengths vs python is that it's easy to use, what w/ the tidyverse, better documentation/examples, less brittle in terms of R/package versions etc. It's just "easier". But if we can add code suggestions to Python and R falls behind because it's not widely implemented, and when it is, the predictions suck... I think we might see a shift to where people think Python is easier to use.

I don't want to conflate R with RStudio, but I do think it's safe to say that RStudio is one of the most popular IDEs for R, and thus provides a solid steer to the whole community.

Some really interesting points. I agree having Rstudio only without Copilot is not a bad problem to have. It's much easier to learn and use for ad hoc analyses python. I don't use R for anything production.

I work as a consultant and like to use it to explore and validate or rule out theories among the team ad hoc.

@DataStrategist
Copy link

DataStrategist commented Jul 21, 2022

Just to clarify, that isn't my point at all... I, like many others, write R code in production all the time. But that's not the point of this post, we are discussing Copilot integration with RStudio.

@jmcphers
Copy link
Member

I investigated this a little yesterday, and I'm somewhat skeptical it can be done on our end. Copilot is proprietary Microsoft technology, and all of the existing editor extensions are written by Microsoft. There is no documentation or API that would permit us to write our own Copilot integration.

There are third-party Copilot extensions available, but they work by ahem "borrowing" binaries from the official extensions (see, for example: https://github.com/zerolfx/copilot.el ) This is almost certainly contrary to Copilot's licensing terms.

So we would need permission from Microsoft to do this, and if granted permission would also need access to their internal APIs to develop our own client or borrow one of theirs. Not insurmountable, probably, but also not a weekend project.

@lbeiby
Copy link

lbeiby commented Aug 30, 2022

How's about Tabnine @jmcphers

@DataStrategist
Copy link

Also... if we can't use Copilot, maybe we can use codex, which is the software underlying Copilot? They say they are looking for partnerships with companies.

@csqr
Copy link

csqr commented Sep 2, 2022

Please do it, integrating Copilot with RStudio would be awesome.

@VsedanoVargas
Copy link

Hi!

Are there any plans to make Github Copilot available in RStudio?

RStudio is definitely a great development environment. It's just a pity that Copilot is not available. I've been using Copilot with the Ruby language for the past 1-2 weeks and I'm convinced that I can't imagine programming without an aid like Copilot for the next decade.

I found several threads in the community mentioning copilot, but they were all closed.

Hola, hasta ahora no he oido ni se de alguna intención de implementar copilot en Rstudio, por ello es que uso intellij idea para trabajar con r, la integración con copilot es la mejor y el trabajo se pontencia a miles; desde que he migrado a intellij para trabajar con R he encontrado gran cantidad de ventajas, practicamente he dejado de lado a rstudio, en serio te recomiendo usar intellij u otra IDE como puede ser VS code.

@ntluong95
Copy link

This feature is very much needed

@CherryQii
Copy link

R need it and deserve it!

@dgordonf
Copy link

I come back to this at least once every two weeks hoping to see a glimpse of an update. I am running data science tasks in Python way more now specifically because VSCode has CoPilot and RStudio does not.

@derek-corcoran-barrios
Copy link

I also think this is very needed

@hashiromer
Copy link

Any update on this?

@wolass
Copy link

wolass commented Nov 25, 2022

It is technically possible...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZRkc3gVeaBI

Would be nice if R studio could match the capabilities of other IDEs as it is our preffered one

@DataStrategist
Copy link

@wolass the problem isn't R. Read the discussion above.

@hashiromer
Copy link

@wolass

I know that we can use it inside visual studio code, but I would prefer to use it inside R Studio.

@higgi13425
Copy link

try the {gpttools} package https://github.com/JamesHWade/gpttools

@ronblum ronblum added the copilot Integration with GitHub Copilot label Jun 30, 2023
@kevinushey
Copy link
Contributor

Any idea where the differences come from? More broadly, I'd imagine Rstudio can turn this into its advantage as my sense is that VSCode has zero awareness of functions in scope but not in code - and this is probably something Rstudio can feed in.

This seems likely. Currently, RStudio is only synchronizing the files currently open with the Copilot instance -- we should probably consider whether we could synchronize other project R files.

@ronblum
Copy link
Contributor

ronblum commented Jul 13, 2023

Hey all! Based on upvotes, this request is more popular than the next five requests combined. As @kevinushey mentioned above, the integration between RStudio and GitHub Copilot is now available. It's still in development and QA, but if you're eager to try It out, check out the latest Desert Sunflower daily builds at dailies.rstudio.com. Please note that these builds are meant for test and development purposes only, not production.

