Consider alternate (browser friendly) buffer

[rolanday]

Hello! :-) I'd love to be able to use this module in my SvelteKit app, but node:buffer dep is not something I've been able to workaround via Vite polyfill (same issue for other frameworks like Nextjs as well).

Have or can you consider alt buffer impl that is browser friendly? Or, any tips on configuring for use in SvelteKit, Vue, Nextjs, etc?

Thanks!

[sindresorhus]

Ideally, all code should be using Uint8Array instead of Buffer, but there's just too much Node.js code that depends on Buffer.

If anyone wants to work on this, the first task would be to convert the dependencies of file-type to use Uint8Array instead of Buffer.

[Borewit]

That work has started to some extend Borewit/token-types#246, but yet there is much more work to do.

[volarname]

+1
this library really needs a browser version without node and webpack deps
something like fromFile(file: File)
because file.mimeType doesnt seems to work properly all times

[Borewit]

+1 this library really needs a browser version without node and webpack deps something like fromFile(file: File) because file.mimeType doesnt seems to work properly all times

That function already exist @volarname : fileTypeFromBlob(blob). Where you can pass you file as blob, since File inherits from Blob.

[akkie]

+1 this library really needs a browser version without node and webpack deps something like fromFile(file: File) because file.mimeType doesnt seems to work properly all times

That function already exist @volarname : fileTypeFromBlob(blob). Where you can pass you file as blob, since File inherits from Blob.

Yes, but it doesn't work in modern frameworks like SvelteKit as example. It uses vite under the hood and shows the warnings:

Module "node:buffer" has been externalized for browser compatibility. Cannot access "node:buffer.Buffer" in client code.

[Borewit]

This module has been primary written for Node.js. It does depend on Buffer. There is browser friendly buffer module available, but you depend on your framework how easy that is to fit it in.
There is not much more we can do, as these core dependencies are not shared between browser and Node.js.

[sindresorhus]

https://sindresorhus.com/blog/goodbye-nodejs-buffer

[Borewit]

https://sindresorhus.com/blog/goodbye-nodejs-buffer

Interesting!, very nice guidance. I will give it try (starting with the dependent modules first).

[Borewit]

It is not only node:buffer file-type depends on, also safe-buffer

graph TD;
    FT-->S
    FT(file-type)-->RWNS(readable-web-to-node-stream)
    S(strtok3)-->P(peek-readable)
    S(strtok3)-->TO("@tokenizer/token")
    TY(token-types)-->TO
    TY-->IE("ieee754")
    FT-->TY
    TY-->NB(node:buffer)
    RWNS-->RS(readable-stream)
    RS-->SD(string_decoder)
    SD-->SB(safe-buffer)
    RS-->UD(util-deprecate)
    RS-->I(inherits)
    style NB fill:#F88,stroke:#A44
    style SB fill:#F88,stroke:#A44
    style SD fill:#CCC,stroke:#888
    style IE fill:#CCC,stroke:#888
    style UD fill:#CCC,stroke:#888
    style I fill:#CCC,stroke:#888

[Borewit]

I still don't see a good alternative for the string encoding node:buffer supports: ascii, utf8, utf-8, utf16le, ucs2, ucs-2, base64, base64url, latin1, binary, hex;

e.g.:

Buffer.from(uint8Array).toString(encoding);

[Songkeys]

I still don't see a good alternative for the string encoding node:buffer supports: ascii, utf8, utf-8, utf16le, ucs2, ucs-2, base64, base64url, latin1, binary, hex;

I think this library can help? https://github.com/sindresorhus/uint8array-extras

I can see there are methods to hex, string, base64. We have to construct every encoding method from sketch though.

[SgtPooki]

i've got a working browser-consumable fork at https://github.com/sgtpooki/file-type, but stream and file support has been disabled for now (since I don't need it for my use-case). All tests for fileTypeFromBuffer are passing.

[andrewbrennanfr]

Hi 👋 Facing similar issues after upgrading from a very old fork of this lib.
I feel like I've read a 101 different issues/comments/responses & ultimately keeping ending up in the same situation.

So just to be crystal clear - this lib can't be used without polyfiling node:buffer right? (in my case with something like this)
There's no "out-of-the-box" way to use this on the client-side?

[mgcrea]

Encountering this while playing with Cloudflare workers, would be nice for fileTypeFromStream to also handle ReadableStream, when I try to pass one (from File.stream()) I get Error: Expected an instance of stream.Readable.