If you find a bug or have an enhancement request, please open a new issue. If you'd like to first check if it's already a known issue, you can search for all issues with the copilot label. We're glad to get these if you're very experienced with Copilot, a novice, or anywhere in between.

You can take advantage of Copilot in RStudio by turning it on with Tools -> Global Options -> Copilot -> Enable Github Copilot

copilot

@Ljie03
Copy link

Ljie03 commented Jul 24, 2023

Hello, due to an oversight, I logged into an account without obtaining copilot authorization, and at this moment, I am unable to log out of the account.
image

大家好!根据赞成票,此请求比接下来的五个请求的总和更受欢迎。如上所述,RStudio 和 GitHub Copilot 之间的集成现已可用。它仍在开发和QA中,但如果您渴望尝试一下,请在 dailies.rstudio.com 查看最新的沙漠向日葵每日版本。请注意,这些构建仅用于测试和开发目的,而不是生产目的。

如果您发现错误或有增强请求,请打开一个新问题。如果您想先检查它是否已经是已知问题,可以使用标签搜索所有问题。如果您非常有经验的Copilot,新手或介于两者之间的任何地方,我们很高兴获得这些。

您可以在 RStudio 中利用 Copilot,方法是通过以下方式打开它Tools -> Global Options -> Copilot -> Enable Github Copilot

副驾驶员

@truenomad
Copy link

I have the exact same issue as @Ljie03. Not sure how to logout or fix this issue.

At the bottom of my script, R is also telling me I am not signed in...
Screenshot 2023-07-24 at 14 06 12

@ronblum
Copy link
Contributor

ronblum commented Jul 24, 2023

@Ljie03 and @truenomad Can you please open a new issue for this? Thanks!

@ronblum ronblum closed this as completed Jul 24, 2023
@kojix2
Copy link
Author

kojix2 commented Jul 25, 2023

Dear @ronblum and @kevinushey, thank you for supporting Copilot.
And to everyone in this thread, I had no idea the issue I opened casually would receive so much support.
I tried the daily build the other day and confirmed that Copilot is working.
I'm looking forward to seeing Copilot in the stable version.

@slodge
Copy link
Contributor

slodge commented Aug 2, 2023

Excited about trying this.

The github account I was using doesn't yet have CoPilot - which caused this spinner to spin forever:

image

VS Code gives a better error:
image

Don't know if this is worth reporting as an issue?

@ronblum
Copy link
Contributor

ronblum commented Aug 2, 2023

@slodge By all means, please do!

By the way, if you get caught in this state, that little "Cancel" to the right of "Authenticating" will cancel the authentication so that you can get the IDE back. We've got issue #13439 to make it clearer.

@slodge
Copy link
Contributor

slodge commented Aug 2, 2023

Thanks - linking #13444 13444

@fgashakamba
Copy link

I have already switched to VS Code for all my coding activities. I do all my coding in VS Code and when the script is working, I copy/paste the code into RStudio for project management and stuff. Having GitHub Copilot integration in RStudio would be a boon. Please make it happen. Pleeeeeease!!!!

@ronblum
Copy link
Contributor

ronblum commented Sep 18, 2023

@fgashakamba Integration with GitHub Copilot is available in the upcoming release of RStudio Desktop on a preview basis #10148 (comment), and it will be availble in RStudio Server in a future release.

@F-Chalreo
Copy link

Hello, I am very glad for the integration, I tested on the dev version and thought it was really useful. Just a question, do we have an estimate on when the next release of RStudio is coming, and what does "preview basis" mean?

Again, thanks!

@fgashakamba
Copy link

@fgashakamba Integration with GitHub Copilot is available in the upcoming release of RStudio Desktop on a preview basis #10148 (comment), and it will be availble in RStudio Server in a future release.

I have installed the nightly build and can confirm that Copilot is working fine. Thank you for the developers.
The only glitch I have encountered with this build of RStudio on Windows 10/11 is that when you open the data viewer in a separate window, the new window hangs with an endless spinner. The only way to close it is to delete the RStudio folder in the AppData directory.

@kevinushey
Copy link
Contributor

The only glitch I have encountered with this build of RStudio on Windows 10/11 is that when you open the data viewer in a separate window, the new window hangs with an endless spinner. The only way to close it is to delete the RStudio folder in the AppData directory.

I believe this should already be resolved in the latest daily builds; can you test and confirm? If not, please file a new issue -- thanks!

@ilyamusabirov
Copy link

I installed v2023.09.0+463 rstudio server build but can't find information on how to enable copilot server-wide. Does anyone know? Thanks so much to the developers!

@slodge-work
Copy link

slodge-work commented Oct 12, 2023

I installed v2023.09.0+463 rstudio server build but can't find information on how to enable copilot server-wide. Does anyone know? Thanks so much to the developers!

I think it's desktop only for now - https://docs.posit.co/ide/user/ide/guide/tools/copilot.html

I take that back... https://docs.posit.co/ide/user/ide/guide/tools/copilot.html says it should work I think 👍

Try the steps:

Enable GitHub Copilot integration by adding copilot-enabled=1 to the /etc/rstudio/rsession.conf

from #13718 - mentioned in copilot_enabled but I can't find any other info on it...

@alanpaulkwan
Copy link

No, not true. If youre running linux, go to the rsession. In Ubuntu on my system it's /etc/rstudio/rsession.conf

# R Session Configuration File
copilot-enabled=1

sudo rstudio-server restart

@slodge
Copy link
Contributor

slodge commented Oct 12, 2023

No, not true. If youre running linux, go to the rsession. In Ubuntu on my system it's /etc/rstudio/rsession.conf

# R Session Configuration File
copilot-enabled=1

sudo rstudio-server restart

Thanks - had already corrected - see above :)

@tgjohnst
Copy link

Awesome to see the progress here! I was able to get copilot enabled in the latest Rstudio Server release (v2023.09.0+463), and it's successfully completing code when editing .R scripts. However, I'm not seeing any completions when working on code blocks in .rmd or .qmd files. Is this intended behavior, or am I missing a setting somewhere?

@ronblum
Copy link
Contributor

ronblum commented Oct 16, 2023

@tgjohnst There shouldn't be any more settings needed. What are you seeing at the bottom of the editor windows after clicking on it? Such as
completion
or
no_completion

@tgjohnst
Copy link

@ronblum I very briefly see Waiting for completions and then No completions available when working in Rmd or Qmd - completions load just fine when working in Rscripts. All three files are in the same project/directory. Screenshots below.

image image image

@ronblum
Copy link
Contributor

ronblum commented Oct 16, 2023

In the R Markdown and Quarto files, what happens if you hit Enter/Return and start typing something? I always like to start with libr which will kick off both Copilot suggestion and autocompletion, or something like # Create a function that.

Also, switch to source mode. Visual mode is misleading: It's not currently providing suggestions (#13427).

@tgjohnst
Copy link

@ronblum thanks for linking that other issue - the visual mode issue was the culprit here. Switching to source mode resulted in suggestions working fine within my quarto notebook.

@rafaelcardosoargus
Copy link

Is there a way to set a short cut in RStudio to toggle on/off Github Copilot? Copilot is great, but sometimes it's quite annoying when I have to just stare at my code while thinking and then Copilot just shows an entire chunk of code where I was reading the original code, making it very difficult to work with. That functionality would be way better than having to click Tools -> Globla options -> Copilot -> Enable/Disable Copilot or to use the Command Palette Ctrl+Shift+P, search for “Enable GitHub Copilot” and then uncheck “Enable GitHub Copilot”.

@slodge
Copy link
Contributor

slodge commented Nov 21, 2023

Is there a way to set a short cut in RStudio to toggle on/off Github Copilot? Copilot is great, but sometimes it's quite annoying when I have to just stare at my code while thinking and then Copilot just shows an entire chunk of code where I was reading the original code, making it very difficult to work with. That functionality would be way better than having to click Tools -> Globla options -> Copilot -> Enable/Disable Copilot or to use the Command Palette Ctrl+Shift+P, search for “Enable GitHub Copilot” and then uncheck “Enable GitHub Copilot”.

We can set up our own shortcuts using Tools->Modify Keyboard Shortcuts... but I don't think there's a convenient "toggle copilot" command to assign there currently:
image

@rafaelcardosoargus
Copy link

Is there a way to set a short cut in RStudio to toggle on/off Github Copilot? Copilot is great, but sometimes it's quite annoying when I have to just stare at my code while thinking and then Copilot just shows an entire chunk of code where I was reading the original code, making it very difficult to work with. That functionality would be way better than having to click Tools -> Globla options -> Copilot -> Enable/Disable Copilot or to use the Command Palette Ctrl+Shift+P, search for “Enable GitHub Copilot” and then uncheck “Enable GitHub Copilot”.

We can set up our own shortcuts using Tools->Modify Keyboard Shortcuts... but I don't think there's a convenient "toggle copilot" command to assign there currently: image

Yeah I tried to do that with the "Copilot: Request Completions" command, but didn't get the result.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
copilot Integration with GitHub Copilot enhancement vcs Version control such as git and svn/subversion
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests